Polyphemus S.
Yelp
Polar Express - Nice if you live nearby. Tickets were a bit expressive. For 2 adults and one child, it was ~$165. (I think that's too expensive, but my wife really want to go.) NOT worth traveling over an hour to get there if you're coming from out of the area. We came from DC and the drive was windy and long. It was too much for small children. You also don't want to break down on any of those roads. You're in the middle of nowhere, and it would be unsafe to break down (no shoulders for many of those little roads). Plus, I didn't see a single patrol car, and cell phone coverage is non-existent for much of the drive (although GPS kept track and got us there just fine).
As for the experience itself, they do a good job. I wish the train had shocks; we rocked back and forth for a good chunk of the trip and it was difficult walking in the cart (I think they use an old train just for this purpose). There's also no AC/fresh air, which would have been nice, but given the Polar Express is in the Fall/Winter, it was fine. You get hot chocolate and a bell on board (that's it). Otherwise, throughout the ~1.5 hour train ride, they have 2 girls dressed in pajamas entertaining everyone with little skits, and then they have the conductor come through to validate the pretend tickets, and hobo (from the movies), and of course old St. Nick. 1/2 way through the trip, you see the north pole, xmas lights, and Santa outside.
The train station is downtown Elkins, which seemed like a really nice town (and EVERYONE in WV was really nice). The Holiday Inn Express is right across the parking lot, so if you're staying there, you can easily walk (it literally wouldn't make sense not to walk). There's a really good restaurant (Maggies) 1.5 blocks away (I ordered take-out, but it's a normal restaurant inside if you want to eat there).