Faicco's Sandwich Shop

I don’t understand any good reviews of this place at all. Absolutely disgusting food. My family ate there two weeks ago. I wasn’t going to write a review, but I’m still appalled that we spent $130 on five sandwiches, two sides and one drink, and none of our sandwiches were edible. I’m not a picky person. I’m usually the garbage disposal that if someone doesn’t like their food.. I’ll say.. it’s fine! I’ll eat it. The bread is super hard.. not a crunchy exterior loaf.. just hard. The bread to meat ratio is waaay off.. like 3:1. Sandwiches super dry. The meats on the classic Italian and the Reuben smelled off. Not quite yet turned, but somewhat acidic implying they were nearly expired. The Reuben was absolutely disgusting. Who serves a Reuben on a hard hoagie roll? The pastrami was fatty, rubbery, the smell made my stomach turn. I have never had the experience where every single one of us hated our sandwich’s. And for $18 a sandwich.. you don’t even get a pickle or a tiny slaw. Just gross. The only thing we liked were the fries. I’m too forgiving, esp with family businesses, to ask for my money back.. but I feel like a complete sucker for paying $130 for absolute garbage.

Best sandwich in Sarasota hands down. I'm not a sandwich person but love this place. The crust is perfectly toasted but not too hard- so many sandwich options and rich flavors. 10/10 recommend

If you're looking for a sandwich made with love, you found your place. Eddie, Lisa, and staff were all great. Closest thing I could find to a Philly Roast Pork, and it was delicious. Went back for an Italian Sub, and it was great as well. Will be my go-to for now on.

My experience with Faicco's is looks can be deceiving. I did not dine in at this restaurant, instead it was delivered to my office as take-out. The burger and fries both looked good when I opened the container but that is where it went downhill. I will give the fries a pass regarding their sogginess. This is because I know that between the time the order was boxed and delivered I can imagine the steam within the container probably is what made them soggy. They did have a good flavor, however. The real issue was with the burger. For me a burger should be cooked well-done. This burger was as pink as it could probably be without being raw. It may not look that pink in the photograph, but the picture definitely does not show how bad it really was. Sorry to say but you cannot blame that on the same issue the fries had. Just to clarify for the owner...I DID ask for the burger to be well done, just as I do at every restaurant I go to where I order a burger. It was not me not asking, it was the cook not following through on the request. Anyone who reads the countless reviews I have posted knows I do not leave reviews I feel are not justified based on my experience. That being said, my office ordered from Faicco's again today (May 9, 2025) and the burger was well-done as ordered. To that end, I have upped my review to a 3-star review.

The food was okay & good to a certain extent BUT way too overpriced! $18 for the sandwich that's ridiculous! & $8 for 5 mozzarella sticks is crazy too. I wouldn't go back bcuz the prices are way too high for average food. Good luck staying in business with those prices!

Absolutely everything was delish and the service was over the top! We would definitely return here and we recommend it to others. They even gave our kids shirts. Perfect place after a trip to the beach. Faicco team, thanks for the great experience.

Fast and friendly service, HUGE sandwiches! Four of us and everyone was very happy. Great selection too! Seating is an enclosed outdoor area and cooler, but they turned patio heaters on for us.

Well…this might be the last review. Apparently they’re closing (permanently) today. Really disappointing as this was my first and only time here. Fantastic deli - our foods was excellent despite certain items falling g off the menu as thy sell out their remaining inventory. You will be missed. Thank you.

