Louisa M.
Yelp
I was walking around downtown Toronto and checked Yelp, finding this highly rated coffee shop. HotBlack has a ton of fans, and I'm a coffee lover, but I was mostly disappointed in everything here.
Walking in, it's confusing how and where to order. The barista behind the counter was so friendly, which is more than I can say for the patrons. I got the total staredown like I was an outsider who didn't belong, which was really, really weird. I felt unwelcomed by the obvious regulars who were hanging out.
I ordered an overpriced traditional macchiato and a bourbon butter chocolate chip cookie. Neither of these items were good, and I would not get either of them again.
The macchiato was made with espresso beans that had fruity notes, and I'm more of a dark / cereal type of espresso lover, so this wasn't to my taste. The barista highly recommended this blend, and I was sorely disappointed. It sure did look pretty, though.
The cookie was even worse -- it was completely dried out and old, the gross kind of overcooked / slightly burned crunchy, not the yummy kind of crispy. You can see how overcooked and dry it looks in the photo. One bite and it was left uneaten.
I don't know if I was there on an "off" afternoon or what, but I was extremely disappointed in everything about HotBlack Coffee. The best thing about the place are the window seats where you can sit and people watch. Other than that, there are better places for overpriced, mediocre coffee in downtown Toronto.