Dee-Dee S.
Yelp
I can speak intelligently on both sides of the street. First, the original (smaller, bakerylike). Their items are so unbelievably fresh. It's immaculate in there. Freshest and most appetizing displays. I have had many of the bakery items. Among my absolute favorites are: the blueberry muffins, salted pecan bar, and coconut macaroons (best I have ever had).
Often, I have taken breads, bakery, and other pantry items home. Best ever, Michigan Mud Pie. Omg, it is wonderful. Had it for friends over for dinner. Everyone raved. I served it with homemade whipped cream.
Now, across the street, the larger restaurant with more of a sit down presence and far more deli and pantry items...
My family and I go here a lot. The food is so unbelievably good. We end up getting the same thing everytime, but all three of us get something different. I would be just as happy to with anything on the menu, but I am in love with the Peanut Noodle. The flavors compliment each other perfectly. It is seriously one of the most delicious lunch items I have ever had... anywhere. My son always gets the shrimp po boy, and my husband, the burger which he claims might be the best burger he's ever had. Potato salad and chips are also excellent.
We eat out a lot. We are from Chicago and have lived in crazy foodie cities. This place is so worth the visit.
One piece of advice. I think a lot of people here are on vacation and aren't necessarily in a hurry. I work in the heart of downtown Chicago where the pace is crazy. The service is a bit slow and laid back here, so be patient with a more slow placed level of service. It's always been pleasant enough, but they get busy. Really busy. And I do think sometime the staff is flustered, it i have never mistaken that for unpleasantness.