We have been shopping here for years. We have always found the food to be fresh, delicious and reasonably priced for Montauk. From local seafood and lobsters to great quality steak, burgers, and desserts, we rely on this establishment regularly and they always deliver. The staff is wonderful- very accommodating and friendly.
portland maine
Google
Sadly , this place has really flatlined. Not sure who is cooking the prepared foods but it is NOT good. The prepared food tastes old and off...Tried some soup from the fridge, literally no flavor and they sell food past expiration date Prices are OUT OF THIS WORLD. Our fish was literally stinky! had to return it. Not to mention , staff is always stuffing their faces in the kitchen and at the cashier, not a good look. From here went to Petersons in town for fresh fish right off their boats.
Definitely will go there first next time.
None of the staff can hide the fact they hold great disdain for their customers. A supremely unpleasant experience.
Maureen Thomas
Google
The have the best gluten free chocolate chip cookies and Belgian chocolate brownies made in Montauk
M Borrus
Google
They give you what you want in a cute little store, but you pay for it. Very expensive. Butter was 10 dollars. I liked playing with the lobsters there.
Shawn Smith
Google
Th watermelon was the cheapest I’ve ever seen with apples at $3.50 each? Someone needs to audit the pricing.
Brigitta Danyi
Google
I stop by and grab my whole lobster from here.
They cook and crack.
Full of meat.
This one on the picture $31 for me worth every penny. Next weekend I’m gonna pick another one!
Al
Google
My Dad brought home a New England clam chowder packed on 4/3 of this year? of last year? Doesn't say... Absolutely Vile taste from this! Beware and make sure you look for These almost 3 month old Chowders
Jackson
Google
RATS - Literally running all over this place.
Gross-
RATS - everywhere.
This place is absolutely FILTHY-
