Good Guys Pizza

Definitely the BEST pizza not only in North Tonawanda but I’d say the whole Buffalo area! Fresh ingredients, delicious sauce, crust is soft where it should be and crunchy where you want it! Love this place! Bravo 👍

OMG!!!! If your into cheesy pizza with a thick crust. Then you have to come here, and enjoy this deliciousness. Every bite was a enjoyable one. I really like the slight sweetness of the crust. Even the sauce was just right, not to bitter and not to sweet.

I placed an order for two subs and one appetizer I was given the time 20 minutes I showed up 25 minutes later Only the appetizer was complete. Not a problem. As another customer enters Good guys two employees engage in a conversation and completely ignore the subs that were placed In front of them after about 10 minutes I step to the counter and ask if my order was complete and a when I got the attention of a different employee they stated “it just came out “ As I sat there for the entirety of the conversation and watched the subs be placed on the warming racks

First time trying Good Guys and the pizza was seriously disgusting. The goey dough wasn’t cooked and separated itself from the thick layer of cheese. The pepperoni looked like the kind anyone could buy from any grocery store. They also didn’t even cut it.

We love good guys pizza. They are about the only place left that gives you a generous portion of everything you order. You don't have to order extra sauce or cheese and the pizza is fluffy and thick and also very consistent! It looks almost identical everytime we come! We ordered a small cheese and pepperoni and it was delicious as usual!

I grew up down the road and spent a good decade eating here. I don't live in the area anymore but always stop by when I'm in town. The last few times we waited over an hr for tiny chicken fingers and got sick to our stomachs both times. Time to stick a fork in this place, something has obviously changed.

Definitely the best pizza in the north towns. A little pricey but well worth it when you see what you get. Loads of cheese and pepperoni. Don't even think about ordering double of any toppings. You don't need to. They load them on.

We drove 30 mins from s buffalo to try this pizza. Wow! We will be back! Absolutely amazing

Looking at my previous review for Good Guys Pizza, it's been almost three years since I've been back... I didn't keep my promise of coming back sooner, but, I'm happy to say their pizza is still just as awesome, and filling! I called on a Saturday a little after 4:30pm and was put on a brief hold (less than 30 seconds) before a gentleman took my order. He was courteous enough but seemed a little rigid, like he hadn't answered phones for Good Guys before but as I mentioned, he was courteous enough and made sure my order was correct and that he took my name down. The wait for the pizza was a little longer than I'm used to, where he gave me an exact time of 5:20pm it'd be ready. I arrived closer to 5:30pm to a pretty packed parking lot, and a bevy of people inside. The parking lot is relatively small but there's plenty of parking on the street if/when necessary. Even with their lobby packed, the line moved pretty fast - I was in and out within five minutes. For dinner, I ordered a small (13", six slice) Steak Pizza, which is an olive oil base (no red sauce) with rib-eye steak that is laid over top topped with diced tomatoes, garlic, Romano cheese, then Swiss cheese, American cheese, Mozzarella cheese, mushrooms, onions, and banana peppers. One of my favorite aspects of a Good Guy's pizza is the cook on the dough and their crispy, crunchy, perfectly cooked crust! It's definitely a Buffalo-style dough that is incredibly sturdy and holds firm with the crazy number of toppings and cheese over top. Good Guys' steak pizza is definitely one of my favorites, the olive oil and garlic come through but the number of veggies that are paired with the rib-eye steak are so good! The tomatoes and mushrooms are certainly a nice, unexpected addition I didn't know I wanted. I worked up a REALLY BIG appetite and devoured this pizza but be prepared, Good Guys serves up one of the heaviest pizzas in WNY (in my opinion) and I'm totally here for it! Of all the specialty pizzas on their menu, the steak pizza is the most expensive but to me, definitely worth it. I'm happy to see (and eat!) Good Guys Pizza is still out here serving up delicious, heavy pizza! It's nice to know I can count on them still to cook up a delicious and very filling pizza.

Good Guys has the best specialty pizzas! Turkey club wrap is delicious as well. If anything is ever messed up, they are quick to make it right!!!

