Casa Mezcal Flavors of Mexico

Our waiter was super friendly and helpful with answering all of our questions. Everyone enjoyed their food. My dish was really great but after trying the birria tacos from my sister I did regret not getting them myself 🤣🤣 one bite and I thought I died and went to heaven. Wow.. so flavorful and juicy. I did enjoy my burrito very much as well but was really jealous of those birria tacos 🤣🤣 We'll definitely be back!!

Food is delicious and for a very good price! Dishes are big, menu has different options and the service was incredibly fast. Our waiter was very kind and took good care of us. I also noticed it has a nice bar so if the food was delicious I can’t imagine their cocktails and margaritas :)

I've been trying to get my boyfriend to go here since they opened. He's not a big fan of Mexican food. I love it. Well last night for my birthday he took me here for dinner..it was great food, awesome service and the fastest I've ever seen..The host sat us at our table gave us our menus, the server was placing chips n salsa on our table within seconds. We told him what we wanted to drink..we were ready to place our order when he brought our drinks. Within 5-10 minutes are food was being served. I kid you not that is the fastest service I've ever had..The food was delicious. We definitely will be back again..loved the atmosphere as well. Our server was friendly checked on us a couple of times or looked at our table when he walked by.

My son & I went on November 3rd, my 1st time, & it was cool! The food was so good, the waiter(Mr. Antonio) was very attentive, I enjoyed his smile& his kind nature! We like this waiter, because he added 2 r experience! We would definitely recommend this place 2 ever1! They also have Horchata, the best drink there is! It's so much better than pop!

First time there. Fun atmosphere and our server was very very helpful and friendly and fast! Gave the food 4 stars as it was a tad over cooked but still very flavorful. Glad we went!

My wife and I were greeted enthusiastically and seated immediately. We enjoyed chips and salsa while we previewed the menu. Our server was friendly and enthusiastic, as well. The food was very good. My wife thought it was "standard" and nothing special, but I thought it was better than most. The only flaw in our dining experience was that they had two different musical sources playing at the same time. When I called it out I was given excuses "well they're in the kitchen, so...". And I was told that they've had that complaint before. I asked if they could turn one of them off as we found it unsettling to have two different songs blaring at the same time. But nothing was done about it. Regardless of the friendliness and efficiency of the staff, and the quality of the food, this oversight is what will keep us from returning. A bit of background music helps to elevate the atmosphere, but two different songs playing at the same time is disturbing. It seems to me that management would have noticed and made corrections, especially after it was called out. Good food, great service, terrible atmosphere. Sorry. (I must point out that our server/waitress was outstanding!)

Update 01-11-24: Been awhile since we have reviewed. Why? 5 ⭐ ⭐ ⭐ ⭐ ⭐ and nothing has changed! If you've been here, you know. If you haven't, you must! I'm adding a few pics to the mix for my update today. Man I love this end of town! Great food, super service. Update: We are becoming regulars. Our servers so far have been Maddy, Tanya and Victor. They are so good, and the food is great, but it is the servers that bring us back. Between Casa and Maybe Baby, we eat on this end of town a lot! Mmmm... Made our second visit. Party of 13 served by Maddy only! She got everything correct and ran full speed. Wow! Everyone in our group said the same thing... Awesome. Maddy is incredible. Did see a negative review saying peppers and onions weren't cooked. Ha! Clearly can see in the pic the onions are caramelized pretty nicely... Sheesh My first review as they were just opening got a very good 4 ⭐: New, different, very busy. I have a feeling my rating will go up. Food was good, server was great. We will be going back. Nice addition to the area!!!

If you like true great tasting Mexican food this place is for you. Very friendly and fair prices. You won't leave hungry.

