Henry Chen
Google
Over the years we have stayed at, and trusted, Hoshino Resorts when we travelled to Japan: Hoshinoya Karuizawa several times; Hoshinoya Fuji; Kai Hakone a few times; Kai Matsumoto; Kai Atami (shame that it closed); Kai Ito and probably a few we have forgetten. We were glad to have found Kai Kaga as a new Kai to stay.
Unfortunately, the drop in service standards was palpable. When we checked in, the two reception staff barely cared how we could park our car, didn't help. Knowing that our dinner was scheduled to start in 10 minutes, the staff nonchalantly directed us to sit in the Travel Library and wait. We had to ask, "Aren't we supposed to get ready for dinner"?
Both rooms were dusty. One swipe of finger across the counter behind the bed gathered a thick layer of dust. My wife had such a serious dust allergy as a result that she had to put in a face mask in order to sleep (for both nights). Corners and edges of the bathroom floor were dirty. More amazingly, the housekeeping staff barely cleaned anything on the second day. The rubbish in the living room was not even removed.
The cause of these issues is likely the inexperienced and limited staff (still recovering from the impact of the pandemic I suspect). We reflected these issues to the hotel manager and she admitted the same. Still, we stayed at Hoshinoya Karuizawa last December (post pandemic) and did not experience such issues. If there is a staffing issue, we would have hoped that the management reduced the number of available rooms rather than lowering Hoshino's standard. It is difficult to win back lost trust.
Lastly, it is strange that Kai Kaga offers guests to use a public bath across the street (no shower, 500 yen per visit for typical guests). As Kai's are onsen resorts, the fact that its own onsens are insufficient in servicing its guests is unacceptable. We ended up not using either onsens for fear of crowding and used the onsen in our own rooms. That was a shame.