The pizza is always consistently good. They do not skimp on the toppings and this has become our new favorite pizza. This place is serving really great pies. The sauce and dough are top notch and the toppings are also fresh and good quality.

Best pizza around, top notch service. Got a half tray chicken finger pizza was cooked to perfection chicken fingers were perfectly sauce with a blue cheese base sauce and dough was cooked with a nice crisp and good crunch on the handle.

Best pizza in North Tonawanda! The sweet sauce is incredible! There's never any leftovers as I just can't stop eating it whenever we order from there!

My go to place for lunch. 2 slices and a 20oz pop is under $10.00, and the slices are large and LOADED with cheese and toppings. Sauce is delicious! Always friendly staff, and service is always quick. Get there for your slices! IMO you won't be disappointed.

Gotta love a good cheese and pepperoni slice and mozzarella sticks. The staff are very friendly. Not a sit down place but definitely my favorite place for takeout pizza.

Small cheese & pep 10/10 Absolutely love how thick the cheese is. I like that they use regular pepperoni instead of your typical Buffalo cup and char. The sauce is just slightly on the sweeter side, which I love. I'm not a crust person, but the crust is also pretty good if you have some blue cheese to dip it in. Delicious pizza!

A 1/2 tray is 12 slices. 12 slices were 6.5 lbs with the box. Half pound pizza slices. Seriously. I'm Sicilian, so I'm all about the crust. This one has the crispy edges and bottom, plus the chewy inside edge. Sauce is a little sweet, but not overly so. I'd say this is as close to pizza perfection I've found in the area. We ordered regular cheese, pepperoni, and mushroom. The order was perfect, timely, and the service was friendly.

Ordered two sheet pizzas for Halloween for a teacher lunch in my classroom and everyone was raving on how tasty this pizza was. I pre-ordered the two sheets because I know Halloween is a busy day for pizza. Good Guys had the two sheets ready to go on time and even gave us some paper plates. You can tell this pizza is good quality and the toppings are fresh. My favorite is the pepper & mushroom. They don't call "Good Guys Pizza" for nothing! Order from Good Guys and you won't be disappointed. If you feel extra adventurous try their chicken Greek pizza which is delicious!!

NY Style Pizza was Fantastic, being able to preorder was awesome, and pick-up was perfect!!

OMG!!!! If your into cheesy pizza with a thick crust. Then you have to come here, and enjoy this deliciousness. Every bite was a enjoyable one. I really like the slight sweetness of the crust. Even the sauce was just right, not to bitter and not to sweet.

This place used to have the best pizza around. Unforunately, I noticed something was off. The sauce isn't what is used to be. I did move away for a few years but it is not the same sauce as they used to use. I will be looking for a new place.

I ordered a 5 piece chicken finger, plain. This is what I was given. I feel so ripped off. Some of the pieces were not even edible. I think they gave me the discarded pieces from other orders. Very dissapointed to say the least.

Everything is always great quality pizza is cheesy sub are large and quality ingredients chicken wings are always great

Was up in the area and got a recommendation from a friend that this is their go-to pizza place and I can see why. Ordered online and it couldn't have been easier. Placed the order for a specialty pizza and went to pick it up about 45 minutes later on a Friday night. Not that I didn't love this chicken finger pizza, it was just a lot of cheese and if I go back to Good Guys Pizza I'll be trying something a little lighter. A classic Buffalo style pizza, heavy, very thick, but overall that's exactly why one would expect for chicken finger style pizza. Small is definitely the way to go if you are ordering for 2 or 3 adults as it's a 6 cut with big slices. Pricing was certainly fair for the quantity, total came to around $25 with a tip. They do have a lot of choices for specialty pizza so I might have no choice but to make the trip back to North Tonawanda to try a different one soon!

A well-known local pizza place, and it's really earned it's reputation The pizza sauce is a little sweet, but the cheese and pepperoni complement it well and it's just a delicious, reasonably priced pie !

