Casey's

This review isn’t about the pizza, the donuts, or even the friendly folks behind the counter. It’s about one simple thing: half & half. Or rather, the total absence of it. Every. Single. Time. I don’t know what’s going on at this Casey’s, but that dispenser where they’re supposed to keep the big chilled bag of real half & half? It’s always empty. Not once in a while — not occasionally — every confounded time I stop in. And here’s the part that really fries me: it’s not like asking them to put it in there is some big heroic act. It’s literally part of the setup! But instead, you’ve got to stand there, pre-caffeine, digging deep into your reserves just to muster up a polite voice to ask for something that should already be there. Anyone who depends on coffee to get functional in the morning knows what I mean — that fragile, pre-verbal moment where you’re still buffering like bad Wi-Fi. That’s not the time to be negotiating with your barista about dairy. It’s the time when the half & half should already be waiting for us. They’ve got three ten-thousand-dollar coffee machines shining like trophies, but apparently no one can be bothered to drop a $20 bag of half & half in the dispenser. Meanwhile, your only option is that sketchy room-temperature “creamer” that looks like it’s survived a nuclear winter. Sorry, but no thanks. Casey’s, if you’re listening — this is not a big ask. It’s one of those little things that turns a convenience store into an inconvenience store real fast. Please, for the love of caffeine and human civility, just keep the damn half & half stocked.

Went into Casey's Lebanon looking for a couple slices of pizza and there was no pre-made food: no pizza, sandwiches ...nothing. So I made joke to cashier because in my 60 years on this earth and coming from IA never have I seen a Casey's where there was no food available. I then go to my car to think where I was going to go for dinner when the cook that was so busy comes out in front of my car gives me the middle finger and starts cussing at me because he took exception to what the cashier said to him. I typically purchased gas ⛽️ and breakfast from Casey's but I will never use Lebanon Casey's again. #Unhinged workers. Interaction with cashier was my frustration about how there was no food prepared. I don't know what cashier said to cook

I love the employees! They are all so sweet and funny, and they make me laugh every time I'm there. Love you guys 🩷🤍🖤💜🩵

This morning I went there. There were no donuts made no breakfast food made at all . The ice machine does not work and has not been working the last few weeks, it’s a brand new machine. The coffee creamer dispenser had the wrong coffee creamer in its place, there is soaked soaked towels all over the countertops by the coffee machines with gnats flying around them.

Best breakfast pizza in town!!!

Stopped on our way to I 64 to get gas and we were assaulted by a "regular customer". Pounding on our window screaming at us thar we were blocking the pump. Not true. Kept screaming at us so we pulled up. I went in to use restroom which was very dirty and he continued on with the berating me in the store.I used restroom and came out. He was back outside and I ask employees about him. I was told he was a regular. I said maybe he needs police called on him to which they replied now you are going to start with me. It w as unbelievable. I left and we didn't purchase fuel. We travel through there all the time and we will never use that place again. What terrible customer service.

I would like to commend the Lebanon, IL store on such a great management staff. It is with excitement that I visit this store DAILY, sometimes several times daily. Today I was witness to the management staff of Theresa and Steve hosting an employee appreciation luncheon for all the employees along with birthday celebration for a worker. How awesome is that to organize and dedicate their time off to say thanks and great job to the employees. Lets be honest, I am sure these employees and even management staff are not breaking the bank every week with their earnings, yet these leaders took the time, effort and their own finances to say thank you to the employees. I personally had given up on this particular Caseys until the birth of the new management and several quality employees. In closing, I would like to say thank you to Theresa and Steve for creating the excitement and gratitude for the employees today. I hope they continue this trend and it spreads to other Caseys stores. It is refreshing to see the employees get some recognition as opposed to it always being the customer. Without the employees, there would be no customers.. Thank you!

I go to Casey's usually for two reasons. I love their chocolate peanut clusters and their pizza is to die for. Honestly their pizza is probably some of the best pizza in the area which in itself is amazing for a corner shop gas station that place

We have had their pizza several times. It is always very good. Only issue one time was telling the difference between a normal crust and a thin crust. We will return

We are from out of town and unfortunately locked our keys in our car.. the employees at Casey's went above and beyond to get us help. We cannot thank them enough for their kindness. Michele, our cashier, was constantly checking in on us, letting us use her phone, and even offered to buy us sodas while we waited for help. Let me just say.. she is an invaluable team member. Very thankful something like this happened around such wonderful employees. Thank you Casey's!!!

They have some of the friendliest people working here! Great service every time! The pizza is pretty good, but the breakfast pizza is phenomenal!