Gotham Coffee Roasters

Love this place! Gotham Coffee Roasters has amazing coffee, super smooth and flavorful. Cozy NYC vibes, friendly baristas, and perfect for a quick coffee break or chill time. Definitely coming back! 💛☕

The As a reviewer in the top 10% of all coffee contributors on this platform, I rarely have to write a review of this nature, but the experience I had today was fundamentally unacceptable for a specialty roastery of this caliber. I visited Gotham Coffee Roasters on February 15th and placed an order between 1:00 PM and 1:30 PM. I was specifically looking forward to a Brazilian pour-over and requested it for "here." When I ordered, the barista explicitly told me it would be about a 10-minute wait. I told her that was "no problem" and sat down to catch up on emails. I then sat there for 30 minutes. It eventually became clear that the staff—two employees who seemed completely absent-minded—had simply never placed the order into the system. Despite being "in process" with other tasks, they completely forgot my existence. After waiting three times the estimated duration, I had to ask for a refund, which was processed on-site. For the owner/manager: You can easily track this incident in your POS system for Feb 15th between 1:00 PM – 1:30 PM; you will see the specific transaction and the subsequent refund. I value the craft of specialty coffee, and Gotham usually has a reputation for quality. However, as a high-level reviewer, I have to be honest: you have one job in a service environment, and failing to even input an order while a customer sits in plain sight for half an hour is a major breakdown in basic operations. I hope this serves as a necessary coaching moment for the team on shift.

Flat white was a bit bitter - strong coffee flavor but not smooth. There is no Wi-Fi.

Solid espresso. They have some indoor and outdoor seating!

Hands down the best coffee in all of New York! Gotham Coffee Roasters is a must visit for all real coffee drinkers. You will not be disappointed! I order all of my coffee beans for home from their website. It gets delivered directly to my door freshly roasted and unlike anything else I can find. So when I’m visiting New York I have to stop by their cafe. The space is small but mighty. If there is a line, it never lasts long as the baristas move quickly. There are only a handful of tables, but I always seem to find a seat to enjoy my coffee. Gotham Coffee is know for their high quality coffee beans from all over the world, perfectly roasted, and you can taste the difference. They have beans from Guatemala, Mexico, Colombia, and Ecuador. They have bags of whole beans available for purchase at the cafe as well. The staff are super knowledgeable and friendly as well. They also serve multiple milk alternatives which is nice. 5/5 stars, Gotham Coffee Roasters is true NYC coffee experience.

I’ve come here several times after running errands in the neighborhood over the last two years. Sometimes I think cafes are good, but it’s actually just that one barista. I can confirm today that all the baristas are excellent, meaning this place has a legit coffee program. Not once have I received a burnt espresso, or the feeling I can make this better at home. A1 to this team!

Niche shop with a very quiet vibe against the background music. There’s a selection of coffee beans, coffee makers, and assorted goods for sale on the side and comfortable seating while you wait for coffee or relax.

Coffee was great, without doubt. I appreciate their professions and offering different kinds of beans to make drinks. But same as some comments I found here, some staff were cool with their professionalism to talk to costumers. My ☕️🥛✨cappuccino was really creamy, balanced. Nothing to complain. Also my first time trying polenta cake which was an item they got from bakery outside. It was too dry for me so I won’t recommend.

Cozy and simple spot to stop by for a quiet moment while in midtown. They dont have a super long menu of fancy drinks with syrups but everything they serve is solid and delicious. Service was quick for us even though there were a few people in front of us in line, and seating is available if you want to post up with a book or your laptop!

Very simple coffee shop with alternative milk options. The barista was very nice but my latte was warm (not hot) and they didn't have any flavoring options other than simple syrup or honey.

Super disappointed with this cafe. I came in with high hopes but left with nothing but disappointment. I ordered a small iced matcha latte with almond milk (they only have oat and almond milk for milk options) and it came out to $7.08. The price baffled me. I asked if they took student discount because most cafes in this area do, and the cashier gave me a nasty face and said no. So considering how overpriced it was I expected the matcha to be so good. The matcha tasted like nothing but almond milk. There wasn't a hint of matcha flavor. I asked the baristas if they could add more matcha powder and they gave me a horrible attitude and said it would be $1 more. To pay $8 for a subpar matcha is crazy. The small iced latte was $6 and even that was underwhelming, the coffee was light and the milk overpowered it. I don't have anything positive to say about this cafe. Very limited seats, rude customer service, bad overpriced drinks.

The service is good, the spot is clean and the cinnamon babka is AMAZING. My daughter and I came here because of the name (nananananananana Batman) and we'll be back for another coffee date. Highly recommend. My daughter gave the chocolate croissant a and the cappuccino was "mid" My mocha was good, but I think if used a different milk it would have been better.

