Fisherman Guesthouse Suðureyri

The town is lovely. We stopped here as part of a tour.The accommodations are mediocre. The room had a strong odor and couldn't open the windows because There was a festival going until the wee hours of the night right outside our window. Zero sleep. Breakfast was awful. They put out rotten fruit on the display to be eaten.

Both dishes were satisfying and well-prepared — the lamb was tender, well-marinated, and rich in flavor, while the fish and chips were perfectly crispy, served with a tangy sauce and fresh salad. A hearty and comforting meal overall.

We wish we had more days here. Perfect guesthouse in a picturesque town. We had a late check in after 12:00 am the attendant was kind enough to wait for us; they also put an instruction note stuck on the door, in case, we were too late. The beds were comfortable and the room had an electric kettle, sturdy table, WiFi was great and lastly the attached bathroom was cherry on top. We booked through booking.com and the rate included breakfast (served between 7 to 10 am). There were moderate food options and the coffee was good. You can also buy souvenirs from here :)

We stopped here during an excursion from our cruise ship. This place has friendly service, is clearly used by locals, and has bathrooms. The beverage selection is limited but of high quality.

If I spot “fish of the day” on a menu, chances are high that’s what I’m ordering. It’s usually the freshest thing the kitchen has to offer—and in a charming fishing village like Suðureyri, the fish was probably caught just a few hours earlier. At Fisherman, the fish of the day was excellent: perfectly pan-fried cod with a tasty caper sauce and creamy mashed potatoes. The guesthouse is warm, welcoming, and easy to recommend—just the kind of place that makes you feel right at home.

Went in their little restaurant across the street from the guest house. Had really great cherry cake and espresso, nice people.

lovely little place. simplistic, yes, and smells a bit of fish in the eating area, but for a town small as this it's a great experience

We had dinner at the Fisherman and stayed overnight and had breakfast at the hotel of the same name. Dinner: We had Fish & Chips, the catch of the day, and homemade rhubarb cake for dessert. The fish was really tender and excellent. The price-quality ratio is good. The staff was really very friendly and helpful. We would definitely recommend it. Hotel: The negative reviews on Google surprised us before arrival, but the rooms were really great, clean, and looked new. There is a shared bathroom with a shower and toilet. Despite the peak season, the hotel was not full. Breakfast: Breakfast is offered in the restaurant across the street and consisted of a sufficient and good breakfast buffet. All in all, definitely recommend!