Casey Rubber Stamps

Ordered a custom stamp with my own design and it came out beautifully. For those accusing the staff of being rude- did you actually interact with them? It was clear to me that they are a small team and extremely busy, everyone is heads down actively working each time I've visited. They must get hundreds of visitors popping in just to check out this cool shop and shouldn't be expected to chitchat with everyone. When I spoke up to get their attention, the girl stopped what she was doing to come up and answer my questions. Later when I picked up the order the owner asked if it was my cat in the stamp (it is). It was cool to see young people working alongside the master of his craft. Seems like they have good rapport with each other which is also great to see. I hope this shop lasts forever.

What an amazing store! I am a huge junk journaler and scrapbooker, so this store was like a candy store for me. All stamps are designed and made in house, and you can also request custom stamps. I loved looking at all the stamps on the shelves. You can also purchase stamps online, which I did as soon as I got home. I can't wait to come back here and get more!! The stamps can vary in price, and they are a tad bit on the high price side, but the detail and designs are so unique and beautiful that I think it's totally worth it.

What an incredibly cool store. Extremely small and cramped. No way you can fit a wheelchair inside. Can fit about 6 people? Lots of fun stamps to check out and a friendly store cat

Very nice experience, and fantastic gifts / souvenirs ! You might have to wait for 30 min to an hour for specific requests, so do not be in a rush while visiting !!

In Websters dictionary as illustration for “hole in the wall.” Inkstained cubby hole with a friendly kitty and staff. While you wait rubber stamps from a large and eclectic selection. You can smell the ink. Fab.

Hit up Casey Rubber Stamps in NYC and it was such a cool find. I showed up early at 11:30, even though they usually open at 1pm, but the guy was super understanding and let me in since I’d traveled across the city just to check it out. The shop is packed with all sorts of beautiful rubber stamps—truly a treasure trove for anyone into print projects. Left with a bunch of great finds. This place is an absolute gem.

I'm in town visiting my sister and I found the catalog for Casey Rubber Stamps and was SO intrigued. She told me how the owner has been doing this forever and the shop has been flooded recently due to... something? I don't remember, an article? Anyway, I needed to see it, I was too curious. It was everything I wanted and more. It reminded me of an old book shop or something; distinct smells, slightly messy with stamps all over, a shop cat, and an array of the strangest stamps. I should have bought the "Viagra Corn" one but decided to be more practical and get a "fragile" one instead since I can use it for my pottery business. This is highly worth a visit!

Lovely rubber stamp store. If you find something in the booklet and it’s not in stock, it takes 5 minutes to make a rubber stamp if the rubber is already cut. Otherwise, it takes 15 minutes.