Bill R.
Yelp
So happy to return to the Excelsior Gallia in the Milan. We stayed here for 3 nights September 10-13. This was not our first stay (see previous review). When we found ourselves returning to Milan, the choice was easy. Unfortunately, this stay did not live up to its 5 STAR reputation. I booked an Excelsior room months in advance; I'm also a Marriott Platinum Premier Elite member. SPG and Marriott finally integrated to one system early August. My accounts were linked/merged, and my reservation showed up in my app under my Marriott Rewards #. The first indication something wasn't right is when we checked in. While I was promptly greeted, I was not recognized for my Platinum Status, no upgrade offered, and the agent was quick to point out that breakfast was not included in the rate. I mentioned that I was a Platinum member and wanted daily breakfast as my amenity. I was told that my status was not showing on the reservation. Once he entered my number, my status was recognized and was handed a voucher to show at breakfast. He was also quick to point out that perhaps my rewards number dropped off due to the systems integration. I asked that now he had my correct status if any upgrades were available, I was told no. Not a very good customer experience.We were in room 414. A nice room, just like the excelsior room we had prior minus a small patio. There was a beautiful cake on a silver platter for our anniversary. This was a very nice gesture and greatly appreciated. Things went downhill or downstream the next morning. In less than 5 minutes in the shower, the shower water had flooded halfway through the bathroom. I was able to pop the filter off the drain and guide the water with my foot towards it, but it was backed up. The smell was terrible. It smelled like something foul was in there. I quickly finished and grabbed every towel - all beyond saturated with water. I quickly called to report the problem and ask for more towels. Maintenance came and said they needed to pour some acid down the drain and that would take care of it. After waiting 20 plus minutes, Same thing. It was not fixed.Prior to leaving for our day, we spoke to Chiara (sorry for misspelling) at the front desk to report the issue. She was very apologetic and professional. She told us she would get on it right away and give us an update later in the day. Later that afternoon, Chiara called and said they are not able to fix it, and the room was not operable. She said she had the Signature Suite available for us when we returned for our last 2 nights.Chiara walked us up to personally check us in the room.The Signature Suite located on the 5th floor is beautiful. Living room, sitting chairs, separate bedroom, his and her closets, makeup area separate from bathroom, one large bathroom and a smaller one in the hallway. Two separate Patios - one off the bedroom, one off the living room. The first night, I decided to have a bath. The first 10-15 seconds of turning on the faucet, the water was a light brown/rust color. The bathroom also has a musty smell. Our last night, I was awakened by a loud noise that came from the bathroom. In the morning, I was greeted by a puddle of dirty water on the floor and the vent from the Ceiling was on the floor. It had fallen from the wall with a surge of water. We couldn't believe it. 2 rooms, similar experiences.Facilities were great as last time. This is why we returned. I would also like to recognize Marcello in the breakfast room. We enjoyed seeing him again on this visit. He is a true professional and all about the customer experience. Sorry Excelsior, Love the property, but this was not a good customer experience. In fact - I never heard from any member from management regarding the issues and the inconveniences we experienced. How could a guest be checked into a room where the bathroom was inoperable? Surely this was not a new issue, with a backup this severe, there had to have been some prior reports. We do look forward to a future stay and hopefully more of a 5 Star experience.