If you're hunting for a place that delivers on big flavor and cozy charm, Faicco's Sandwich Shop is a must-visit. Tucked away like a true hole-in-the-wall gem, it radiates that old-school Italian vibe, complete with warm, welcoming family hospitality. I kicked off the meal with their rice balls, and let me tell you--perfection. Golden and crisp on the outside, creamy and cheesy on the inside, they hit every mark. The cheese pull? Absolutely next level. For the main event, I dove into the Italian sandwich, and wow--this one's a standout. The bread had just the right crunch while still being soft inside, perfectly hugging layers of the finest meats. Every bite was a mix of savory, fresh, and satisfying. But the real star for me was the Chicken Fra Diavolo sandwich. Picture tender, crispy chicken smothered in their house-made vodka sauce, topped with gooey, fresh mozzarella that stretches like a dream. It's rich, spicy, cheesy, and everything a sandwich should aspire to be. While I didn't save room for dessert, Faicco's more than made up for it with an experience that feels like stepping into an Italian family kitchen--unpretentious, authentic, and brimming with flavor. Would I come back? 100%. Whether you're a foodie or just hungry, Faicco's makes you feel at home with every bite. Don't sleep on this spot!

BAMN! Best Italian subs I've had here since New York. Absolutely delicious, EVERYTHING about it was fresh and sooo tasty! I got the Chicken Cutlet w/Prosciutto, Fresh Mozzarella and Pesto on a sesame seed Italian sub roll. EVERYONE was amazingly friendly and engaged in conversation when possible. I went in about 1:30pm on a Wednesday and only had 1 person in front of me. It is what it is! A sandwich shop that has amazing food, even take-home! There was also seating outside. Every place I looked was clean and I CAN'T WAIT to go back and try EVERYTHING on the menu. I can't believe that I've lived here for 7 years and never even heard about them. They are now COMPLETELY on my radar and I will recommend to anyone!

Delicious as usual. Second time having their eggplant parmigiana dish, take h in e and heat up. Will always come here!

Food is without question, excellent. Lots of sandwich choices, with fresh breads, and a slew of Italian combinations. The service is as good as can be expected in an incredibly busy deli. Seating is outside and comfy but can be a bit hot in a Florida summer. This is a great grab and go spot, and the sandwiches are fantastic. Go!

Takeout from Faicco's- hot heroes made it 40 minutes home and still hot and fresh. Service is always friendly and Eddie the owner is in there working hard! So lucky to have a great New York style deli in the area- their original location is in Manhattan, NY so this is such a treat here in SRQ!

Okay place. The sandwiches are much too big. Went once and haven't been back, it's just too much to eat. Zero atmosphere, you eat outside in the parking lot. No service, you get it yourself.

$44.00 for a submarine sandwich and pastrami sandwich!!!! Ouch. The pastrami sandwich was oozing grease and came with inedible soggy fries. Absolutely ridiculous. We DO NOT recommend.

Hmm not sure what happened to the bread? It's not as fresh and crunchy as it normally is. Hope the original recipe/baker/supplier returns. I couldn't get past not having crunchy bread

Great food! Easy take out, but what's up with the limited hours? How do people stay in business? Anyway, I hope Faicco's does!! Thank you

Beyond thrilled that my favorite sandwich shop in New York opened up a second location in Sarasota. The sandwiches are HUGE (enough for two meals or three). My favorite is the Italian Hero. Do yourself a favor and check this place out!

This place knows how to make some amazing food. This was my third time here and I've never been disappointed. From the meatball sub to the Cuban... they never miss. The Italian ice is top tier. The customer service is so friendly. Perfect place for a world class sandwich. Perfect shady area to eat with lots of fans so it never gets hot. 10/10 amazing

Eggplant Parm and chicken parm Sub very good! Love the French bread and the breaded eggplant was just right. Only can finish half since the sandwich is plenty for two to eat !

Subs are substantial, hard to eat all at once, but delicious. Staff is friendly and accommodating. I didn't see a sausage's part on the menu, but it hey made on up with a choice of sweet or mild. Good spot.

The hubby and I went to Faicco's for a lunch date. We shared the roast pork with broccoli rabe and sharp provolone on a seeded roll & rice balls. Everything was delicious. The sandwich was pricey but HUGE. We very much enjoyed our lunch.