Any Gen Z writing a Huge Delicious Pie review this doesn't apply to you! You weren't around for the good Pizza! You wouldn't understand. What the hell happened to good guys pizza. When I moved out of NT I would drive one hour round trip because the pizza was just that good. I would fly the pizza all over the country because all the locals that moved away from NT couldn't get pizza that good where they moved to. It's not an uncommon theme just like Teds hot dogs, Platters chocolate and Webbers mustard. You could Always count on Buffalo comfort food until now. The pizza I grew up on at Pizza Junction that became Good Guys has turned into either undercooked or overcooked slop! The pizza was always heavy which is what made it great but the dough was amazing. After Covid things went down hill quick. I don't know if they changed the dough recipe or are using cheaper ingredients or just don't care anymore. There is no consistency. You just never know what you are going to get. They can't even cut the pizza so I'm going with don't give a shit anymore! It's sad to see this happen but it's just not worth the drive anymore! The blue cheese is still good so at least they have that going for them.

If you're looking for a nice thick slice of pizza with good dough and great cheese. This is the place to go! All of the food they serve I a large portion and just tastes right! Don't u hate getting a sub and u taste roll over what u ordered. Not here u get the taste here! Chicken wings are cooked just to the crisp! But I can say this place is one of my favs.

You want a huge delicious Pie? Order here/ Great size for the money and the homemade sauce is so good!

As everything and everyone city's back, shrinks sizes they stick to what has made them the best. Even as cost and prices increase their customers continue to be loyal and faithful because they know they are getting their moneys worth. No matter what you order on the menu you will walk away happy and telling all your friends that you need to go to Good Guys.

Good Guys is one of the best places around. I am hoping their quality and customer service stays up to par, or better, because other places have gone down the tubes.

If you were a fan of Pizza Junction back in the day, then this a must try. They are run by the main group of people who made Pizza Junction a staple of WNY. They don't skimp on portions, and the prices are reasonable given the amount of food you are getting. I have been the Philly and I for one would say that their steak and cheese sub is as good if not better than the Philly Cheesesteak you can get in Philly.

if you want a nice thick slice this is the place the dough and cheese were absolutely amazing and the crust is top 3 crust I've ever had

While I was visiting a friend in the neighborhood, we needed to grab some food for the night. It was suggested to order subs; nothing fancy but I'm always up for a good sub. We ordered turkey subs and some sides and the sub was stacked! For "just a turkey sub" there was so much meat and cheese packed into it. The mayo was good with fresh vegetables on it as well. Really tasty and I would definitely get other food from them again. Note: the parking lot is pretty small and being on a corner intersection can make picking up food tricky if s a busy night.

Best of excess!! Their regular pizza is everyone else's double cheese, double pepperoni!! It's delicious!! One of the best pizzas in WNY in my opinion.

A pretty good pie, with A LOT of cheese. When I say a lot of cheese I mean the cheese was thicker than the crust, that much! You will definitely have to eat about half the slice with a knife and fork because the cheese will slide right off. With that said however the pizza itself was very good, sauce was tasty and the crust was good and the pie had plenty of pepperoni too.

Great pizza shack that was transferred over from a few workers at Pizza Juntion who opened their own joint. Food has always been on the pricier side but at the end of the day, serving size and quality makes up for it. Open for take-out only.

I'm a Buffalo native that moved to Cleveland, OH 10 years ago. Let me just tell you that this is my go-to pizza place EVERY time I come home. If you love sweet sauce and mounds of cheese, you'll love this pizza. Crunchy crust too!

Wings were just awful. Very small and over cooked. Very disappointing to say the least. Will go elsewhere next time.

Came back home looking for the best Buffalo pizza. Found this gem and it was perfect. Got a basic cheese pizza and beef on weck pizza. Lots of cheese and toppings. Can't wait to go again when back in Buffalo.

