Caye Custard (formerly DandE's)

The frozen custard tastes great, the place is very cool. A good spot to avoid the heat while having their wonderful treats. We had soursop, butter pecan, coconut, cookie dough, coffee and oreo - all great. The home made waffle cone is good too. If you're here long enough, make sure to get the punch card so you can get a free scoop after 8 purchases

I was in Bze for a week and came back here twice. The ice cream was so right!!! The first I had coconut and butter pecan in a waffle cone and second time I got the mango. They were all great! My friend got the caramel which was also really good! Perfect thing to have in that intense heat!

Amazing ice cream! Try the coconut and butter pecan on a cone. I recommend this place.

We stumbled across this gem as we were looking for a place to eat. For those unfamiliar with frozen custard it is like ice cream but more creamy. I like this better than ice cream. The host was very friendly and explained all the flavours and "styles" (like sundae, concrete, etc.). See our pictures for the full list of flavours. Chocolate is always a great option but we enjoyed trying the soursop as well. We visited multiple times and leveraged the buy "5 scoops get one free" punch card.

If you’re craving something cold, creamy, and absolutely delicious in San Pedro, look no further than Caye Custard. This spot is a hidden gem and hands down the best ice cream on the island. From the moment you walk in, the sweet aroma hits you and you know you’re in for a treat. The custard here is unbelievably rich and smooth—velvety in texture and bursting with flavor. Whether you’re a classic vanilla fan or want to try one of their fun, local flavors, you really can’t go wrong. Every scoop tastes like it was made with love and top-quality ingredients. It’s the perfect stop after a hot day at the beach or an evening stroll through town. The staff is super friendly, the atmosphere is welcoming, and the portions are generous. You’ll be thinking about this ice cream long after your trip ends!

A great little custard shop (ice cream on steroids) in San Pedro. Stopped by after dinner next door this week and grabbed a pint of coconut custard. It was terrific. More delicious than ice cream, more fat, more creaminess. The staff was friendly, helped with selections, etc. A nice little custard shop "on the island." We weren't looking for dessert, and this was a most pleasant find! Recommend Caye Custard for a tasty dessert, any time of day!

Best ice cream on San Pedro! We visited for a week long scuba trip and frequented this spot. We enjoyed the company and locals. The custard flavors are put of this world, soursop is a must try! Thanks for such a nice nightly treat

We got 3 flavors - vanilla, coffee and strawberry sorbet. We really liked the texture of the vanilla and coffee - but didn’t like the strawberry. We are having ice cream on the island every day and this one wasn’t the best - but still good if you’re in the area