Amy H.
Yelp
First of all, I LOVED Hanalei Bay. I have been to Honolulu/Oahu twice and found Hanalei to be more of "THE Hawaii" experience. Kauai is known as the garden island, it is significantly more tropical than Oahu and you have a fraction of the tourist, populations, etc.
The cottages location was superb, we were looking for something more intimate for our honeymoon. We wanted to avoid the resort type setting (though you get service, you also are interacting, sometimes interrupted, etc). I was impressed by the photos online but when we actually arrived - we were stunned. Large indoor space, immaculately clean, unbelievable views from both the front and the back. LARGE open windows for you to look out of in the livingroom (we had cottage #3).
I also have to say, Lucas thought of everything. Fully stocked (not food) kitchen, they even had sun screen, beach towels, basic cooking staples and one morning we stepped outside and there were fresh Papayas and Mangos on our door step. He had been trimming the trees and cut some down for the guests. We were also greeted by a batch of delicious peanutbutter cookies.
The location has the Hanalei river running just behind it with Kayak Kauai just 2 properties down, we were able to easily get to local kayaking. This location is also just a short walk away from lots of shopping, restaurants and the actual bay.
You can also drive to the east to Princeville for groceries and Queens Bath.
All in all I would say this was the best vacation space we could have choosen.