We were visiting a cousin in Bath New York and decided to go out for a Sunday lunch. She suggested Casa Mezcal. Being a big fan of tequila they had me at Mezcal lol! The inside was bright and had the typical colorful Mexican decor. We were seated right away and the waitress came over with water and chips and salsa, which were excellent. I ordered the organic margarita which is made fresh, and our cousin ordered the house Margarita. Both were excellent! My wife and I ordered the Fajitas Texana- which have chicken steak and shrimp in the usual sizzling dish. I think our food took like five minutes to come out! And it was excellent. So with great food and friendly service, I highly recommend Casa Mezcal. I hear they have one in Painted Post and Ithaca and maybe another one. I'll have to check them out when I'm in those areas as well.

I went here with my wife to celebrate her birthday. It was late afternoon so it was not crowded and was very clean and festive inside. Our waitress was friendly and attentive. I ordered the mezcal shrimp tacos and my wife ordered the burrito Diablo. She requested the hot sauce on the side in case it was too spicy. The food was delicious. For dessert we shared the tres Leches. We will be back.

Really solid Mexican food. Delicious, huge portions, and absolutely reasonable prices. We shared the Nachos Locos and it was outstanding. The horchata was terrific - they put real bits of cinnamon bark into it! Also, our server was excellent - totally on top of everything we needed and seemed genuinely happy to help. Very cool ambiance with brightly colored walls. Highly recommend if you find yourself in the area (as we did) and need to eat!

Our food was absolutely delicious and more importantly, Amanda, our server was the greatest. Our order was taken right away. Our food came out quickly and all our needs were met while we enjoyed the ambience..

Visiting family before Christmas Eve, they brought me to Casa Mezcal for dinner after a busy day and we had a great experience! We arrived Saturday, the night before Christmas Eve 2023, around 6pm to a pretty full parking lot, albeit I still managed to take a parking spot right next to the entrance. Once inside, we were greeted by a hostess who managed to get us seated at a booth right away. Inside was nothing too fancy, but it felt authentic and there was plenty of tables, booths and many of them were filled already. Our waitress was a friendly, courteous young woman who brought over a basket of warm tortilla chips and salsa, all complimentary, and mini-plates to snack on as we browsed the menu. We were starving so we destroyed the first basket pretty quick but she was ready with another basket. She was fun conversation and fun to banter with. After we got our drinks and had time to read over the menu, we ordered our dinners. It did not take too long at all for the food to arrive. For dinner, I ordered their Burrito Santa Fé- a burrito stuffed with grilled chicken, steak, rice, beans, crispy tortilla strips and grilled onions, smothered with their cheesy guajillo sauce and garnished with sour cream, cilantro, corn, and black beans. It says right on the menu but this is definitely a knife and fork burrito! This was excellent and plenty filling. Nothing about the burrito stood out to me but still very good. Maybe next time I would ask for a bit more "heat" to it. The quantity of food and the price were excellent. All-in-all, I really enjoyed Casa Mezcal! Friendly staff, great food, nice portions, at reasonable prices. If/when I am back in Bath, I would like to come back here again!

We chose to dine at this popular Mexican restaurant on a Saturday night and, though busy, we were immediately seated. A server provided complimentary chips and a salsa along with menus. My wife and I each chose enchiladas de casa, a trio of enchiladas with small sides of refried beans and rice. My wife chose chicken while mine was adobo beef. Each was light on the protein and the meal in general a bit of a disappointment.

Can't believe how good this is! The Nachos Locos was amazing. Thanks for the full belly.

There is no better Mexican restaurant north of the border! I've been twice and I can't wait to go again! The food is amazing, the prices are reasonable and the service is great.

Great menu. Easy to walk in and be seated. Clean and colorful space. I try something new each time I go and always end our visit with Flan. There aren't any steps to get into the building or dining rooms but the front doors are a little heavy just as a heads up!

excellent food and great service......The selection of food is fantastic and everyone is very polite and helpful and the restaurant had beautiful colorful decor.

This place is fun! Drinks were awesome. Service was super friendly and the food was good Tex Mex. Their tomatillo sauce on my enchiladas was sooo good. Highly recommend for a Mexican night out.

