Henry Social Club

Atmosphere was great, drinks were good. The food... A-M-A-Z-I-N-G!!! From the first bite to sadly the last, I was definitely impressed with the care taken from prep, to plate, to 6 totally amazed patrons! Thank you! -Chris and Christina Cosat ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

This was our first time to the Social Club and definitely won't be our last, just a great experience beginning to end. We stopped in on a Wednesday evening without reservations and were able to get 2 seats at the bar. I would recommend reservations to assure seating as we just got lucky. Service was spectacular, and the food was outstanding. I had scallops, and DH had the pork schnitzel. I can highly recommend either entree. They both were delicious, fresh and had great presentation. A must visit restaurant in beautiful downtown Columbus.

I recently dined at this restaurant with some friends. The food quality was unfortunately not as good as my last visit, but entrees were good. The service was top-notch and the staff were very attentive and friendly. The location was great and the decor was nice, with a modern and trendy vibe. Parking was convenient with both street and garage options available. It can be quite busy and I recommend making a reservation to ensure a table. The restaurant was clean and well presented, with a focus on detail and presentation. Overall, it was a pleasant dining experience but the food should improve for those prices.

I have to go with the 3 "G's" on this one,! Great food..Great service..Great atmosphere!

Paint falling off the ceiling likely going into the food. Steak was loaded with gristle. They gave me a $50 gift card to come back. That was months ago. I'd rather not. I was not allowed to sit at the bar (bartender too busy, no one else sitting at the bar) so I sat by myself at a table. I was hoping to have a social hour in "Henry Social Club". Wrong type of place for that. It's not a social club.

Checked out Henry Social Club for the first time in Columbus Indiana. Chef Tyler made this a wonderful experience! Lamp Chops and Scallops were amazing. We paired this with a bottle of Unshackled, Red Blend CA.

My husband and I went to the Henry Social Club last weekend. Even though we didn't have a reservation they were kind enough to accommodate us. The atmosphere was classy we felt a bit underdressed. The salmon was perfectly fried, and the sauce and veggies complemented the fish nicely. The crème brulée was the best I ever tasted, I highly encourage you to try it.

A swanky place with amazing drinks and food! We had Fried Green Tomatoes, Brisket Mac N Cheese, Crawfish and Andouille Sausage Gumbo with Creme Brulee for dessert.

Such a good experience that after a great dinner I rebooked for the next night. Medium sized warm venue. The hands on vibe of the owner was evident and it showed with great service and friendly atmosphere. Bar has big selection of cocktails & spirits. Menu was tweaked slightly night 2 so assuming there are maybe 5 or so staples and then 3-4 specials nightly. Good apps & salads offered. Our group liked the steaks, fish & pasta. Desert was awesome! I'm a believer and will absolutely return with a reservation

Food was incredible... HOWEVER, I was very let down to find a hair in mine. What was more disappointing is that they didn't compensate us or anything. We spent over $150 on appetizers, drinks, entrees, and dessert... so removing a drink off the table would've helped save my opinion ‍ Aside from the hair, I was incredibly pleased. Service was kind, food was unparalleled to anything else in town. It's a pretty restaurant with low lighting and beautiful for a date night.

Food was great, though we mostly enjoyed several appetizers and split a main course. Ambiance and service were top notch and friendly. Barkeep was very knowledgeable about numerous cocktails. Our only disappointment was with the dessert that we had ordered to go. A key lime item which exhibited absolutely no lime or any taste at all, and had a putty-like texture. We will likely pass on dessert on our next visit.

Excellent menu and food. Service reflected knowledge and passion for the menu options.

Our favorite date night place to eat, drink, and hang out! The food is always delicious and the drinks haven't failed me yet! All of the staff members are absolutely amazing, the service is top notch!

We really wanted to love this place after reading their website and Yelp reviews. But we were so disappointed. 1. Their website has a dinner menu with Prime Rib for $25 ....this caught our eye yet when we arrived they had a completely different menu than what was shown on their website. This is ok but I think online it should be mentioned that "menu changes seasonally etc". We ordered the ribeye ($48) and it was not good. (We are from Texas and know our steaks!) We asked for it to be cooked "medium" but the ribeyes were tough and their steak knives did not make it any easier to cut. Now looking back I wonder if they show the old menu online with the much lower prices just to get customers in the door. (Bait and switch) We wouldn't have been so disappointed had we known ahead of time their menu online was not available. 2. They offer sparkling water ....but it tasted like sparkling water that had gone flat. I assume they carbonate it themselves but seems their C2 cartridges were empty. I asked for a new bottle of sparkling and it was the same. I won't nitpick about the roasted potatoes, coarse cut veggies but had those been better side items then it wouldn't have been such a bad meal. Service was great.

