Stephanie T.
Yelp
After seeing all the 5 star reviews, I was excited to check this place out. It was pretty good, as you can't really go wrong with ice cream, but not as mind-blowing as some of the reviews make it out to be. For other Vancouverites, I prefer Earnest Ice Cream or Rain or Shine hands down.
All the flavours look really delicious, and their descriptions will make you laugh a little. I ended up going for the salted caramel in a waffle cone, which has chocolate flakes in it and apparently Harrison Ford liked it. Well if it was good enough for him, it's good enough for me, right?
The salted caramel is tasty, perhaps not as salty or "burnt sugar tasting" like Earnest's, but still good. The waffle cones are crisp and well made, the bottom was crafted so there is less chance of melted ice cream dripping out.
Tip: If you eat at Wildside Grill first, keep your receipt and you get 10% off at Chocolate Tofino.
There is some covered outdoor seating in between Chocolate Tofino and Wildside Grill, plus washrooms behind. If the weather is nice they also have a lot of picnic tables in the area (uncovered).
If I'm in Tofino again I'd come back, as it seems like the best place to have ice cream there. But, it's not even close to my favourite ice cream places and not something I'd crave for.