Megan B.
Yelp
We really wanted to like this place but were sorely disappointed. First of all, as others have noted, it's not a diner. You order at the counter, which was backed up and had a line, and then get a buzzer to pick up your food when it's ready. We were given coffee in paper cups and plastic cups for the self-serve water. You have to get everything, including ketchup, salt, pepper, napkins, silverware, yourself.
We ordered two small coffees, a side of eggs with a side of sausage (they don't have just an egg platter on the menu so it's a la carte) and a breakfast sandwich with bacon. After waiting for over 15 minutes, our food was ready, and it was underwhelming at best. The breakfast sandwich ($7.50) had one egg, which is fine, but the roll was too large, and there was less than one piece of bacon on it. It tasted like a spicy mayo sandwich with some hints of egg and bacon flavors. The food has no presentation, no sides or garnish, it's just on a tray or in a basket with wax paper underneath.
The prices are much too high for the portions, and the cafeteria style doesn't match up with the name/design of the place. Probably won't return unless they lean on the actual diner side more - wait staff, coffee in mugs with refills, better potion sizes. Otherwise, there are many better places in Andersonville.