Laura W.
Yelp
My husband and I wanted to experience one of the "authentic" colonial taverns while in Williamsburg, and as our schedule allowed, Sunday was the only day we could visit one. Our options were limited to 2 of them, with one closing at 2:30pm. We opted for the one open all day, Chowning's Tavern, as we were visiting at an "off-time", around 2pm. We were immediately seated upstairs.
We ordered iced tea and coffee (his) to drink plus two waters. Waters were never received, iced tea was served with zero ice. A promise to bring ice was never fulfilled. We saw our server for our drink order, food order, delivery of food, and to get the check, which we had to flag her down. She had 2 other tables so it is not like she was busy. We found her rolling her silverware, which, as a former server I know, is the last thing you should do on your shift. Service was 1.5 stars.
The food was a solid 3 stars but nothing above that level. My husband ordered the beef trencher-Warm beef brisket, caramelized onions, aged cheddar cheese, and beer spread, horseradish sour cream, served on hearth-baked bread. He enjoyed it, although he thought it was heavy on the onions. I tasted it as well and confirmed it was pretty good, although the beer spread was pretty runny. The home-made chips, however, were excellent! Very well flavored and crisp. I ordered the Virginia pork BBQ sandwich-Slow-cooked pork on a brioche roll, served with tavern slaw. The pork was semi-dried out, although I did like the spice in the bbq sauce. The slaw was about a teaspoon worth in a ramekin. I had a side salad as my side item, which was fine-typical side salad. The blue cheese dressing was runny and seemed bottled instead of homemade.
I am glad we tried the "authentic" colonial tavern experience, but I would probably leave the historic area for Duke of Gloucester street and eat there instead the next time I am in the area.