Cozy & warm nook of a place. Rich and well-filled Americano. Best cup I've had for a while. Lovely staff and can't beat a window seat with my coffee-partner. OK, so I spilled a little of mine carrying it to the table, but that was 'cos it was well full!

I usually really like this cafe but today I overpaid for a latte that was schlepped like it came out of a gas station machine or Dunkin' Donuts or something. I don't understand what happened as usually the lattes are great and look like the photos but the one I received today was very subpar with no effort.

If you're in the area looking for good quality and good coffee, stop by Gotham. The name of the coffee shop first caught my eye (and it's also right next to my work place) - seriously though, stop by. This is the best coffee shop I've found in Manhattan so far that sells quality black coffee that doesn't rip you off. I got the pour over ($5 for 10-12 oz. for any single origins, I believe?) which is a great price for the area. They rotate their single origins, so you can definitely try different coffees here and there. The barista recommended the "Mexico - Luis Ordoñez - Finca La Piedra" which I thoroughly enjoyed. It has a light acidic after taste of fruits (nothing too juicy or citrusy). I think it has some cocoa notes? Not sure. Anyway, it was very good, definitely try it out. I'll probably stop by later to grab a bag of beans because I thought their coffee quality was good. I'd want to try a cortado or a macchiato next time!

Cappuccino didn't wow me but it was decent. I appreciated having the outdoor seating and the street wasn't too busy so it was relaxing to sit outside. Only one barista was working on a busy Saturday afternoon so there was a line that formed inside the store so had to wait a bit but overall a good experience.

Solid coffee shop located in the Flatiron district. It's a small place with 4-5 tables inside to study or chill out with a drink and bite to eat or a couple tables outside as well. The hubby ordered a hot almond milk mocha which was well made and went down very smoothly. We also ordered a peanut butter cookie that was buttery, moist and so delicious alongside a bag of the Brooklyn blend. Most bags run between $18- $22 but that's what I'd expect from a roaster working their magic from Brooklyn.

Potential to be better. Service was great. Cozy spot. Liquid sugar had a weird aftertaste. Was excited about the pastries bc they looked good, however 2/3 of my pastries were stale & dry. Coffee was okay if you're just looking something regular degular, no WOW factor. I have more of an appreciation for sweetened coffees before receiving, so beware, this is a diy spot.

Small shop, has 4 tables but they make the most of the space. Cute modern space. The mocha I just had here is perhaps the best straight mocha I've ever had... compares favorably w/ the spiced mocha (Aztec Mocha) from a place called Lofty in San Diego. Unbelievable richness that you rarely experience, perfect balance between tart and sweet.

Stopped by for a quick hot chocolate and coffee. Drinks were nothing special but it's a good choice for a cafe to relax at for a bit. A few people were working and they have outdoor seating. There was a bit of a line and they only had one person working so it took us a while to get our drinks.

Service was a bit slow but there was only one person working. We got two lattes and a bag of beans and have no complaints about the taste. Beans were pretty expensive though, ranging from $18-$25 ish.

I love this place. Hands down best pour-over cup around. Nice staff and chill seating. 10/10.

Delicious. I got the iced coffee here in a small size with regular milk ($3.75) and also a tahini cookie ($3.25). Their cookies are tasty. Will definitely come back as the price seems fair for what it is. Have a fairly optimized seating area.

The gold standard for Iced Mochas. No other place can replicate the taste and creaminess this place can do. Phenomenal all around. I only rate mochas, and this one is the only 5 star. My go to order is an Iced Mocha with oat milk. You cannot go wrong. The perfect compliment of espresso taste with mocha flavor. They use high quality French chocolate, and you can tell its what makes their mocha unique. Do yourself a favor, try it out.

Cute spot. But cold brew is super watered down and though they charge 75 cents extra for oat milk, they barely add 1 tbsp of it. Go to dough across the street, better coffee and everything else.

Gotham coffee roaster has joined the pick of coffee roasting. Nevertheless, after drinking all those fancy coffee roasters/ shop, Gotham doesn't stand out. But the quality is alright.

A really adorable coffee shop. Not going to lie.. the name lured me in. I will come back for the coffee though. I got an iced coffee, which normally is not my thing, but it was delicious and hit the spot on an 80 degree day in NYC. There is some seating inside this spot but not much. They sell some snacks and coffee grounds to take home. Great and quick service too.

Great coffee, but some real weirdo customer. This woman chose to wait in line 5 feet away from the person in front of her, which caused other customers to have to wait outside the store while the store is fucking basically empty, so she and the air in line can get their coffee 5 feet away from the counter. Pure stupidity. Barista should really remind idiots like that otherwise next time she is making other customers wait with her across the street.

Just stopped in this morning and got an oat milk latte. Service was really fast and the latte was really good!

