Jeremy O.
Yelp
So you're trying to decide if you want to stay at the Estate Lindholm. Easy answer, absolutely. There are some thing to consider however. Keep in mind that this is a bed and breakfast type place and not a hotel. What this means in this case is that while it is a fantastic place to find quiet and relaxation without the usual bustle and noise of a hotel the "drawback" is that it also does not have all the amenities you might take for granted in a similarly priced hotel. It should be obvious there is no room service but keep in mind there is not even a vending machine. This is something you can obviously work around using a local market but just understand what you are getting and what you are not in this gem up on the hill.
I'm sure by this point you have read many stories about Gordon and Brion and there wonderful customer service. All very much true so I'll leave it at that with the exception of adding a personal thank you to both. They pick you up at the dock upon arrival, get you back there when it's time to leave, and are willing to help you with whatever you need in between. Side note, if you are considering which ferry to take to St John and read about both Charlotte Amailie and Red Hook just take the Red Hook. We planned on taking Charlotte and to this day never did see that thing anywhere.
So now some details to consider. Why are you going to St John? Are you looking for a quiet vacation on the beaches or some time in the bars and food? Well you're in luck because from here you can have both. The bars are all a short (5 minute) walk down the hill to town from the estate and yes, you can walk up the hill but you probably won't want to. We (two 40 somethings in average shape) did on numerous occasions and while it is certainly doable in that heat you will break a pretty good sweat and who needs that on vacation. Hail one of the always running cabs going up the hill and you'll be out 7 or 8 bucks but not only do you save the sweat but to be honest the hill is a bit dangerous walking up in the dark as there are curves, no lights, and no sidewalk. We made it at least ten times but that was only because it became a personal battle, do as I say here not as I did. The estate does leave a small flashlight in your room by the door, bring it if you choose to ignore my cab advice.
Next issue I had while planning. Rent a car or not. Well again this is dependent on your plans. If you intend to really explore the island you can rent a car and will be okay as the estate has parking but understand you won't be driving this car down into Cruz Bay as there is very, very limited parking from what I observed. A consideration would be to rent a car for just a day or two from one of several available rental places in town. A cab can get you to most of the many beaches and I suggest you get to as many as you can but if you just want one beautiful beach you can make the 15 minute walk down the trail to Honeymoon Beach from the estate which was one of the very best anyway. There are a couple others within walking distance as well but with the amenities (chairs, beer, snacks, etc) this one has basically all you'll need, including on occasion, donkeys on the beach. Oh yeah, watch out for the couple foot wide stingray that swims up and down the water line on a regular basis. Make sure you plan ahead if you want a car for a day or two as they can get a bit scarce.
I read many reviews before selecting the estate and the only negative I could find was some people felt the breakfast fell short from what they expected. Let me address this quickly. No, you will not have a menu with a bunch of different choices for your breakfast, again, this is not a hotel. You will have some really good french toast, fresh fruit, juice, and coffee on a wonderful open air patio overlooking the bay. This is a simple and convenient way to get a little food in you and check in with the hosts or fellow visitors in regard to any plans for the day before setting out on your adventure for the day. For us this was perfect (and the french toast was REALLY good) but if you want that fancier breakfast with a bloody or mimosa at some point there are several choices for that just down that hill you're on.
I also read some reviews discussing the small pool. This is a small estate, the pool is plenty big and out of six days I think we had company down there once. Additionally the honor bar is down there to keep you from getting thirsty while you sit in the water looking out over the bay.
There is so much more I could add as advice after having experienced this wonderful place for a week but learning was half the fun so go ahead, pull the trigger and visit the Estate Lindholm, you will not be disappointed and while you're there make sure you say hi to Leo who works on the grounds, great guy and if you're lucky he just might bring you a fresh mango.