Robert G.
Yelp
Everyone here is weighing in on the Cathedral of St. Paul, in Minnesota's capital, with 5 stars and that's what I was thinking. Yelp has changed its explanations for their ratings, making them more realistic and less childlike. A 5 used to imply "as good as it gets" and is now denominated as "great." This is indeed a great church, in both its craftsmanship and its uplifting character.
I managed to go in here for a short while, with some people waiting to go to confession and others simply worshiping. I had the camera on my phone in ready mode and stayed toward the sides. It was difficult to capture the cathedral's grandeur from either the interior or the exterior and frame the photos correctly.
Something very cool happened here. One of the employees acknowledged me and quietly and diplomatically answered some of my questions and addressed my comments. First, I would have never thought that the same architect who designed this cathedral also designed Minneapolis's basilica. I learned that that day. When you scrutinize them in greater detail, some similarities do become apparent. However, Minneapolis's main church is more rectilinear while the cathedral in St. Paul has a more evident cupola, as well as more domed and vaulted areas, making it very evocative. With St. Paul being the relative underdog of the Twin Cities, it was seemingly dealt a slightly better hand in terms of an incredible main Roman Catholic church building.
I wanted to make some other comments of the type I would typically make and don't feel I need to apologize for. I made a quick study of the people in the church and the demographic was both urban(e) and diverse. When you walk into an important church and it is anything but provincial, that usually also says something positive about the congregation and the experience as a whole. In short, I trust my gut. It's called "live and learn." That said, I'm sure they cast a broad net in terms of their relief and assistance efforts, outreach within the archdiocese, and many other types of involvement that benefits the Twin Cities area.
The most interesting juxtaposition, in my mind, is how the Cathedral of St. Paul, albeit massive, is both very peaceful and very imposing. Sitting atop a big flight of steps in the city's Cathedral Hill neighborhood, the view over downtown St. Paul, the state capitol, and toward the riverfront is awe inspiring.