This is hands-down the best place to eat in downtown Columbus. I was in Columbus for a few weeks on a long work trip and after trying it the first time, I had to come back again. Not only was the food absolutely incredible (flavor, texture, everything) but the staff were very friendly and welcoming. Not to mention, the ambiance is lovely with their modern decor and slightly dimmed lights. It was a vibe. Of course, this is a more upscale place, so the prices are higher. But I assure you, it is worth every penny. The prices reflect the quality of the meal you'll be having here. Here are my thoughts on the dishes I tried: Ancho Rubbed Lamb Chops - Seasoned. To. Perfection. The lamb was perfectly cooked and every bite was a delight. Served with a refreshing chimichurri sauce that complimented the seasoning perfectly and even the vegetables were divine. Thai Style Green Coconut Curry Tofu - I'll admit, I was expecting something more saucy based on the description, but this dish was to die for. Perfectly crispy tofu that was full of flavor. The lentils were definitely the best lentils I've ever had. Just incredible. Key Lime Crumble - This was a great treat. Nicely tart key lime flavor and even the crumble itself had some lime infused into it. A nice end to the meal. Mocktails - Yes, they have mocktails! And the bartender was not only happy to experiment with some for me, but he also made a point to present them just as beautifully as their standard drinks. One was a creamsicle flavor with a couple cherries (LOVED this), the other was a Strawberry Mule. If I end up visiting Columbus again in the future, this is the first place I'm going back to. Incredible!

Went for our 29th Anniversary. The service was wonderful and the food was delicious! I had the Scallops with sweet potato gnocchi, and my husband had the Tofu Curry dish. We've had it several times. Always very good!! They gave us a free dessert of our choosing for our anniversary, which was a very nice treat. Had Spanish coffee with dessert. YUM!!

Vanessa, our server, was excellent. The food was fantastic. From the bacon wrapped dates, soup, to the pork and filet.....AMAZING. Everyone was so friendly. We had a much needed relaxing evening !!!

I've been here two or 3 times before. I've never been disappointed, it's just not necessarily my go to type place. I'm more of a chill beer and burger type girl over a fancy dress up for an expensive dinner type girl. However, if you're looking for a nice place to take someone on a first date or an anniversary or something like that, this is a perfect place in Columbus. But make sure you get reservations! The last time we went, I got the Thai coconut curry tofu. My husband got the salmon. Both were absolutely delicious! Pricey, like I mentioned, but delicious so it was worth it. I'll probably be back again at some point for some special event!

Truly amazing dinners. They do seasonal fair plates and their drinks are to die for wonderful service and very intimate.

Exceptional food! The Pork Schnitzel was amazing, the sauce was delicious. The Vegetarian Naan Flatbread was so flavorful. Service was great!

We had another great experience at Henry. Try the Right Reverend to start out. The deviled eggs are fantastic. I had the Chicken Cordon Bleu and it was amazing! The staff is attentive and knowledgeable. This locally owned spot is a must do.

The food was very good and changes continuously which makes us wanting to return. The service was also very good.

Chose this restaurant because of Yelp - Food was amazing! Pork Schnitzel was excellent. Vegetarian Naan Flatbread was bursting g with flavor! Everything was fresh and flavorful- service was great!

Delicious food and finely crafted cocktails in a great setting. Excellent service. Highly recommend!

Go adventurous. The ambience is perfect for an upscale date night. The food was delicious & the drinks were uniquely crafted. Excellent burbon selection. Menu changes daily, definitely on the higher scale of price but worth it if you're looking for gourmet farm to table experience. This is the closest thing I've found to Old Town Alexandria Vibe.

Located in the quaint, yet growing Columbus, IN, Henry Social Club brought a much needed higher scale dining to the town. The interior is very modern and gives upscale. They have seating in front of the chef kitchen where you can eat and view the process. I recommend the bacon wrapped dates and can't go wrong with their steak. The best steak I've had to this day. I've gone there for company dinners, anniversaries and birthdays. Each time, very good and consistent. The service is good. They have a good variety of drink offerings from all prices. Book your next event here and you won't be disappointed. They take great pride in the food and restaurant.

Really enjoyed the food, appetizer and various authorizers. The service was awesome, and the ambience was very comfortable.

Lovely atmosphere and a menu that brings excellence with every option. Service is always spectacular and our favorite server is Evan!

Great service and cocktails. The food was good but not great. Scallops entrée was not filling at all. With 3 medium-sized scallops, there should have been more gnocchi. The bacon wrapped dates and the creme brulee were enjoyable. Would definitely return for cocktails, apps and desserts.

We had a phenomenal meal at HSC. We were lucky to sit at the chef's table. Excellent food and service. Scallops with Gnocchi and Strip Steak were delicious. Will definitely be back!

My favorite place! Best food and cocktails in Columbus by far! The staff is amazing! Great bourbon selection and craft cocktails around!

As good of quality and ambiance as you will find on the level of any major city I have dined in the country!

Great service, thanks Bryce, great cocktails and of course, great food. A gem in Columbus, thank you!!!!

