Jackie S.
Yelp
This was my first time dining at this somewhat iconic spot - firstly, I think you definitely come here for the ambiance. I love the theming here, from the underwater elements in the lobby to the views of the open ocean tank while you dine. You don't often see classic theming like this at Disney restaurants anymore!
I had a raspberry mojito from the drink menu, which boasts mostly fruity, sweet, tropical drinks. It was nice! We started with both the chicken wings and the coconut shrimp, and I'm always pleased by complimentary bread and butter. The sweet bread was a nice change up and went well with the apps we ordered. The chicken wings had a nice flavor - better than I expected! The coconut shrimp were standard, but no complaints about a good standard coconut shrimp.
I ordered the surf and turf. Firstly, I'm not sure that 3 pieces of shrimp along the steak fully feels like a great surf and turf deal, but I was pretty stuffed from the meal, so I can look past that. Unfortunately, my medium steak came out very medium rare, and though I hate sending things back, I did. Our server was extremely kind about it, and I was quickly brought a new plate, so no complaints there at the end of the day. But even with my new medium steak, I felt like I've had a better quality, smoother filet at other Disney restaurants, though the chimmichurri sauce was very good. The mashed potatoes had nice flavor, but were more vaguely smashed than a smooth puree you might expect. A friend ordered the shrimp fettuccine and was satisfied but not blown away.
I wish I had room for dessert; they looked great! Overall, great service, fun ambiance, fine food. I think I'd return with friends who wanted to go, but I won't add it to my list of favorites on property.