Bill Z.
Yelp
I have to begin with a little bit of schtick... I'm convinced Herbert Candies is the best candies in the area... but I'm not from the area. That matters for me for specific items in the store.
When I walked in, I immediately suffered sensory overload from the wonderful smells, especially since, with Autumn approaching, the Halloween candy is starting to come out. My enthusiasm waned slightly as I wandered through certain sections of the store. I thought certain items were very much high-profit items, such as gumdrops and peanut brittle. I've made peanut brittle, so I know how easy it is to make a halfway decent brittle, but to be fair, I didn't sample theirs.
I was uncertain about the chocolate. The variety is impressive, but to me, the price was not. I have a favorite spot to buy chocolate in New York, and many of their items - chocolate, fudge, truffles - are significantly less. But I also knew I needed to sample it before making a judgment.
My absolute favorite thing at Herbert is their taffy. For me, taffy is an occasional treat when I visit a shop along the coast. Their taffy is the same price. The pieces are slightly smaller (meaning I can have more pieces without feeling guilty), the flavors are varied and intense, and it is very fresh. It will be difficult for me to ever buy taffy anyplace else after this.
I was worried I wouldn't be able to make a fair judgment on their chocolate, but 2 nice things occurred. The first was the lady behind the counter showed me samples of their featured chocolate of the month, a chocolate-covered caramel. Then she pointed me to their end-of-season clearance table in the back, which featured several of their summer lines of chocolates at SEVENTY FIVE PERCENT OFF (can you tell I'm a little excited now?). So of course I bought a box of their Geneva Dark Chocolate. These are smaller pieces of solid dark chocolate. They are also incredibly rich. Herein lies my predicament... my favorite store in NY sells dark chocolates for about half the price, but slightly less quality. So for me, I will have to decide whether I want to satisfy my wallet, or my palate. Or, I can satisfy them both by patronizing both stores.