Close your eyes until you get inside. You are in Mexico . Nachos & Salsa, Authentic Mexican dishes & desserts. Casa Mezcal serves the Biggest and Best Margaritas anywhere. Too many South of the Border Tequilas to count. Don't speak Spanish? Don't worry - Madie or many of the Servers do! They'll be your interpreters and describe the mouth watering entrees. You might even learn some Spanish while you're there. 5 Stars

Love the food, staff, and the vibe, Bar area is great for dinner. We have been eating there for years. We have even picked up appetizers for social gatherings at our house.

Authentic Mexican! Fabulous, try the Sante Fe! Quick and friendly. Lots of choices, too!

Located just south of Hammondsport, Casa Mezcal has a full lineup of traditional Mexican-American food. The menu appears to be authentically made up of food and drink and the staff appeared to be authentic Mexicans, but I'll await later reviewers' opinions. I can assure you the food is authentically good when we eat here and the parking lot is authentically full whenever we go by, so I'm not concerned with how it compares with what you buy in California. Dinner starts off with house-made chips with very good salsa. If you've ever been to any Mexican-American restaurant you know the rest. Very good food at very good prices, served very efficiently.

I've eaten there 6 or 8 times. Always great food, great service. I recommend the mariscada, a seafood stew.

Found this place on Yelp, sadly it's other web presence is weak, but what we saw we were drawn to. We tried to call to see about reservations, but kept getting busy signal. But we went on. Do know that we are snobs about Latin foods. We are NOT fans of most of what's available around here. This place is located in an old Pizza Hut building- pretty cool rehab! We got there about 430pm. Lots of cars in the lot- we were worried. Happily the place had some empty tables and booths, but not for long. Soon people lined up waiting for a table. Also a large bar, with people sitting and dining there. The beer and cocktail list was very impressive! Loved the margarita flights - three small tastings of their amazing cocktails. Ordered the "street fries" to start. Wonderful! Rich, and full of flavor. Definitely a sharing experience. The burritos and tamales were great! I'm a Pazole fiend. It was good, I've had better and a lot worse! Over all a GREAT place to dine in the Pen Yan area- definitely will go back. Close to amazing views of the Finger Lakes area. Go! You will NOT regret it.

New to town and this has been the best experience so far. The atmosphere was amazing, staff was top-notch!!! Food, was beyond expectations! Highly recommend. The icing on the cake was the adorable changing station in the women's room. Bravo!!

Food is fabulous! Everything is delicious, fresh, flavored with Mexican seasoning and really really delicious!!! Portions are very huge! Healthy for kids! We have ordered seafood fajitas, burrito, taco salad, street tacos and much more!

We asked around and locals seem to rave about this place. It was pretty busy around 530 but we got a seat immediately. As a California native and now an Albany transplant this is not real Mexican food not is it even tasty. NY in general suffers from poor representations of Mexican food so it may be good to you but it's not even close to real TexMex.

Food is awesome . I highly recommend Arroz Con Pollo. I can't remember the last time I had such great fast service. Our waiter was on point.

The food is terrible. Out of the 3 items we ordered we sent 2 back because they were cold. The server was lovely but the manager couldn't be bothered by a table sending multiple items back. Wine selection is also bad. Lighting and decor are like a cafeteria. Genuinely bad experience.

Service was nice and quick. A bit too quick if you expected fresh Mexican. The salsa tasted more like spicy spaghetti sauce. We ordered Tacos El Pastore and Sante Fe Burrito. The tacos el pastore was missing the pineapple and lacked flavor. The Sante Fe Burrito was dry and the steak was clearly reheated and old.

I was passing through the area and was happy to find a Mexican restaurant with good reviews. The food was delicious and the service was great! I accidentally left something behind at my table and when I called the next day, it was there waiting for me. Since I was out-of-state by then, the manager happily mailed it back to me! I am very grateful for an overall great experience!! I will definitely return.

