Joan B.
Yelp
We went to this restaurant on our holiday visit to Fort Collins, CO, primarily because my elderly father was along and this was an old haunt of his back in the 1970s, and he went to it TWICE during our three-day visit! The second time we went along, and it was really pretty darned good! I say anything that has been open that long (I just learned on their website they opened in 1957! Wow!) is doing something right!
Yes, the architecture and decor is a bit OK a LOT dated, as it does not look like it has changed since the 1970s (including the stalactite-style ceiling finish, LOL!). But honestly that gives it a certain charm, and I have to say that stepping into the bar part of it was like stepping back in time, with little nooks with small tables and cozy booth seats, lots of wood trim and carpet! Carpet, I say! I felt like I was in a 1970s movie or TV show!
All that aside, the food was very good, if a bit on the traditional presentation side. You will not find any fancy gourmet sounding items on the menu, nor elegantly dribbled sauces or artfully placed garnishes (except for they did have slices of pineapple for garnish, which was an interesting and not unwelcome surprise!). You WILL find hearty fare that sticks to your ribs and tastes good going down! The rolls and butter that come with every meal are welcome, as is the salads that they offered (who would think to put Chex cereal on a garden salad? but hubby said it was delicious!).
My five breaded jumbo shrimp were kind of pricy at $27 but delicious, and the baked potato I ordered with them was large and hearty. Dad had a steak, which was not terribly surprising, and hubby had French onion soup, which he raved about. Wish I had the recipe! I splurged for the peanut butter cream pie, because my dad said it was really good, and they brought forks for all of us and he said it tasted just the same as always! I wish I had the recipe; I took home the leftover and ate it in our hotel the next night, and it was STILL fabulous!
So yeah, Charco Broiler may be a little outdated and kitschy, but that's half the fun! And the staff was VERY friendly and warm, which is sadly hard to come by these days. Do NOT pass this by! It's near the intersection of I-25 and Mulberry so it is pretty hard to miss (plus the bright yellow sign with the horned steer on it is fairly obvious).