Best Pizza

Barsnobs was here, it's on the wall. They need a new marker! Pizza is top notch. Thin crispy and good cheese. A surprise for sure. Staff was nice. They put the 'as u' are in casual. I tried lol. Go see em, tell em Barsnobs sent ya!

Best pizza in Montauk by far. Super cool atmosphere.

We love Dive Bar! They have the best wings, pizza and knots around AND they are dog friendly with their outside seating. We visit often and highly recommend you do too!!

Dive bar is always had a very interesting dynamic between ordering your pizza and ordering your alcoholic beverages. The old location worked better that I think it does here. I'm not sure I understand the allure. The pizza is unremarkable if you're buying by the slice. If you customize a full pie, for example their clam pie, the experience is much better. The location works to be close to the docks. But overall, this is certainly not a destination pizza.

Great peperoni pizza! By the slice. Pepperoni was thinly cut but rather large circles. Beer on tap. Cool things to look at. Rock n roll music playing. skater vibe to it. I like all the customer writing on the walls.

Damn…I really wanted to love it because the location and environment is kick-ass…but the pizza was not good…I ordered a “grandmother” which I had (perhaps incorrectly) assumed was a Sicilian style pie. The flavors are there…but my pizza was over-cooked to the point that it was like pizza jerky. Soooo chewy. I will give them another chance with a standard style pie and we’ll see if the crust holds up.

not very impressed, it took them 45 minutes to bring out our food which was a simple 1 order of wings and 1 order of mozzarella sticks. the wings were comically, ridiculously saucy to the point that i could barely eat them. there was also crass graffiti in the bathroom.

Really great spot up in the marina district by the fishing pier. Would give 10 stars for atmosphere if I could. Wish I wasn’t driving I would have loved to get trashed here.

Hands down the best pizza ive had on LI. So sad to see the original location by Hither Hills was gone but so thrilled to see they reopened elsewhere. What you see is what you get, a dive bar and the best pizza. If you like thin and more well done this will be for you. Just the smell of the ovens when you walk in... I bellied up to the bar and got two slices and a bourbon while waiting for a fresh pie. The bartender was great. They have some table seating also and an outdoor area as well. This stop was the absolute highlight of my Montauk trip.

It's what it is. A bar with pizza. Slow service on busy nights. Pizza is good but nothing special.

i cannot reccomend this place enough - it's the best dive bar i've been too. the drinks are top notch and strong, we spent over three hours there one day watching the llws and truly had the best time. their eggplant parm and grandmas pie is a stand out, some of the best in Montauk! Don't shy away from its look, there's a true hidden gem inside. slices are about $4-6.50 each and pies start at around $28. it's become really live at night too and it's 21+ only after 9 pm. terrance, the owner, is so awesome and gave us drinks on the house after having to unexpectedly close down for the day. love this place!

Caesar died twice: once in Rome, and once in this tin pan. $15 for a Caesar salad straight out of a 7-Eleven fridge. A few limp leaves tossed into a tin tray, three sad condiment cups on the side, and croutons that looked like they died of boredom. For $15, I expected a salad. What I got was an autopsy of one.

Great pizza! Old montauk feel! Bar and drinks were fabulous! Would definitely visit again!

New location! So disappointed to discover they closed the location on 27 but glad they relocated. The plus side of where they are now, even if it's a much smaller place, is that you're right on the water. The pizzas are still good but definitely not the same. The grandma was not as thick and was very doughy, almost as if it wasn't fully cooked. They also don't offer the grandma veggie anymore; you have to build your own. Luckily they still have kale, which I love as a topping and which you rarely see as an option. However for what they charge for toppings ($7 for meatballs & eggplant, $5 for kale) they really didn't put much on the pies.

ordered few more times. pizza. inconsistent. last time is was very burnt. time before was just ok. worth checking out. busy poplar local-ish bar. suggest going for a beer and a slice (slices eat in only/not to go).

Such a great addition--so nice to have a local, no-frills spot. The bartenders are friendly, the vibe is laid-back, and it feels like old Montauk. Just good, normal people hanging out. Love having a place like this around.

Spent $117 for 3 pizzas and a hero. All the pizzas were burnt. No springiness to the dough probably there since last night. Not enough cheese or toppings! Will never go there again. If I had opened the box when I picked them up I would have walked out after checking them out. Your place on the stretch had burnt pizza and it still is burnt. Learn how to make pizza!

Great relatively recent addition to Montauk. Excellent pizza, salads and drinks. Fun, friendly staff and not your typical bar music (lots of punk, metal etc.). Extremely mixed crowd of locals, skaters, artists and curious onlookers. Recommended.

Weird that the name is dive bar pizza and they claim to have pizza all night in help. Yet I went at 11:30 pm and no pizza was available to any of the paying customers. However the owner walked in and suddenly the entire place smelt like Parmesan and he was able to receive pizza in front of the entire place

Best NY style pizza on the east end. I said all I needed to say in the first sentence but yelp needed me to type 85 characters...

burnt $60 pie. should not be that expensive. would rather eat the parchment paper. at least it's cheap then.

Incredible pizza. Thin and perfect char. The spicy clam pie is a standout... Water views too. Hard to beat