Casanita

Great find! Right across from our hotel. Great menu and specials. Amazing food. Waitress was very efficient but not very friendly. Overall 5*.

The server and a local wine was great but the food only good and wasn't fantastic as one would expect from an awarded restaurant. Presentation wasn't really anything special. We really wanted to be wowed but it was lack luster. I will add that the service was top drawer and quite exceptional though and the prices were responsible.

We passed her by accident and it was a great discovery. Service was very friendly, we felt very welcomed. Food was good albeit a bit expensive for the portions. It’s definitely on the pricier side but the experience was nice. Specialty was fish, and ingredients seemed fresh. Desserts were nice too. Price to quality ratio is a bit too high.

While the restaurant is beautiful and service was amazing, the food was barely average and seriously overpriced. I ordered a prawn pasta and it was quite disappointing. The flatbread wasn’t great either. The complementary bread, however, was nice. Unfortunately, I would not eat here again.

We were hoping for a table in the garden terrace but were placed in side room - which overlooked the moped scooter parking. Zero atmosphere. The food was pretty expensive and not remarkable. My husband had bolognaise pasta, which he said was cold and only 6 out of 19 for taste. I had sea bass - tiny portion and the ‘roasted’ tomato accompaniment was plain, cold tomato. We were charged 8 euros for bread we didn’t ask for. This was our first night in Formentera, having only arrived on the island hotel at 9pm!! Otherwise I would have complained and refused to pay full cost - VERY expensive for mediocre experience. We were Not impressed.

Really good Italian restaurant. Good variety of menu with some interesting options (I liked the tuna tartar). Service is fast and super kind. I was positively surprised by the level of service. Coming to the bill, it was also ok. We know that Formentera is pricy, but this place in on average so it really worth. Will come back for sure!

We had a lovely dinner at Casanita. The food was great and the staff were very friendly. The Creme Brulée dessert is a must try! It's the best Cremé Brulée I've ever had!!!

Amazing staff but the food just wasn’t good enough. Sadly one of the pasta dishes was off (which they confirmed) and I was very sick later. Such a shame as the menu and waiters were so lovely. Enjoyed the octopus Ragu though even though I’m currently reliving it.

I guess this Italians haven't started using Yelp yet. I was surprised this place wasn't on Yelp yet. This is a well known Italian seafood restaurant in a town where there's a lot of Italian tourists. We figured we had to try it! We were seated early in the evening. 8:30pm. Maybe the 2nd table in the place. By the end of the night, the restaurant would be full. It's a popular place. The good thing for tourists is that they speak English with no issues. The offering of the menu is varied but as you can imagine, it's mostly seafood. My son had the pasta. It was good for him. My wife had the steak. It was grilled and sliced and set on top of garnishing of potatoes. I had the large prawns on top of some diced vegatable garnish. All of the food was very good. The portions are small though. Maybe I needed to order like the italians and get the pasta course?!? Make a reservation. Give this place a try. One of the finer dining establishments on the island.