gmcguire1992
Google
We have just returned from a 5 night stay at Eala. This is our third stay since June 2024. There are lots of positives to Eala, including its wonderful setting, cleanliness, spa/pool area and breakfast. However, we feel that Eala has lost its spark, for the following reasons: ||1. Service in the hotel - whilst the reception staff are polite and welcoming, our third stay was not acknowledged even though we reminded them in an email. This was disappointing as it is the extra little touches that make a difference. ||2. Service in the Bistro - on our first night we dined in the Bistro. We were served by a waiter who was unwell and had a dreadful cold. He kept sniffing when serving us and wiping his nose. This was off putting and not the start to the holiday we wanted - the last thing we wanted to do was catch a cold at the beginning of our break! On the same night I was also given a desert containing gluten and if it wasn’t for me questioning the biscuit like topping, I could’ve become very unwell. ||3. Dogs - we identified two dogs staying at Eala during our stay. One was a puppy and particularly disruptive - it was very yappy and reactive. The dogs were also welcome in the indoor area of the restaurant, which we felt was inappropriate particularly as they weren’t well behaved and due to the cost of the food in the Bistro. ||4. Bistro experience - last year we were supplied with complimentary appetisers and a petit four after dinner. These were no longer offered. We were advised by one of the staff that a new manager had taken over the restaurant. Unfortunately, we do not feel that the changes were for the better. The menu is as also confusing and the special dishes lacked variety - the pasta of the day was a courgette dish which did not change for the duration of our stay. ||5. We were served a ‘packet breakfast’ on our final morning as we vacated early. This was of very poor quality. We were served a stale sandwich , a few berries and a croissant. We have stayed in less prestigious hotels where the breakfast offered in the room was far superior. This needs addressing as we felt like we were dining from a canteen. ||Overall, our stay was very enjoyable. Had we have not experienced what Eala was like last year, I’m sure we would’ve enjoyed the stay more. However, for the reasons described, we do not feel that the stay was 5*. Our holiday began in Florence at the St Regis where complimentary tea and coffee was served to your room in the morning, and a complimentary pressing service was given for your evening outfit. These extra touches make an experience truly 5*. This review is not intended to put anyone off Eala, as it is a wonderful hotel, although changes need to be made to bring back its spark.