Good 'N Plenty Restaurant

Pennsylvania Dutch restaurant · Lancaster County

Good 'N Plenty Restaurant

Pennsylvania Dutch restaurant · Lancaster County

150 Eastbrook Rd, Smoketown, PA 17576

Highlights

Farmhouse with a Pennsylvania Dutch menu, from fried chicken to pickled veggies & buttered noodles.

150 Eastbrook Rd, Smoketown, PA 17576 Get directions

goodnplenty.com

@cntraveler

"Good 'N Plenty is an Amish country mainstay where you'll get all the traditional country charm—there's a definite farmhouse vibe at the restaurant, with red and white checkered tablecloths, and a cute gift shop up front. Most guests—a mix of families, tourists, and large groups—opt for the all-you-can-eat choice in the cafeteria-style room (though, you can order à la carte in a smaller room). Expect straight-up Pennsylvania Dutch comfort food: fried chicken, mashed potatoes, and meatloaf. Chow chow (essentially pickled relish) is a signature side dish that’s worth trying." - Nancy DePalma

4 Best Day Trips from Philadelphia | Condé Nast Traveler

View Postcard for Good 'N Plenty Restaurant

John Moss

Google

Came here tonight for dinner and everything was really good. We chose the family style dining which was all you can eat fried chicken, baked ham, meatloaf, mashed potatoes, corn, green beans, buttered noodles, apple sauce, gravy, bread, butter or apple butter. For dessert we chose apple crumb pie with ice cream and shoefly pie with ice cream. The atmosphere was really friendly with a gift shop and bakery downstairs. Well worth the short wait and the money.

Sam R

Google

Ok, I tried this spot due to a recommendation from an Amish woman. I personally liked Katie's Kitchen more for authentic Amish food. Let's see, this place was good that I can see what's cooking due to the open kitchen. The applesauce was okay, the wedding meal was weird but okay, the peppa slaw was fine, the mash was good. The refresher was very very light with sugar but that was fine with me. I'm not sure whether I'd be back but might come back for a breakfast meal. The server was super duper nice!

Mo Franklin

Google

The staff was so nice and inviting as soon as we entered the building. The family style dinning experience is definitely new to me, (sitting at a hs cafeteria type table with random people). I really enjoyed it though, met a few nice people and the food was good. The fried chicken and mash potatoes was official chicke gravy boat was clutch. My girl got the meatloaf it was good too. They have a family style all you can eat option for $26 per person. If you have the appetite for all that seems worth it to me. They have a nice gift shop too

Patti B Johnson

Google

Oh my gosh! The Dutch Sampler has fried chicken, meatloaf and pork with saurkraut, I had whipped potatoes and chow chow as my sides and It. Was. Delicious! Becky was our server and she was pleasant, helpful and so quick. I highly recommend this restaurant, they have a nice shop also.

林彥璋

Google

We tried the family style food. It was a very special experience to share food with the other people. The food and the service were good. The desserts were too sweet for me. Overall I recommend to have food with your family when you first visit here!

Beng Reyes

Google

Overrated and they probably were good before, but the Amish sampler that consisted of meat loaf, fried chicken, pork with sauerkraut was very disappointing. The chicken was kinda old(refried probably), meat loaf tasted straight from the can. We also ordered the spinach and grilled chicken salad, but the chicken was rubbery, the greens wilted. The server Connor was really very helpful and did his best to make us feel welcome. Amish chicken pot pie was like a frozen dinner . It was plenty, but not good.

PartiGirl ToFu

Google

An all you can eat place that brings the food to you. Fried chicken, meatloaf, ham, corn, mashed potatoes, and dessert. The waitress would give a smart remark or weird look when you requested more food!

Rock U

Google

We opted to go to the other dining room as we wanted to order from their ala carte menu rather than their family style all you can eat option. It was a good choice as the portion size was generous as you can see from the attached pictures. We were also served their super soft bread with whipped butter and jam so we certainly had our fill!