Michael T.
Yelp
This review is hard to write because based on the location, advertised amenities, and the great reviews and photos on Yelp I had high hopes that I'd have an insanely wonderful weekend staying here. That said, this is a solid 3.5 and that's because a few things just left me feeling like the value proposition here was a little off and left me wanting a little more to push it reach four stars.
The location of the Franciscan is tough to beat, and sets you down in a spot far enough from the crowds where you can enjoy a quieter and more local Tahoe experience.
The accommodations are nice too. Cabin vibes abound whether you're on the lakeside of the lodge or just across the street by the pool. We had a one bedroom on the pool side and the living area is quite large with a sofa and loveseat that turn down to a bed, while the bedroom was actually quite small but adequate for two people.
The refrigerator and freezer were residential sized, perfect if you're staying a while or just want to keep a lot of beverages cold. There was also a stove and microwave available, and all the utensils, glasses and plates you could need, which was greatly appreciated. I'm glad the room had a coffee maker, but they only put one packet of coffee in the room, and that packet had a coffee pod inside versus filters and coffee. I brought my own coffee, but I didn't pack filters so I couldn't enjoy it. Due to COVID there was no housekeeping so the coffee wasn't replenished, though I'm sure I could have asked for another.
The bed itself was a disappointment. I was expecting a Queen and it felt like a full. The mattress was also pretty firm and just not really comfortable. The pillows were all different, some lumpy and uncomfortable while others were just fine. The sheets were kinda scratchy too.
The lodge doesn't have AC in the room, which isn't abnormal for the area, but we were there during a summer weekend and despite having all of the windows and doors open during the cooler hours and running a box fan in the doorway and window to draw the cool air in, the room would not cool down. Despite the warnings from the front desk about keeping windows closed at night to avoid issues with bears we had to open them, and even with them open in the dead of night, the room wouldn't cool down either. The evenings were incredibly uncomfortable.
I loved that the pool side of the resort had several picnic areas with gas grills so you could enjoy the outdoors and cookout with the family while on vacation. The open space was also nice for kids to runaround, ride bikes etc.
The pool was great. A large concrete deck with great lounge chairs and small tables, shade, and sunny spots too. While the pool was advertised as heated, it was actually pretty chilly. After some time in the water it was more enjoyable but it certainly shocked the system.
Staying in Tahoe, access to a private beach is what you want and Franciscan offers some great beach frontage and a private pier to take in the lake. But the amenities kinda end there. We didn't find many or any beach chairs, loungers, or umbrellas out for guests, and that's surprising considering guests are visiting from all over and aren't necessarily coming with their beach gear. The Franciscan beachfront looked especially bare when yiu looked just down the beach at the wonderful amenities of the Martis Camp beach club and Mourelatos. You couldn't help but be envious of the guests enjoying the amenities at those places. Adding this to the lodge seems like something that would greatly enhance the guest experience for a modest investment.
All in all, a solid 3.5 star experience, and while the stay was enjoyable and the service very nice, I can't go to four stars because there were too many little things that made the experience less than ideal for me.