Guana Island

I had high expectations for Guana Island, which is marketed as a secluded private island retreat with a tropical orchard and farm-to-table dining. The island itself is beautiful and there are moments where the property shows real potential. However, given the rates and positioning as a luxury resort, the overall experience fell short. Location Although Guana is promoted as a private island, the beaches and coastline are public. In practice this means numerous boats anchor just offshore each day and bring groups of non-guests onto the main beaches and snorkeling areas. During our stay these visitors occupied portions of the beach including near the spa, were seen on hiking trails, and regularly passed through guest areas. At times the groups were loud and disruptive, which significantly undermined the sense of privacy and exclusivity many travelers expect when booking a private island resort. Despite this, the island itself is stunning. The landscaping is beautiful and the hiking trails are excellent, particularly the walk to Longmans Point. North Beach offers a more rugged and peaceful stretch of coastline with fewer visiting boats. The natural setting is easily the property’s greatest strength. Food & Beverage The food and beverage program was the biggest disappointment. Breakfast and lunch were largely buffet-style and quite basic, which felt out of place at a resort charging luxury-level rates. One surprise was the lack of fresh tropical fruit. Prior to arrival we confirmed with reservations that fruit from the island’s orchard such as papaya and passion fruit would be available. In reality most mornings we were served imported fruit similar to pre-packaged grocery store fruit salad. After multiple requests we were occasionally given fresh papaya, but inconsistently. During the orchard tour we learned that papaya, bananas, and coconuts were currently in season on the island, yet these ingredients rarely appeared in the menus. Servers were inattentive and unable to explain where ingredients were sourced, and items such as halibut (not native to Caribbean waters) appeared frequently. Overall the farm-to-table concept described in the resort’s marketing was difficult to see reflected in the dining experience. Dinner was stronger and we did enjoy the views and wine selection in the evenings. The pastry chef deserves special mention as the desserts and house-made ice creams were excellent. Beverage service also fell short. Coffee and espresso were self-service from a Keurig-style machine and cocktails rarely incorporated fresh fruit. On the beach guests were often expected to retrieve their own drinks. Rooms We stayed in Grenada 2, which likely has one of the best views on the island. The setting is beautiful but the interiors felt dated. The couch in our room was always damp, making the seating area unusable. The balcony is shared with the neighboring unit and the minibar was not stocked. Activities Outdoor activities were a highlight. The hiking trails are fantastic, kayaking around the island is beautiful, and the hike to Longmans Point with its tide pools was the standout experience of the stay. The island’s two resident donkeys are cute mascots, though during our visit they appeared to need vet care and one had an open wound. Guest Services Several concerns were raised during the stay, including meal service, fresh fruit availability, and the presence of non-guests on the beaches, but these issues were not meaningfully addressed. While waiting in the lobby during checkout we also noticed a printed guest rooming list left on a coffee table displaying guest names, room numbers, and notes in plain view, which felt like an avoidable lapse in privacy standards. Conclusion Guana Island has an extraordinary natural setting and tremendous potential. With stronger service standards and a more authentic farm-to-table dining and beverage program, the resort could offer something exceptional. In its current state, however, the experience feels closer to a mid-tier resort charging luxury-level prices.

My husband and I have been visiting Guana Island for about 12 years now. We stay at the North Beach Cottage and it’s got to be the most wonderful place in the world. We really feel like celebrities when we’re there. Their service is extremely personal and caring. The cottage is a dream - right on the water with its own pool and outdoor shower. The food is outstanding and we’ve been meeting the same people every year who are there when we are. A review almost can’t do it justice. Management and staff are outstanding. We’re going back next year

Guana Island has been on our bucket list for 20 years and we finally made the trip, and it thoroughly exceeded our expectations. What a beautiful location, with great food, beaches, snorkeling, and remote island experience. It is easy to meet and get to know the other guests, and the staff are exceptional with many having worked at the resort for many years. We are already planning a return visit!

Fab quiet, exclusive, romantic spot. The quiet is key. You won't hear someone's idea of a resort spotify playlist anywhere. Not in the bar, not on the beach, not in the dining room. ||You will feel well taken care of for your entire stay.

I wasn’t quite sure what to expect when we arrived, having heard so much about Guana Island and it exceeded my expectations in every possible way!||||It is truly a special, magical place. My husband and I were immediately charmed by the old-world, traditional feel of the island — from the warm and inviting lounge area, to the quaint bar, the cozy library, and the two lovely outdoor dining spaces. The accommodations were spacious, charming, and extremely comfortable. From the moment we arrived, we felt completely at home.||||The food was exceptional, and the staff went above and beyond at every turn. We loved the hiking trails, the stunning beach with its variety of water activities, and simply exploring the property, where we encountered mother nature daily — iguanas, birds, a small snake, flamingoes, and even donkeys and turtles.||||Guana Island is unlike anywhere else — serene, soulful, and unforgettable.

Absolutely fantastic stay! The epitome of barefoot luxury with a home away from home feel. The staff were friendly and always available to help without being overbearing. Arrival and departure were handled seamlessly. Our room was very clean and comfortable and really did feel like a home away from home. The food was spectacular! We will absolutely be back!

My husband and I went to this island paradise to celebrate our 25th anniversary and it was one of the most amazing trips we’ve ever taken. We travel extensively, and we have absolutely nothing negative to say about Guana Island. If you’re thinking of it, you should go. It’s beautiful, private, and the perfect combination of being able to relax and unwind but also to explore and be active. If you want the stuff to dote on you, they will, but if you want them to leave you alone, they will also do that! Highly recommend.

Another great snorkel spot. Also great for beginner snorkelers as it is not too deep and lots to see. You can anchor and swim over to the snorkel spot