Cream City Social Eatery

I enjoyed this place and will be back. The music was on point! Our server/bartender was so nice and knows how to cater to customers. And..I must say that the food was VERY good and our food presentation was awesome! * * I had steak Alfredo, salad, and garlic Parmesan & BBQ chicken wings and fries. Can't wait to go again! 😋

Cream City Social Eatery is amazing! I was very impressed with the menu and the overall cleanliness of the restaurant. That is, Cream City Social is a very crisp and fresh product, and they have excellent customer service! The menu is really impressive, especially for dinner, and the amount of talent it takes to create amazing dishes is awe-inspiring. Moreover, the presentation of each dish is breathtaking, and the flavors will keep you coming back for more! Cream City Social is located in a very vibrant neighborhood, where the residents are eager for amazing food finds, and the community has alot to be excited about! Cream City Social is a perfect place for a casual dine-in [lunch] or for a causal dinner date, and the menu selections are absolutely fabulous, leaving you in complete shock that you discovered this restaurant! 5 Stars!!!

During lunch, they turned the music up to headache level. Food took 45 minutes to make simple orders and they messed it up horrifically. All food was cold. Didn't know how to make a panini at all. Prices are about 4x what they should be. This was supposed to be a fun birthday lunch but this place is disgusting and I'm telling everyone who ever asks to avoid it.

The ppl that works there are so fun and nice. They are a while vibe and will make sure that you have fun. The drinks were good, strong but good. It feels so jomey and comfortable. I went on karaoke night, good times! Bartender and server all participated. The food was very good, great portion, I couldn't finish all of it. Love it!❤️

This is the place to be. Customer service was A-1, drinks were A-1 and the live DJ had the music on point as well. I'm definitely going back real soon.

Found this place by accident and been coming often. The service is great and fast the food and drinks are really good... Fun music and djs reasonably priced food.

Get the shrimp and grits with provolone cheese. Best shrimp and grits I ever had!!! And good size portions. I repeat shrimp and grits best you will ever have!

When we walked into the place it an ok vibe. We were greeted and we had to find our own seat which was fine . The seating is tight and not kid friendly . The music was way too loud so you would have to talk over it . We went in there wanting to support black businesses in Milwaukee however we waited almost an hour for our food and it was cold and warm ..I ordered a chicken breast panini and it was extremely overcooked… friends were cold. My daughter ordered the shrimp fries and they cut the shrimp up into pies and she said it was flavorless. My other daughter ordered the burger the onion rings were good but the burger did not melt in your mouth ….the blue cheese dressing was not of quality…. I really hoped for better results …. They also enter a gratuity on your tab so pay attention to double tipping as I also payed a tip of %18 percent plus money …. If it was worth it fine but I was NOT SATISFIED 😪

Stopped in for lunch today for my first visit. I was immediately greeted by the bartender, whom I believe is also one of the owners. He told me I could sit anywhere I wanted. I grabbed a booth and a server came to greet me, introduce herself (Lori or Laurie or some variation) and bring me a QR code to scan, while also offering me a menu if I prefered not to scan and download. I asked for the popular dishes to which she replied, the chicken n waffles, wings, and Salmon Alfredo were the most popular. I ordered the chicken n waffles. The dish was delicious! The waffle is housemade. It was fluffy, slightly crisp, topped with powdered sugar, and I picked up a cinnamon flavor in the batter. Solid! The chicken tenders were crispy, nicely seasoned, and perfectly cooked. It was a great dish that I think would feed two people, so it was a good value at $12. I was full after one chicken tender and a 1/4 of the waffle, so I wanted a box and to close my tab, but Lori disappeared. Never came back to check on me, but thankfully I made eye contact with the bartender, and he asked hiw my dish was. After waiting another 10 minutes or so, I made eye contact with him again and told him I was ready to close out. He went back to tell Lori, and after another 5+ minutes, she arrived. The gratuity was already included, which I looked for when my bill was higher than I expected. She didn't mention it, so heads-up that they add 18% to your bill, and there is still a tip line on the receipt. I plan to return to try the wings and maybe a burger or panini.

This place was a 0 out of ten for 50 dollars I was expecting way better the fries were horrible the burger was ok u have to put everything on it yourself the meat came dry definitely would not recommend

The price just for this steak pasta was ridiculous! But the taste was mouth watering it might keep me coming for more not sure! Very pricey tho not sure if many will come to buy some unless they had it!

The food was ok. The drinks were ok. The service was ok, I probably wouldn't go back unless I know someone having a gathering there. But I can see that the ladies bathroom was very clean to be inside of a lounge/bar

We decided to try out this restaurant as it is in walking distance from our home. Looking at the menu I was particularly interested in trying the chicken and waffles. We arrived about 2 on a Sunday afternoon. The restaurant was not crowded and we were told to take any table we wished. We did and after several minutes of not being greeted, I asked a server who was our server and she said "I can take you." Obviously servers are not assigned tables. A few things to note... the music was loud and all rap. The restaurant was cool, with the air on high (79 degrees outside) so bring a sweater. It was difficult tell employees from patrons, (even though they were wearing shirts with the logo on) because many employees were doing hookah and socializing like they were on break. I ordered a Bloody Mary (Sunday brunch right?) but they didn't have the ingredients to make one so I settled for the house lemon drop. The food and the drinks were excellent. My plate was hot and delicious. The lemon drop was clearly made with fresh lemon juice. The portions were good and filling. I was thinking this place has so much potential! If they would change the music and turn it down a bit, they could draw a mature crowd that would pack the place. There are no places like this in this neighborhood. As I was leaving, it was difficult to get through a crowd that was standing blocking the walkway and exit. My neighborhood, my people so not a huge deal but for others this could be a deal breaker. I hope the owners read the reviews here. I would love to come back!

Attended this restaurant's soft launch and I am so happy this place exists. I was welcomed by bartenders and servers right away and seated at a booth. They have a really good amount of booth seating as well as a full bar set up. The server was very knowledgeable about the menu, professional, and friendly. I ordered the steak and it was perfectly cooked. You choose two sides... the mac and cheese is a hit. My friend ordered the Alfredo with chicken. The chicken is juicy and there's a good amount within the Alfredo. Pictured is the half order- great portion size. Everything we received was as described on the menu and the server made sure we were satisfied! I cannot wait to come back- I hear the chicken and waffles is really really good. Also, you can tell that there was a lot of thought put into the decor and aesthetic. Down to the music, it's really a vibe.

Food was not good and charged me twice and never got my money back. I just wouldn't recommend it... was disappointed twice

Went yesterday for lunch and they had very good food and service! We will be returning.

Listen....I had the best steak I ever had here. I recommend the wings as well they were made to perfection no exaggeration. I can't say what anyone else's experience will be but mine was 5 stars I doubled my tip. And the owner is extremely attentive to his patrons. Best kept secret in Milwaukee.

Listen, I had the Surf n Tuff a couple of days ago... and baby, my mouth is still wanting more. It's a joy to be served by a pleasant staff while having amazing food. I'm not a member of Yelp. I also do not normally write reviews unless I'm disappointed.. So, with that being typed... check them out.. :)