Excellent coffee! My iced coffee was super rich and smooth, and my boyfriend said the same about his hot coffee. Chocolate babka was also great (not quite on the level of Breads Bakery but still quite good). Friendly service, too.

This place is adorable! The person who works behind the counter is super nice and makes an amazing latte! Cute outdoor seating where we were able to hang out. It wasn't in direct sunlight which is great on this 90+ degree day! So happy we discovered this coffee shop.full iui

Nice place. Friendly staff. Great coffee They had 6 options for pour over, including 2 different Ethiopians, which happens to be my favorite bean. We tried the Kenya and the Ethiopian Gedeb. Both were very flavorful and tasted nice and fruity. The baristas brewed then perfectly. Well done

What a charming cafe! I wish there other locations because the customer service on Saturday (2/2/19) at 9AM was top-notch, friendly and engaging; not to mention my scrumdilicious oat latte and raspberry oat bar. Yes, I'm a spodey Oatie. It was the perfect breakfast combo right before my visit to the James Corbett Salon next door. It's Tuesday morning on my way to midtown and I'm hankering for a pick-me-up. Charmed to meet you!

Gotham coffee roasters is the BEST!!! I leave early so I have the pleasure of a delicious cup of coffee here before work. From day one Cade has remembered my name, my coffee choice and is always so positive. He is part of the reason I come here! I wish everyone was as nice as him! Cade, thank you for always brightening my day!

They have this yummy cinnamon iced tea and Green's cinnamon babka (in my opinion hands down the best babka in New York City). The place is tiny. No a/c and no washroom. The closest is at BB&B is what the barista told me. Still, staff are friendly and there are outlets for recharging. I should try their coffee, but I cannot help but think of their cinnamon iced tea when I go there.

A gem of a coffee shop hidden in the city! Didn't know this place existed but luckily we made a stop here. Super quiet even on Saturday afternoon - perfect place to catch up or read a book. The barista was helpful and friendly - we got the Nicaraguan pour over and an iced soy latte. Both drinks were really tasty. Ambience of this place is clean and modern without feeling too sterile. Would definitely return here when I'm in the area or if I need a place to sit for an hour or two knowing the seats aren't always taken. Bonus - they have loyalty/punch cards here!

I came here after lunch with some friends. The barista was very friendly, the decor and environment was pleasing the eyes, and they had good tunes playing. I ordered an iced americano and found the flavor profile very balanced. Not too acidic and great after taste. I'll definitely come back if I'm ever in the area!

No half-and-half, can't make change for a 20 and no straw. That's a lot of "no's" for one simple coffee order.

Small coffee shop with an awesome chill vibe. Simple, minimalistic decor, with lots of sunlight (in the day time). Not many seats- about four tables and seats for 8-10 people. Definitely more of a take your coffee to go place. They play "coffeehouse type music" (indie, bluegrassy). Your typical range of espresso drinks (latte, cappuccino etc). I really enjoyed my almond milk latte- strong espresso with creamy almond milk. It cost $5.25 not including tip. Almond and soy milk for $0.5 extra. They have both Califia farms barista almond milk (YES AMAZING) and also unsweetened almond breeze almond milk. The barista let me choose. Overall a solid coffee option between chelsea and flatiron.

Nice little coffee shop. Staff was very friendly, and single origin espresso was very nice. They also have a good selection of beans if you want to get pour over. The space is limited (4-5 tables).

Relatively new coffee spot in Chelsea with simple decor and a very solid cup of coffee. Not sure why, but the few times I have passed by, there aren't people sitting there even though it's probably a nice place to get work done without distractions. The coffee is local and is nicely balanced without too much bitterness. If this spot was any closer to me, I'd be coming by all the time.

Gotham definitely has a complicated story - after ten years of wine making life, it finally decided to come back to the coffee brewing industry, in which they once worked for the original owners of the Starbucks. Thanks for bringing its first retail store to Manhattan. Proudly serving both locally blended beans and internationally sourced beans on a seasonal basis, Gotham has brought his own style for sure. Latte carried both a strong sense of bitterness at first sip, and gradually turned into a balanced taste after seconds. Sister coffee of Prodigy, which I have stopped by occasionally and loved it as well.

LOVE LOVE LOVE THIS PLACE!!!! They recently opened down the block from my office and every time I go in for my morning coffee I feel More and more at home. The staff is extremely friendly and knowledgeable about coffee, they always ask me how my weekend was, or make small talk while they prepare my beverage. It is always clean and a great addition to 19th street. They have everything from drip coffee to lattes to cappuccinos and teas. They also offer a somewhat small, but delicious, variety of pastries by the register. If your in the area definitely stop in!