Good food Good service Nice people Greeting was good and our table was ready. Drinks came quickly Nice selection of beer and wine. Charcuterie board was available and had some nice items on it. My lamb was delicious and well prepared. Schnitzel was available and was a great surprise to the others who ordered it. They loved it.

I come to Columbus once a year and it's not complete without dinner here. This time my wife was able to join me and she couldn't get enough of it. Incredible service, cocktails and food. The perfect place for a date night or anniversary dinner. Already looking forward to next year.

My husband and I went to HSC for our anniversary. We had a very enjoyable dinner. I had the filet with mushroom risotto and he had the cod. Every bite of mine was delicious. His was good, but needed a little salt according to him. The servers were very attentive. We'll definitely be back.

Wonderful service, food & drinks. Love the staff and hand crafted cocktails. Will be back.

The food here is amazing, and worth every penny. The server was very friendly, and accommodated my friend's request smoothly, when she wanted to try a different cocktail because her first choice turned out not to be to her taste. The ambiance is pleasant. Sort of a modern art deco kind of feel. I'm really looking forward to my next meal, there!

Every visit to Henry's is amazing. Great atmosphere, delicious food, and fast service. I make a point to stop every time I pass through Columbus; a few times a year. Every time has really been stellar.

Henry Social club provides a unique cozy atmosphere with the best drinks in town and amazing food!

Excellent food, great menu and good ambiance. Staff are knowledgeable and friendly . Creative cocktails

The food and service was great. I had the pork schnitzel and the others had the sea scallops. What a neat place tucked away in downtown Columbus.

I was in Columbus for work and Henry's was my go to place. Impeccable service and wonderful food. The handcrafted cocktails are perfection. Lovely atmosphere and ambiance.

Really great ambiance! Nice for conversation. My colleague and I stopped in for cocktails and appetizers! Great food, excellent service. I look forward to a return visit with my hubby sometime this year!

We had an exceptional anniversary dinner last night at Henry Social Club and look forward to more celebrations at this lovely restaurant! We reserved a table ahead through Yelp (amazing when digital tools work according to plan) and were warmly welcomed at the door by our waiter. They knew it was our anniversary from my reservation and brought two glasses of champagne- we were delighted and felt very special. Our meals were excellent. We are fans of restaurants in Indy like Vida, Tony's and Delicia. HSC felt right on par with any of those dining experiences and was, dare I say, a bit more metropolitan? I was reminded of trendy restaurants we visited while in Salt Lake City and New York City. We started with the deviled eggs and I don't think I'll be able to have deviled eggs without crispy onions moving forward. For our main course, I ordered the salmon and found new hidden flavors with each bite. It was a large portion but I cleaned my plate because it was so addictive. My partner ordered the steak and frites and he said the steak was one of the best he's had. Also a very large portion. We topped off our evening with the lemon crumble. It was a delightfully tart, fresh dessert I'll be craving all summer. I recommend this for a very fancy first date, a rehearsal dinner, adult celebration (no kids menu) or any time you need a perfectly curated meal and modern environment. 10/10.

My favorite restaurant in Columbus. Phenomenal. Excellent food and service. Highly recommend.

We have been here several times when coming from Louisville to see a concert in Brown County Music Center. The food and service has always been great!!!

The best Columbus has to offer. The food is excellent with great technique and ingredients. The service is impeccable. As casual or as formal as you prefer. It depends upon you. The ambiance is incredible. Modern furnishings and fixtures with a speakeasy feel.

Our absolutely favorite restaurant in town! The food never fails to be delicious, I love the atmosphere, and it's by far the best place for a good craft cocktail. We always get great service and have a fantastic time.

The food is outstanding with craft cocktails. Most nights you will need a reservation.

The food is phenomenal . You must try the pot de crème for dessert . I was celebrating my birthday at Henry Social club. They went out of their way to help me celebrate. I have five girl friends with me. We all enjoyed a variety of starters and entrees. Everyone loved the food . Henry Social went the extra mile on the restaurants decor. The open kitchen is beautiful

I travel for work and always try to find the small non-chain restaurants. This one is a gem. Great service and excellent food. Will definitely stop in again next time I'm in the area. The whole downtown area is very cute and wish I had more time to spend there.

Everything was delicious! We are looking forward to returning this evening. The chef's table was a treat.

Everything was wonderful. Nice quiet little restaurant. Wife and I went there for our 11th anniversary and we were not disappointed. A little pricey but food was excellent. Service was quick and polite. Thank you for a great first experience! We look forward to coming again.

Visited this restaurant while passing through, and WOW, did it make an impression. The lamb chops were a 5-star entree! Looking forward to visiting again!

Always exceptional service, food and drinks. Our favorite place to celebrate a special occasion or date night!

The lamb was amazing, as was the drinks, service, and atmosphere!! We would highly recommend-