I was so excited about this sandwich it was so heavy and so big. They had put a little mustard on it no mayo and very heavy on the pepper no oregano and only oil I was getting was from the peppers it needed that extra moisture of oil and vinegar and mayo to bring it all together and not be so dry We did get the rice balls and they were very good

Hefty sandwich Today was my first visit to Faicco's. With so many positive thoughtful reviews, this must be a surefire winner. I already knew the layout from when it was the hot dog place, so I headed in and ordered at the counter. Great interactions while I quickly looked at the overhead menu and ordered their Italian Hero and quickly changed to their Spicy Italian Hero. I paid, they gave me my drink and a number to place on my table, and I went outside. They have lots of tables and there are very big fans to help keep it more comfortable in the summer heat. Even though it's only April. My hefty sandwich was brought out, cut in two halves. One half was enough for me, I'll join the chorus of two meal sandwiches. I might have been able to pull it off, but I really had no need to. Initially I thought the sandwich was dry. I'm used to Italian subs being drenched in oil and vinegar, and this sandwich had little oil and I didn't taste any vinegar. After a while I appreciated tasting other flavors, including whatever made it spicy. Anyway, steeped in history, I'm going to assume they know exactly how this NYC sandwich should be and I'm just a happy passenger.

Ordered Italian Hero. Took one bite and something tasted rotten. Took the meat off and ate the cheese. The next morning I had food poisoning. I don't know if they use Boars Head deli meats or not, but I will never eat there again. This happened about a month ago.

Honestly I'm a Sandwhich fiend, I love sandwiches and subs and paninis. But this place the sandwiches had no love, no flavor, nothing. They tasted like bread with something in the middle for texture. The service is very abrupt and not entirely polite I'd say. The place is mostly to go orders and outdoor seating. I truly wanted to like this place, but like I said lack of flavor left me and my friends wanting more. All of us had to use hot sauce to give the sandwich flavor. Which is shocking because the prices on these sandwiches was not cheap. Many were above $12-15 each. I say pass and go to a different sandwich place. I feel bad saying that since it looked family run, but I can't justify the price or flavor unfortunately.

The chicken pesto sandwhich is one of the better sandwiches I've tried. We've had other sandwiches here and they've all been good but that's what I'll be ordering moving forward from here it's great

This was a small spot where ordering takes place at the counter. There were a few tables to sit at as well. They had a number of different sandwiches to choose from as well as a few appetizers such as rice balls and mozzarella sticks. I went with the Spicy Italian ($16). It came with hot coopa, ham cappy, hot soppressata, mozzarella, lettuce, tomato, hot vinegar peppers with olive oil and vinegar. This was absolutely stuffed and came in weighing about a pound in a half. There was a nice mix of all the meats. The peppers added the spicy factor. The bread also held up nicely with the abundance of toppings. I would have preferred a sliced provolone cheese, however. I also tried the muffuletta which came with Toscana salami, Genoa salami, hot soppressata, provolone cheese, olive spread and pepperoncini. This was also very tasty. The olive spread went nicely with the meats and provolone. The Cuban was the final sandwich I tried. It was a special on the particular day I attended. It was another satisfying sandwich. The bread was nicely toasted and there were a ton of pickles present. Will I go back? No doubt.

Faicco's is the new hotspot in Sarasota and for good reason. These are authentic generously proportioned gourmet Italian (New York) style subs. Quality. They also have some dessert and beverage options. Pretty primo. A sandwich runs about $16 in 2022 but the value is there for the quality and quantity of ingredients be they roasted red peppers, fresh mozzarella, or prosciutto. It's a casual affair with a nice casual seating area picnic style and covered. I would probs call in my order so you don't have to wait. The shopping center it shares with a Mexican market that includes baked goods and a pet supply store. The Mexican market has some good stuff to try. Parking by the pet store is for its customers only. Definitely a welcome addition to the foodie scene in Sarasota.

