Danielle F.
Yelp
What a let down. After studying the menu and their website extensively I finally decided to try Corndance especially after hearing great things from a colleague. Upon arrival the parking lot was full but entering the establishment it felt quiet and empty. The manager greeted us at the hostess stand and the seating hostess sat us at a booth. The interior and ambiance was not at all what I expected considering their menu offerings and prices. I really expected the dining room to be elevated and sophisticated, perhaps even with linen table cloths. It's just a glorified Outback with booths and looks very casual, nothing fine dining about the restaurant interior except perhaps their wine vault which was very elegant.
I ordered the truffle risotto as my main course and it was inedible. I sent it back. Not only was the Arborio rice (if they even used the correct rice grain) granular and hard / unevenly and undercooked but the actual taste of the truffle was atrocious! I couldn't even finish my forkful. They also topped it with a queso fresco or cotija cheese which doesn't belong on this dish. Maybe a Parmesan? Why would you have risotto as a menu offering if you don't know how to cook it?
The appetizer was like the Dean's French onion dip you buy at the grocery store in a tub with house made kettle chips (the chips are the only thing they got right). The elote corn was heavily doused with a steak seasoning almost like Montreal seasoning and was not an authentic flavored elote. It had a funny flavor and aftertaste. No lemon in this either and very little cheese.
For being a steakhouse how can you not get a basic steak Caesar salad right? The authentic Caesar dressing should be anchovies, minced capers or garlic, lemon juice, egg yolk, and oil. So simple! Let's not reinvent the wheel. Their chef and line cooks do not know how to cook, period. This dressing has absolutely zero flavor except heavy pepper, no tanginess from the lemon, not even any salt. Flavorless and bland. Even the croutons had no taste, just roasted bread chunks with no salt or seasoning.
By far the worst part of the meal was the fact that the steak was ordered medium, and our server Andrew specifically asked if was okay with a pink center and we said yes. That's how medium temperature steaks should be! Instead we got a charred completely brown & black hard dry strips. (Pictures for reference).
The plating was also super awkward. They used the same shallow bowls with a high back for salad and sides and the food is almost spilling out the edge of the bowl. We needed to ask for a plate to spill the salad over into a wide plate. The only redeeming factor was their wine and stunning wine glasses.
All in all, I will never be returning. You're truly better off at Ruth's Chris, Outback Steakhouse, or even Texas Roadhouse (and I despise chains!) but at least there you know what you're getting and there is uniformity and consistency. Actually Rocky River Tap and Table might be the best choice. Farm to table, fresh ingredients and fabulous taste. Everything on their menu is tasty and exquisitely prepared. Corndance is sadly, SEVERELY lacking!