The Comanche

Stayed for one night. Tried to check in on a Sunday, but the lobby is closed. Called the number on the door and got a call back 4 hours later. We booked a premium suite and were government a double full. We went to the lobby and told someone and they said the premium suite wasn't cleaned and they moved us to a king with no tv, and no hot water. Definitely a waist of money

The Comanche is back and better than ever. New management has brought fresh upgrades, warm hospitality, and renewed energy to this historic gem. The improved rooms, welcoming team, and sounds like the pool will soon make a comeback. It's must-visit in Christiansted.

This hotel is advertised on Priceline.Com, it is NOTHING like the pictures they have posted. The room is filthy, the pool empty, deck has hugh caved in areas. I did not feel safe either. This place is a dump.

Run by someone who doesn't want to run a hotel. Website says Continental breakfast, and there is not even coffee available. Had to go down the boardwalk to get a cup. Check in done self-serve. I was down in the office trying to get a receipt, and while I was gone, the cleaning staff took all my food from the mini fridge and stripped my bed before I had even checked out. The nightclub next door keeps you up all night with booming music and drunks hollering and laughing until after 2 in the morning.

Club Commanche Hotel is so old, broken down and dirty. The pictures on their website are very deceiving. The hotel is a dump! No amenities at all; no restaurant, no continental breakfast; no bar: no ice machine! We tried to get our money back after seeing the hotel, but it was not possible. Do NOT book room here! Camping out is a better option.

Club Comanche is a historical property boasting a perfect location in Christiansted. The rooms are beautiful, boasting exposed wood ceilings and flooring throughout. Some of the furnishings show their age, but are comfortable. Smart televisions add a modern, convenient touch. On their website, the pool is said to be permanently closed, which is very unfortunate. In it’s prime, I’m sure it was a beautiful place to relax. Continental breakfast is not available, despite being advertised online and in the rooms. Overall, this is by no means a bad choice. It is priced on par with other comparable properties, and the location is unbeatable. I do wish management would consider revitalizing the pool and bar areas. This may help attract more visitors in the future and liven up the atmosphere a bit. In addition, I would like to express my utmost gratitude for the wonderful staff that took care of me during my stay. Thank you for your hospitality!

The room was very cozy and had a nice view. The ac worked well. I enjoyed a warm shower after exploring the island. The hotel had a beautiful antique vibe to it. The breakfast was not appetizing as it had flies but other than that the hotel has great accommodations. For the price you can beat it. I also enjoyed the soft bed sheets, the location and Peking is accessible easily across the street. You don’t have to pay additional for parking which is great. The hotel staff are amazing and very helpful they Evan gave me a after hours assistance. Anytime you need something they respond. The room was top quality.

Nestled within the heart of Christiansted the Club Comanche Hotel St. Croix is a true gem that captivates with its unique blend of historical allure and shabby chic ambiance. From the moment I stepped into the lobby, I was transported back in time, enveloped by the rich tapestry of the past woven into every corner of the hotel. While some may perceive the weathered facade as signs of neglect, I found it to be an integral part of the hotel's charm, a testament to its storied past. Each room is a sanctuary of tranquility, adorned with vintage furnishings that whisper tales of days gone by. While it's true that some areas may show signs of wear and tear, I couldn't help but be enchanted by the palpable sense of history that permeates every nook and cranny. The staff's genuine warmth and hospitality further enhance the experience, making every guest feel like a cherished part of the hotel's legacy. Whether it's savoring the offerings of the continental breakfast or simply unwinding in the charming courtyard and pool, every moment spent at Club Comanche Hotel St. Croix feels like a journey back in time. In conclusion, my stay at Club Comanche Hotel St. Croix was nothing short of enchanting. If you're seeking a one-of-a-kind experience that seamlessly blends history with hospitality, look no further than this hidden gem. Embrace the quirks, savor the stories, and let yourself be transported to a bygone era where time stands still.