Marianne St. G.
Yelp
I love this place. I love it enough that I seriously considered giving it 5 stars. Please bear that in mind as you read.
First. they have good food. That is not a given, and needs saying. I really recommend the German Pancake with just lemon and butter. Or, in the evening, we love the Prime Rib, minus the gravy but with extra butter.
They have a good selection of tea, if avoiding sugar and soft drinks, and solid coffee. If you get the vanilla coffee, I suggest you have them cut it 50/50 with regular coffee, or it is very sweet. Then, you can have it twice for one price.
Also, they have humane meat. They serve Zenner's sausage, for example, so if sourcing matters to you, you can eat here without wondering what you will have to do to get a good meal.
So far, this sounds like a 3 star joint, so why do I give it 4? The people. I feel like a regular, and recognize my wait staff, even if they don't recognize me. I feel welcomed, like a genuine guest, that they are happy to see. It is a genuine, old fashioned welcome like you see in the movies but I don't think I have experienced anywhere else.
When available, we like to sit at a table next to one of the two fireplaces. The place is decidedly old fashioned, and while I sometimes think it could use a freshening up, I don't really mind. It feels like what it is - an old fashioned restaurant that never lost its soul. I spoke to one of the waitstaff about this and she told me that many of them are long time employees, that it is a second home to them, and that they do feel like we are their welcome guests in that home.
So, at least 4 stars. Enjoy that classic ambiance and genuinely good, old fashioned service and enjoy a relaxing meal with friendly folks who want you to have a good time. I always do.