Cindy's Pies

This place was amazing. You go, you ring the bell, the door opens (just the top), he says “how many pies” you say, “one pie”, he says “flavor”, you say “STRAWBERRY RHUBARB”, he says “classic crust or crumb crust”, you say “CRUMB CRUST” he says “$20” you say “nevermind I’ll take two”. He leaves. He returns. You have two INCREDIBLE pies. We will stop at Cindy’s Pies on every trip to the finger lakes from here forevermore. One small caveat: the sign for the place is “Cindy’s Grape Pies”. This is not true. The owner is not Cindy, you can only buy grape in September and they also sell cookies and tarts. None of these facts should deter the persevering traveler but just wanted to share.

Delicious! Wonderful customer service & the pies were so flavorful! We were grateful for a free sample & bought cherry cookies and a cherry pie. We were told the business has been around for about fifty years - incredible.

A new favorite place to go. Every fall we take a drive to Naples, enjoy the foliage and pick up a grape pie from Monica's. This year though when I searched for Monica's website to see what hours they were open I found out they had closed their doors for good. Well I still wanted to get a grape pie and Cindy's Pies came up in my search so that is where we went. The grape pie was mouth watering, better than I have ever had. We also grabbed 8 tarts of different flavors that were just as fabulous as the pie. Our new yearly ritual will definitely include a stop at Cindy's Pies 🥧

If you want a homemade pie that is extremely fresh stop in here! We got a baby tart to eat immediately because I literally couldn’t wait and then got a large grape pie. Very clean professional and high end bakery that Cranks out some of the best pies you’ve ever had !

Fresh pie, that filled our car with amazing smells that was vegan. I can’t believe it. On a rainy may day this was amazing. Can’t wait to come back for more.

Holly is the greatest! I can't wait to come back in September when it's time for Grape Pies!

Been coming here since I was a child, best pies in Naples. A little more $ than some, but delicious pies and cookies!

Stopped in curious to try the Grape Pie. You can get either crumb or regular top we got the crumb It was absolutely spectacular and still warm. We will be stopping to grab a few before we start our drive home to Pa. We also grabbed two cherry tarts to eat in the car on the way to our air b&b which were also delish!!! If you’re in the area make Cindy’s a must try!!