Would really like to give them 4 1/2 stars Nice clean place Nice seating area outside Have had several of their sandwiches and have also ordered platters for home parties...they are Good They also have some prepared foods in the fridge that are also Good The sandwiches are Pricey I absolutely love Italian Ice, however theirs is Just OK, not the best. Really had hoped it would be Will I be back for the sandwiches & the prepared food...Yes

Was curious to check out the place that replaced the hot dog joint that used to occupy the space. Faicco's did not disappoint. Bread was crusty and fresh. Meat on the Cuban was super flavorful. Subs were served steaming hot. They have a nice kitchen work space where you can see them assemble these inspired sandwiches. There seemed some pride of place in both the food and in the physical space that they've set up for serious sandwich work--both for making them and for serving them. They come wrapped tight in wax paper, perfect for serious eating. Recommended.

Stopped here on our way to the beach in Siesta Key and my lord, this deli is absolutely INCREDIBLE. They simply could not miss, so glad I found this place. For those that know of this place in Sarasota, you are incredibly lucky. We started out ordering some of the fried raviolis, amazing. Perfectly fried and the marinara sauce it came with was spot on deliciousness as well. We also got the Sausage Rolls, simply even more amazing. They were sweet sausage, generous portions, 4 pieces for 6 bucks? Sign me up everyday for that and I will carry it home. We are on the patio and another gentlemen eating couldn't help but notice how good they looked and ask me what they were. For the grand finale we got the Chicken Prosciutto Mozzerella sub, so good I mistakenly forgot to take a picture. It was a massive sub, more than enough to split with someone or have lunch for 2 days. Service was friendly, they even bring your food out to you on the patio. Faiccos you are amazing, check this place out!!

Amazing sandwiches, toasted ravioli (my favorite & so happy to find it in FL), rice balls and prosciutto bread (my husband's favorite) everything was sooo fresh. Can't wait to go back!

When your logo has a pig on it, how can you go wrong. I split the Italian sub and it was terrific. Good bread, seasoned just right and tasty meat. Like you've read, the sandwiches are gigantic. It can easily feed three normal eating people. Service was fast and friendly. Definitely will be coming back.

I came here in a whim after remembering they were open to fuel up on what was going to be an afternoon of shipping during holiday season. I ordered a eggplant sandwich and my companion ordered a porchetta with sun dried tomato sandwich. We opted to eat there in a covered patio area adjacent to the parking lot. The staff was great, cordial, and as efficient as possible. The sandwiches were brought out to us upon completion. They had fans going for circulation and some music. The bread was quite good, it had a nice density and texture and the contents of the sandwiches were delicious. I also like that they used high quality fresh mozzarella that got melty when toasted. Upon doing some research I found that the owners have an original location in NYC. Check it out for yourself and let me know how you like it!

The portion size is crazy. I could only eat 1/2 the sandwich. Having more than 1 size would be a good idea as leftover sandwiches to me are usually soggy. I liked the crunch on the bread. Chicken Parmesan was good but the marina sauce could have more flavor. I think the Italian should have a hot version. Mozzarella was very fresh.

If you like it big well this is gonna be your next favorite spot! High quality meats and huge portions and delicious bread . what more could you ask for? check out our video review here https://youtu.be/eX555ytqdNs follow us on facebook at Out & About Media Instagram outandaboutwithtylerbutler

This is the real deal. If you're from NY you know the original Faicco's in NYC. Well, they've brought the greatness to Sarasota. The location is easy with ample parking and outdoor seating. The inside is tight, but just order at the counter and they'll bring it out to you. We came around 11:30am on a weekday and we were in and out in 10 minutes. The menu has so many delicious options. A few porchetta options, several with chicken cutlet, Italians, sausage, Parms and then some traditional like an American or roast beef. There is surely something for everyone. They use fresh mozzarella on most of their sandwiches and it's the real deal. I went with my brother and fiancé and we got a pesto chicken with cutlet, fresh mozz and pesto, a porchetta with homemade porchetta, fresh mozz, bacon and sun dried tomatoes and a spicy Italian. They were incredible. None of us could agree which we liked the most, they were all that good. We were each only able to eat half and had half for the next day. Packed high, no skimping here. Great bread, great meat and fresh mozz. Wow. Prices are good for the quality here - I'd be shocked if somebody could eat one of these sandwiches themselves in one sitting. They range from $13-$16 but for two meals I think it's a steal. My family is all from NY and we were wishing a real NY sandwich shop would open here and now we have to wish no more. This is the real deal. Check them out asap!