Love Gotham Coffee Roasters! We stumbled upon this tiny and adorable spot on a recent trip to NYC, and I am so glad we did. The clean and modern interior is a super calming juxtaposition to the hustle and bustle of nearby Union Square, and you'll enjoy the break from the frenzy as you sip a delicious coffee or tea at one of the Instagram-friendly marble tables. We kept it simple with our first visit - just a hot coffee and a berry iced tea - but I found both of the drinks to be flavorful, fresh, and well made. The baristas were friendly and knowledgeable, and it was super interesting to hear them talk about the sourcing process for the different kinds of coffee beans. We also learned that they own a roastery in nearby Brooklyn, so you know the product you're getting is top quality! I can't wait to come back to this off the beaten path coffee shop the next time we're in the city!

The first coffee place with nonbitter (nonburnt) coffee! My only quip is that the mocha didn't taste strongly of anything in particular, i.e. needs more chocolate in it. Definitely come for a good cup of coffee without the bitter burn of your typical burnt coffee. I'm looking forward to trying out their matcha latte next time - hopefully its quality is on par with the coffee.

Small but cozy cafe, perfect place to grab a drink and read a book or do some work. Everything was good however my only problem is that they don't have WiFi. I was trying to get some work done but I realized that they didn't have WiFi so instead I read a book. I got a cup of hot chocolate and I really enjoyed it. Would definitely come back to try their other drinks.

Extremely questionable business practices. Refused to honor the posted price of $5 for a mocha (on the "specials" menu to the right of the ordering counter). So I canceled my order and won't be back.

Cute coffee shop tucked away between 5th and 6th ave on 19th street. I went around 1:30pm on a Thursday and there wasn't a line (only one person was sitting in the shop to be honest). I got a macchiato and the barista was quick to say that it was made in the traditional way, not the Starbucks (aka like a latte) way. I had a bit of a chuckle when she said that and quickly countered that I hoped she'd be able to teach the Starbucks baristas a thing or two about macchiatos then :P The macchiato itself was quite good - it both had the perfect temperature and the correct amount of milk. The foam could have been a bit better, but that's probably my own fault for ordering a non-dairy drink, as non-dairy milk tends to foam more poorly than regular milk. Overall, I'd recommend a stop here, but it probably isn't the best coffee I've had in the city.

Skip the evil corporate coffee. Oh wait that's so 2004 Skip the sell out to Nestle thinly veiled corporate coffee (the bottle one))in disguise and visit a friendly place that makes espresso drinks with care that taste great

I live in the area and when I can stop at a small coffee shop over a Starbucks, I will. Overall the coffee was actually good with flavor and not bitter. However the coffee cup and lid did not fit properly. Walking into work the lid popped off and wouldn't go back on. Spilled scalding coffee all over me. Been to Starbucks hundreds of times and not one cup to lid issue.

Coffee was great, the shop as a whole was a little small so it isn't the best if you're looking for a spot to work or have a drink with friends for a while. While there isn't much seating, if you want to grab a coffee and enjoy it, this is a good spot. I had a pour over last and it came out very good.

Wicked good coffee shop. The espresso was on point, and the staff was knowledgeable. I love getting a pour over and an espresso while I wait. The babka was moist and delicious, perfect afternoon snack. Highly recommend trying the frost bite next time you need a boost in the afternoon.

Experienced 1. Sampled house coffee 2. Ordered americano (red hook expresso blend) with au lait finish ( almond milk) Assessment 1. Coffee tasted mostly fresh. Somewhat sour from acidity and slightly bitter after swallowing. Not bad for those that prefer their their coffee to be on the bitter end of the spectrum. 2. Not that different from house blend but slightly less sour and less bitter. Almond milk may have contributed to final taste. Recommendations: 1. Use a barista blend almond milk instead of the generic silk brand. For an upscale place like this, I was surprised to see them using Silk Almond milk. Service: Excellent! Looking forward to trying their pour overs and hot cocoa!

Had very good espresso here, and the barista was super nice. Unfortunately I wasn't looking for a pastry at the moment, but couldn't help noticing that there was babka in the case calling to me, so I know what I'll be trying out next time!

Free oat milk! Rare in coffee shops it seems. Friendly staff, strong coffee, nice vibe. One star down because I've had better baked goods. Great coffee spot in the area!

We drink a lot of coffee. I drink it primarily to avoid homicide. My husband, former barista, coffee snob extraordinaire, LOVED this place. So much so that we visited 2x in one day. Their limited edition Ethiopian roast tasted liked blueberries - even I tasted the notes!

Finding delicious coffee shops in the cities is one of my favorite things to do and after finding this place on instagram I knew i had to give them a visit. The interior of the coffee house is a little small but it has a very comfortable feel. The baristas were very nice and not overly busy. I ordered a pour over and expected a cup but was given a carafe which let me savor the coffee even more. The Colombian single origin was delicious and was very clear. All in all a great NYC coffee roaster.