Every year for Super Bowl we go to Good Guys Pizza. My family and I love it. Both my parents grew up in the TNT area, so to us this is what pizza should be. Everything on the pizza is thick. The dough, sauce, cheese and toppings are always loaded! The cheese is almost like getting twice the cheese (or more), but you still taste everything on it. Most people cannot eat more than 2 slices. I usually like less sauce, but the way they make it, it all blends together perfectly. We also ordered wings. They were similar to most places. They were not very crispy, but were saucy and huge. We did get our order on probably the busiest day of the year for them, so maybe it was the day. Next time though, I would ask for them to be crispy. Only downside, is they do not deliver (I saw they joined door dash, but we had a gift card) and that the parking lot is rather small. They also are on the pricier side - but you get huge portions. The pizza is definitely worth your trip and they serve single slices as well if you just want a piece or two!

I placed an order for two subs and one appetizer I was given the time 20 minutes I showed up 25 minutes later Only the appetizer was complete. Not a problem. As another customer enters Good guys two employees engage in a conversation and completely ignore the subs that were placed In front of them after about 10 minutes I step to the counter and ask if my order was complete and a when I got the attention of a different employee they stated "it just came out " As I sat there for the entirety of the conversation and watched the subs be placed on the warming racks

Great pizza. Parking lot isn't ideal especially at the corner, but they've tried to widen the lot it appears. An NT favorite for sure.

Love this place ! Best pizza and wings! The staff is amazing! So friendly and helpful. They are all very hard workers. Especially on those hot summer days. Don't know how you guys take the heat with those hot ovens in no air conditioning! Your customers have noticed, and we appreciate all you guys do ! I pick up pizza all the time for the NTNLL so I've gotten to know these devoted people pretty good. Never once have I gone in and not been greeted with a smile, and friendly conversation ! Thank you Good Guys We are lucky to have you as part of our community! Diane

I had the 'taco' it was massive. And amazing I had the chicken taco, amazing. I was like why is this so expensive for a taco but really it was a burrito and so good. I added Tom and lettuce. Yummy. The group had a pizza, let's just say saucy. They loved it. We order delivery. So cannot speak for the atmosphere but the delivery service was great.

I can't get a decent slice for the life of me, I continue to punish myself by getting slices hoping atleast one will be good, but I get it either super cold or slightly warm and super soggy :(. Very Disappointing as of late....

Not sure how I never reviewed Good Guys. My favorite pizza and second to none. Absolutely amazing pizza. Some of the other offerings (subs, wings, fries) are very good but can't compare to the pizza. What to order: cheese and onion half sheet. Huge junction style slices, blows away the large pizza. Two slices and you are full for the night. I have recently had the wings again and they are better then I remember. Ordered the gold wings (honey mustard) and they were amazing. Highly recommend. Place your order ahead of time, this place gets busy.

This is my second review for this pizza place. I'm from Connecticut and when I come here to visit family I look forward to having pizza from this establishment. It's the best I've ever had. So if you haven't tried this place go you won't be sorry. Jane P.

Great pizza & wings every casual gathering family has!! Prices are fair even in this present economic situation! Delivery was quick and the driver was friendly! Hope people at least give a try! You too may make it your "go to".

I have never been disappointed checking this place out. One of my top 5 places in Buffalo for pizza. The food is quality every time and the prices are very reasonable!

Since I was passing through NT yesterday, I decided to stop in to try this "famous NT" pizzeria. I was able to buy a slice to go. When I opened the box in my car, I was disappointed to see I received a corner slice. I was not "cornered" but had I been in a mood to complain, I would have asked for different piece!! The take out service was busy and I needed to get to my destination in the area, so I went with the slice I received. The cashier also told me the slice is already warmed up. It was warm, but he could have put it back in the oven for a minute or two. Guess he was in a rush to get me served and on to help the guy behind me in line. Oh well. One slice of cheese pizza - $2.97. Bit pricey. Too doughy. Too thick. Didn't help I got the corner piece, more dough, less sauce and cheese. I would say the pizza was tasty. Not fabulous. Closest pizza of this type is served by Franco's I would say in comparison. However, Franco's crust is less doughy, which I much prefer. And Franco's sauce /cheese ratio is perfect and overall tastier. I'm not sure I would go back again. Not my first choice, as there are competitors with better service and pizza nearby.

