Cowboy Butter

Barbecue restaurant · New Milford

Cowboy Butter

Barbecue restaurant · New Milford
59 Bank St, New Milford, CT 06776

Photos

Cowboy Butter by null
Cowboy Butter by null
Cowboy Butter by null
Cowboy Butter by null
Cowboy Butter by null
Cowboy Butter by null
Cowboy Butter by null
Cowboy Butter by null
Cowboy Butter by null
Cowboy Butter by null
Cowboy Butter by null
Cowboy Butter by null
Cowboy Butter by null
Cowboy Butter by null
Cowboy Butter by null
Cowboy Butter by null
Cowboy Butter by null
Cowboy Butter by null
Cowboy Butter by null
Cowboy Butter by null
Cowboy Butter by null
Cowboy Butter by null
Cowboy Butter by null
Cowboy Butter by null
Cowboy Butter by null
Cowboy Butter by null
Cowboy Butter by null
Cowboy Butter by null
Cowboy Butter by null

Highlights

Wood-fired BBQ with burgers, wings, brisket, and seafood  

Placeholder
Placeholder

59 Bank St, New Milford, CT 06776 Get directions

cowboybutterbbq.com
@cowboybutterbbq

$30–50 · Menu

Reserve

Information

Static Map

59 Bank St, New Milford, CT 06776 Get directions

+1 860 717 4416
cowboybutterbbq.com
@cowboybutterbbq

$30–50 · Menu

Reserve

Features

reservations

Last updated

Aug 22, 2025

Powered By

You might also like

Terms of Use • Privacy Policy • Cookie Policy
 © 2025 Postcard Technologies, Inc.

Leslie Kaye

Google
What a great restaurant with fantastic food and great service! We all couldn’t stop saying mmmmmmm so freaking delicious 🤤 and huge portions. The fries were amazing!! Looking forward to going back and trying something new! Cheers🍻🍻

Steve Antonacci

Google
We came here opening weekend on a Sunday for lunch , it’s nice to see that spot occupied for one , and it’s also a bonus to have another food option in town . I had the smoked Brisket burger with hand cut fried cooked in tallow which added a distinct flavor. My wife had the Calamity Jane salad which she really enjoyed. My Brother in law had the brown butter bbq turkey breast with deviled egg potato salad . He remarked that the turkey was delicious as well and the deviled egg potato said it’s something he’s never see before . My SIL had the same salad as my wife but added salmon she said it was fantastic and the salmon was cooked perfectly. We will be coming back for dinner ! Give this place some time to solidify the staff and catch its rhythm … give this place a try please !

Alexa B

Google
First visit! Our burgers were so good. Flavorful, juicy and cooked perfect sooo yummy Mac n cheese was good too! Can’t wait to come back

Leslie Pranger

Google
Excellent food. Great portion sizes. My husband had left overs... That never happens. Excellent staff! Definitely will be back!

Blair Trump

Google
I'd give 6 stars if I could. Shared the oysters, burnt pork ends, wood smoked chicken wings with dipping sauce, sagebrush salad, and prime rib. Genuinely A+ all around, except the oysters which were 'just okay' and a little on the small side. I'll be coming back, and though I'll try some new menu items, I'm definitely getting those pork burnt ends again!

Ray Przybysz

Google
Everything we had was delicious. Brisket was moist, tender, and had great flavor. Waygu burger was great, tons of flavor and it all melded together perfectly. Corn salad that came with the brisket was very good and something different compared to what most bbq places serve. Cornbread was moist and the flavor was great. The only thing we ate that wasn’t terrific was the “pasta salad” that came with the burger; it was dry and didn’t have much flavor. Portion sizes were decent. A little pricey, but the food was really good. We will be back.

Patrick Lillis

Google
A+ friendly staff food was excellent. Keep up the good work. Best of luck

Brian Moker

Google
Went to their soft opening during the local fireworks event - great experience and this place will be our new regular spot. 10/10
google avatar

Amber L.

Yelp
Well, first off...wow. A friend of mine showed me pictures of the food that got me excited and the food is better than the pictures. Everything hit the spot. But of everything we tried - top three was the brisket meat, the sweet cornbread Yes please, and the fried cauliflower. Cannot wait to go again. The service was - before I begin - backstory we haven't seen my friend Jenny in six years, so we had a lot to discuss. And would you believe we talked for almost three hours - and they never said a cross word. The service was kind friendly and very forgiving because they close at 9. We thought it was ten, and there we were just talking like the wait staff was gonna spend the night. And they were all so nice. The decor is spot on. Well done for providing a BBQ place that's delicious, beautiful and friendly.