Oh my god. This place is absolutely amazing. I'm so happy it gets as busy as it does. Got there around 1 pm and we waited about 45 minutes. I would gladly wait 4 hours just to eat that sandwich again. I got the classic- the mozzarella is creamy, the prosciutto is soft & salty, and that bread is crispy & crunchy. I added mayo & lettuce because I can't have a sandwich without them. Absolutely heavenly. I loved watching the people work and you could tell who the owners were. However, every single person that was working behind that counter could have been the owners they took so much pride in their work. I can not recommend this place enough. Please visit and support Sarasota's local business! This family has a great restaurant and I will be a regular now.

Wow. You get what you pay for. Monstrous hoagie. Enough for2 people. I ordered the Italian , loved the bread and fresh cut meat. If your in the mood for a quality hoagie, the Faicco's is your spot. Bring your appetite I'm looking forward to trying more

Thank you Eddie @faiccos_sarasota! Had the Italian hero, rice balls and prosciutto ball and thought I was back in NY! The bread on the sandwich was amazing and enough meat for every bite! Rice balls were perfect with the yummy sauce. Hubby and I sat and enjoyed our sandwich while listening to a great Playlist. Enjoyed our conversations with Eddie. God bless America and keep making those delicious sandwiches. Will definitely be back for the Porchetta, anything with broccoli rabe and Italian sausage ring. YUM! So glad and grateful for the good old Italian deli/pork store.

Ok third time is a charm.....,NO! Save your money. If you are in need of lots of food then this your place. If you want good food.......eat somewhere else. Place is terrible.

Absolutely delicious sandwiches! Interesting combinations, great bread! Can't wait to go back!

Incredibly good tasting chicken parmesan sandwich. Also ordered sausage rolls. Yumm-O!! Sandwich is huge! Sadly, didn't see an option to purchase a half, or combine two halves on the menu. Seems way overpriced ($48 for a 2 hoagie sandwich lunch) even though it was very tasty. I would have liked a lot more sauce on my slightly dry sandwich. And I couldn't tell the cheese run off from the paper wrapping. (They are identical in color). The light coat of breading on the chicken was perfect tho. Eating outside in FL is always tricky. This visit was very hot and moist. Standing fans seemed to create more noise than comfort. BUT... it is worth the time to go and eat there! Friendly, helpful, and courteous staff made sure we got refills and answered our many questions.

Awesome Italian sub. It took me 3 days to finish. Eager to go back and try the rest of the menu.

Excellent food. Stopped in first time. Tried two sandwiches as it was hard to make up our minds. Had the chicken parm hero and the one with roasted red peppers and prosciutto and fresh made mozzarella. The one with red peppers and prosciutto was a clear winner. And fresh mozzarella makes a huge difference in thr taste and quality. Everything went together perfectly. Size of sandwiches were huge and while it seemed pricey at first it felt like good value for the money. I had read a complaint about portion size before and my opinion is that they could have charged less and given half the sandwich but probably more would complain that the sandwiches are too small. So with that we had NO issues. Service was great! Food was great! Portions were great! I cannot wait to try them again! The American was calling my name. Personally we will share next time as we felt we had to eat more just because they were so good and we were not going home. 2 thumbs up for sure!!!!

A first timer, made a great choice with Porchetta with broccoli rabe. The bread has such a nice crust to hold the meat that melts really. A great effing sandwich okay. I demolished the zucchini sticks before I could get a pic.