The best thing about staying at my mom's house for a few days was being in Good Guys delivery range. Pizza by default has a thick bread-like crust that is my jam, but for those who prefer something different they also offer a NY-style which is a favorite of my husband's. Sauce is always tasty and added in the right crust to sauce to cheese ratio. They are not in any way stingy with the toppings yet the middle remains crisp without the outer edge getting overdone. The wings aren't anything spectacular but they're a fine example of a good Buffalo wing, and typically arrive relatively crisp with a good amount of sauce. Subs are very good. Bread quality is high and again they do a great bread to meat to cheese ratio, which isn't easy to find. Ingredients have always tasted fresh and except for occasionally getting the toppings wrong, have never had any complaints on the sub front. Overall a solid pizza and sub joint, a definite favorite in the area.

I much prefer "Bad Girls" to "Good Guys", unless we're talking about pizza, and in this case we are. Because "Good Guys" has a very strong claim to being WNY's best pizza shop, and is without a doubt in the top 10. What to get: Cheese and Pep slice What else: Good Guys are much better than God Guys, which are down at the local church, and don't make very good pizza. How to improve: Charge slightly less for slices, maybe. If it were full of moody male employees, it'd be "Brood Guys." Oh wait, it is. WNY has perhaps the best pizza in the world, and certainly the most unheralded. Some people hate it because it's greasy, cheesy, doughy, and nothing like Italian, NYC or Chicago pizza. But it's absolutely amazing, when it's done right, such as here, Imperial, Franco's, Mattina's, Bella (on S Park), and the incredible Pizza Oven up in the Falls. The amazing thing about WNY is that every slice is different, and there are multiple styles going on, all of which are quite unique and original to this region. If it were on the East Side of Buffalo, it'd be "Hood Guys." This particular slice is more like the "carpet style" which Franco's does equally brilliantly, and Bozanna's used to do before it closed down. You won't get a heartier, thicker, heavier, cheesier, greasier, saucier square of pizza than here up in North Tonawanda. There's a reason this tiny local shop with no seats in it is always busy long into the night. If it were full of guys that got canceled on, it'd be "Stood (Up) Guys." If you come to town, and you want to try some of the best pizza of your entire life - addictively good, no less - come up to Good Guys and get yourself a slice. If it were owned by FEMA, it'd be "Flood Guys." They charge a little more than most places for a slice, but it's worth it. However if they keep upping the prices they may have to rename themselves "Greed Guys." And if it were dedicated to Biggie and Tupac it'd be more like "Gunned Down Guys", but it's in North Tonawanda, which is known as one of those "white power" type neighbourhoods (puke, puke, puke), so it probably would never be dedicated to Mr. Smalls and Mr. Shakur. But we're talking about pizza, not politics, which I suppose is one of the few things in life we can all agree on. And if it were full of dudes that are so into this pizza that they are in a permanent state of arousal, it'd be "Wood Guys."

Had this on my "to-try" list for a while and just tried it the other day. Pretty good wings, we got medium extra sauce crispy and gold which is like a bbq honey mustard I think. Ordered take out so not much to say about that. Staff were cool. Wings were good and they actually put extra sauce unlike some places. Blue cheese was good and they give you big containers which is a plus for me. Price was the same as any other pizza joint. I'll have to try the pizza next time. Overall good wing and would go back.

Ordered BBQ wings extra crispy. Wings were soggy and BBQ sauce tastes like sour ketchup. Worst wings I've ever had!! Will never order from Good Guys again.

Subs are the bomb wings are good the pizza has gone down hill since the new owner has taken over tho but it's still good with large crust and a lot of cheese.

I drove 400 miles to come back to North Tonawanda to visit. One of my goals was to stop at Good Guys. It was as good as I remembered. Simply the best pizza around* * - Assuming you are not a NY style pizza snob. If you like plenty of cheese and tons of toppings this is the pizza for you. To sum up I quote my son after he had a slice after a 3 years. "Holy F*** that's good pizza."

One of the Worst pizzas I have had. Should have looked in the box prior to leaving the restaurant. It was completely burnt. The crust, the cheese... it was super sloppy. The flavor was almost non existent, as well as the sauce. Big bummer since this was our first time back in WNY to visit home in 4 years and really craved that Buffalo style pizza.