Keri F.
Yelp
Fish Fry - Simple deep fry, great breading, perfect seasoning (salt/pepper), not oily, firm + flaky, 2 pieces at a time, but all you can eat! PERFECT basic fish fry 5/5
Fried Chicken - bone-in, 1/2 chicken, light crunch, bland. 3/5
Spatzle - served cool, kinda squishy, had much better, no flavor, no gravy. 2/5
Coleslaw - vinegar heavy (too tart for me), but wet. I added honey and salt. 2/5
Fritters - HEAVEN. This is small Indian Fry Bread: soft, light, fluffy, hot. Worth a lactaid! 5/5
German Potato Salad - warm, heavy meat flavor, didn't combine great for me. 2/5
Jalapeno Pretzel - seemed like store-bought-microwaved, cheese = can't, other said "YUM"
Supper Club atmosphere - "Exemplary" = dark wood panel, cheesey bar, average lighting, basement feel, TVs, piano, ADDITION: German themed knick knacks. 5/5
Beer - OMG! Very different (German!) but yummy! I couldn't say the names, so they said "2 oktoberfests, 1 lager, 1 pilsner, 1 dark" I love it this SIMPLE. It's winter so of course a BIG dark beer was in order. We ended up sampling all of them, but we ordered another (small) dark. 5/5
Old Fashioned - It's not a real Wisco supper club unless they do Old Fashioneds, so ordering one is part of our "club rating system." First, they "sorta" muddle. They add 2-3 scoops of sugar, splash with soda (sweet vs sour), add 2.5 shots of liquor, then swirl it all so much to whip into a froth. Overall, not a great OF. 2/5
CONS - Holy Wait Batman! We arrived at 6:20pm and were told 1 1/2 hrs, but got sat 2 HOURS LATER! We were pissed, even for a Fish Fry on Friday at a highly rated place (we've waited at many places for 1 - 1 1/2hr; this is the longest). Then my partner ordered 1 spatzle, but we were charged for 2! I ordered Chicken to check consistency of the menu - the order was forgotten and came 10 min after the other entree. No apology + full charge = pissy customers. 1/5
Overall, Fish fry, beer, fritters, and the supper club "feel" are PERFECT, but we will have to think LONG and hard about a 40 min drive to HORRIBLE wait times. Too bad you can't order fish in the bar area. Too bad the back of the building is a "show room." Too bad the main dining area sits as many people as the bar area. 3-4 stars.