The extensive menu of heros at this family owned restaurant is welcomed amongst a sea of sandwiches that miss the mark. The first thing I noticed was that the two Italian men behind the counter slice the meat to order and pile it up on a fresh roll with all of the stuff you'd expect. The service was also top notch since the woman running the cash register is Tina Faicco herself alongside her husband - I asked how to pronounce the name and I still can't say it lol- Along with the Italian Hero, I got a mortadella hero as well which has arugula on it- that was the perfect complement- foodies take note. Two heros could easily feed four adults ! I can't wait to go back and try more items on their menu. My order was takeout but they do have a large covered area outside and a few tables out front - Just remember, they are closed on Sundays.

Cute deli sandwich shop. The staff seems friendly enough although I cant say I felt like anyone really wanted to be there? Maybe its a NY thing. They were nice enough. Prices are a little high for sandwiches but they're huge. Enough to split for two meals. I got a rueben on rye, which was great. My husband got the american, which was huge. I tried it and my sandwich was better. He was happy though. Wouldnt call it the best Ive ever had but it was good and filling. Thanks yall.

Terrible Hamburger for $14....overcooked and meat vs filler combination was very unappetizing. French fries were greasy and tasteless. Took long time for it to be cooked.

Just opened 10/24/22. This is going to do well. Eddie, the owner, moved here from NY, where he was rocking The Village with his great hero sandwiches and Italian specialties for 25 years. We went for lunch: I had Mortadella, Ham and Mozzarella with Arugula on a fresh hoagie roll, my wife had an Eggplant Parm sandwich. Your jaws will get some exercise opening wide enough for these killer sandwiches. Both sandwiches were straight-up delicious. My wife proclaimed hers the best eggplant parm sandwich she's ever had. Prices may look high for a sandwich, but know that we both stopped after finishing the first half. So come very hungry, or know that you are getting two meals! The value is there 100%. All the seating is outside, most under cover. There is also real Italian Ice available, which looked really good. That will be happening on our next visit, which will be soon! Welcome to SRQ, Eddie!

We saw all the social media posts about this place a few days ago and couldn't get there fast enough. We arrived before 11:00 on Saturday and people were already piling in, and for good reason, the sandwiches are out of this world. We ordered the meatball sub and the Italian hero. Both were enough to feed two people each! We are so excited to have a place like this in Southgate and cannot wait to go back and try more items on the menu!!!

We could not wait to try this place each time we went they were closed. I finally found their hours and they close most days at 6 pm and closed on Sundays. My husband ordered a prosciutto ball and we shared a spicy Italian. Well worth the money however I really only had one complaint which is the sandwich was on the dry side. I just added some sub dressing when I got home. The cashier was nice however no one greeted us when we walked in. The place was clean and looked much better than the last place that was at the location. I love that everything is freshly sliced. Initially it seems expensive but where can 2 people eat for less than $20? The sandwich is large enough to share.

This place is absolutely outstanding! The sandwiches are delicious! I usually have The Pesto Chicken! The service is always excellent! The ambiance is very friendly! This is the only place around where you can get a damn good Hero!

I sometimes drive 45 minutes for a sandwich from this place, that's now good it is. Faicco's has the sharpest provolone, the freshest bread, the highest quality meats. This restaurant is the reason I like mortadella. We get the Mortadella #1, the Chicken Parm (the true test of an Italian deli!), and the Italian sandwich. The rice balls are also 10/10. They have great specials too, so ask if you are ordering over the phone. A must try in the Sarasota area.

Ordered three sandwiches. Spicy Italian- perfect! Italian Roast Beef- damn good , a little too much sundried but still amazing. American very good - American cheese coulda been better quality but still great. Will definitely be back to try the Pastrami.

I had the hot Italian sausage with broccoli rob, which was so good and it was enough for two meals. I also tried their hotdog which had a nice crunch and very flavorful. My guest for lunch had the Italian and I got to taste by and it was out of this world! I highly recommend you try this place get there early because there will be a line