Cristy R.
Yelp
The Bay Voyage Inn's amazing views of the Newport Bridge make up for the service mistakes and food presentation.
Our waiter, although really friendly, completely messed up my date's drink order and forgot to put in our order of calamari when we originally asked for it. I ordered a glass of Riesling, my date ordered a glass of Pinot Noir. The waiter walks over with two glasses of white wine. Try again! When my date informed him that he had ordered Pinot, the waiter returned five minutes later with a glass of Pinot Grigio. Foiled again! I chuckled and kindly informed the waiter that it was Pinot Noir - RED, not WHITE! I jokingly then said, "you can leave the Pinot Grigio if you want." He laughed and said ok. I mean, what were they going to do? Pour it back in the bottle? I really thought we wouldn't be charged for the mistaken glass of wine, but to my dismay, we were!!
The Fried Native Calamari (smoked tomatoes, piccalilli dressing, sea salt) were fresh and yummy!
I feasted on the Sautéed "Day Boat" Scallops (toasted orzo, English peas, spring greens, mint). There is nothing more appealing than a perfectly grilled scallop - why hide it with spring greens? I think the presentation of this dish could be a little better. Show off your sautéed scallops! Don't hide their deliciousness! They tasted divine! Mmmm.
My date ordered the Grilled Porterhouse Steak (charred radicchio, arrugla, parmesan, cabernet gastrique). Instead of medium well done, the steak came out mooing. Not impressed. He sent it back to the kitchen to cook a little longer, but the initial introduction to this porterhouse was clearly disappointing.
Be sure to ask to sit next to the windows or outside! The view is romantic and amazing! Unfortunately, the Jamaican/Caribbean music that played in the background the entire meal didn't really match the ambience of Bay Voyage Inn. "Anything Goes" by Wayne Wonder was playing when we paid the tab.
I would definitely give this place another shot - I think I'll venture there again for brunch.