I had the Chori Pollo and it was A Mazing! Probably some of the best Mexican flavor I've had in upstate NY. I would come back just for this dish. The beans and rice were not great. The corn tortillas were hot and steamy fresh. The service was excellent. Really don't know why it's a single use only men's room for as large a restaurant as it is. Oh! And the devil's hot sauce! Ask for that. The spice is under the radar overall, so that sauce kicked it up a notch.

We have been here three times. The food is better at the Fiesta Brava on Market Street in Corning--but this is close for casual. The last two times have been mediocre--and leaning to 'trendy' with presentation and delivery. Consider it eye candy over substance. But it's close to home. I took a photo of the wait staff. We were declined service and forced to leave the establishment. Not good. Not a happy place to go. Attached is the phone photo that got us thrown out. And really, the food is rather bland. Look to Corning...

Food was good. Service was ok, but required aggressive requests to gain attention. Strong smell of cleaning fluids was annoying. I would repeat since only restaurant open on Sunday and foot was tasty. Food delivery was quick!. Nothing more to add. Ok no more to add. Ok no more to add. Why cannot I end this review? ??!!!

Great food. Super nice people. Always a good time. No wonder their parking lot is always packed!

Food was delivered quickly and very tasty. Service was right on point and very good. Restaurant was clean. Atmosphere was very welcoming with the music playing, sort of felt real festive. Will we return, sure we will.

Worth a stop if looking for reasonably priced Mexican when vacationing by Keuka Lake. Expect a wait at peak times as no reservations are taken. There are a variety of margaritas to chose from, along with a decent selection of tequila and mezcals. Staff is friendly and efficient.

This place has amazing food and amazing service, the employees are very kind and helpful and speedy. I normally don't like mexican food but i find myself always excited to go here! the only thing i would change is that when you first walk in there is a strong bleach smell that is very off putting, and i have smelled it every time i've gone, but once you get into the restaurant beyond that it is a great experience. i highly recommend this place!!

The meal and the service we had was fine. I've had better Mexican (we winter in Tucson), but I've had worse. Our server was attentive and pleasant. I rarely leave a restaurant miffed, but I was tonight. I ordered a bottle of Ithaca Brewing "Flower Power" which I have really enjoyed for years. I also know when a beer has turned "skunky." With the beer poured into a glass I realized after about 3 sips that it had turned bad. I told this to our server who came back a few minutes later to tell me that the bartender told her the beer had just come in yesterday. I said I didn't know if it was old or had been in the sun too long, but that it was definitely skunky. I assumed the beer wouldn't show up on our bill. But it did. And when I showed it to our server, she again went back to consult with the bartender. When she returned she said the beer had been discounted. I asked if $6.50 showed the discount. Apparently, she said. It's a minor issue about the total bill price, but I will remember for a long time the lack of customer respect shown by the bartender.

Wonderful food. Party of six and we all loved what we ordered. Great atmosphere and fast service.

Solid Mexican food and and margs in southern NY??? Who woulda' thought? Found this place through Yelp search when needing a good meal after a day of driving, since the guy at the hotel had zero suggestions on where to get a bite to eat that wasn't fast food or delivery...SO glad I decided to take a chance on it. Parking lot was full when I arrived (a good sign), but they were able to seat me right away. Efficient, competent, friendly servers; really tasty mezcal margarita and solid chicken mole enchiladas. Seems like the options for seated dining in Bath/Hammondsport area on a Monday night are pretty slim, but I would wholeheartedly recommend Casa Mezcal any day of the week!

Second time here and it's just so good! Tortilla chips are fresh, salsa is delicious. Street tacos rock. The steak was excellent but the chicken even better! Great beans and plate presentation. Great Service and fast! Family owned and the place feels like you went to Mexico for your meal. Highly recommend!

I have now been 3 times and all 3 times they have missed something on the order/made it incorrectly. Was it still good? Yes. Service is fairly good but be prepared for lack of English further causing misunderstandings.