Chris D.
Yelp
At the outset, the level of service at the hotel is excellent and very impressive. I would recommend this hotel to anyone visiting Seville (notwithstanding the hotel's general manager described below), but the safety hazard on the jacuzzi terraces must be conveyed to travelers and was not properly addressed during our stay, and that is the reason for the poor rating.
My wife and I were on our honeymoon and extended our stay in Seville since we loved it so much. Our previous hotel did not have a room available for the extra two nights so we booked the Penthouse Suite with jacuzzi terrace at the Gran Melia Colon. Upon arrival we were offered champagne and other refreshments at check-in and given a tour of the hotel by their very attentive staff.
After settling in we enjoyed the private jacuzzi for about an hour - as we stepped out of the jacuzzi, my wife stepped on an exposed nail on the wooden floor boards of the terrace. The nail punctured her big toe and she screamed out in pain (photos uploaded). I immediately called the front desk, and the guest relations manager promptly arrived to the room and the hotel doctor arrived shortly thereafter. Upon closer inspection of the terrace, there were no less than 10 nails exposed that could cause serious injury. The guest relations manager had the maintenance staff hammer down the nails as the doctor tended to my wife.
I asked about a tetanus injection, as the nails were rather rusted (see photo), but he said it would be unnecessary. The doctor prescribed a topical antibiotic spray and told my wife to stay off of her foot for at least 12 to 24 hours. As many of you know, no city in Spain can be enjoyed without being able to explore it on foot.
As my wife rested in bed for the rest of the night the hotel asked us what they could do about the situation - my wife and I told them that they should propose something to us rather than the other way around.
Shortly thereafter, the guest relations manager kindly offered one out of two nights free of charge. We were not satisfied with this and requested that both nights be given free of charge. We are not tourists trying to skirt the bill -- remember, this was not as if we had a bad meal, or the room was not tidy - the hotel's negligence and reckless disregard for guest safety injured my wife and we lost 18-hours of our trip to that negligence. Moreover, we were on our HONEYMOON.
The next day the guest relations manager said he had spoken with the general manager of the hotel, Margarita Gonzales, and she concluded that one out of two nights was "fair." After being disappointed with the news, I myself went back into the Jacuzzi as my wife rested and I noticed more exposed nails on the terrace that were not cleared by the maintenance staff. I asked both the guest relations manager and Ms. Gonzales to come to the room to see the nails.
Ms. Gonzales noted that my wife's wound was "superficial" and that she would be back on her feet within 12-24 hours. Unfortunately, the only thing superficial was the hotel's inspection of the terrace and the level of service and empathy by Margarita Gonzales. After saying she would get in contact with the hotel insurance to see if she could do anything more than one night, Ms. Gonzales called my wife and stated nothing more could be done. Her tone and attitude was not in line with the high level of service we experienced with everyone else at the hotel. We asked if she could at least cover the laundry we gave to the hotel in-lieu of our two-night request - she said she was unable to do so. Unable? Unlikely. Unwilling? Yes.
During our stay I contacted the U.S. Consulate in Seville and they suggested filing a police report and reviewing the hotel, we decided against a police report but felt that we must tell others of the safety issue at this hotel.
To conclude, any person thinking of staying at this hotel, PLEASE be careful on the terraces as you may find yourself seriously injured by exposed nails. The entire hotel staff was gracious and very kind to us, but Ms. Gonzales seemed to be the outlier. We both feel that she is holding this hotel back from being truly great, other high-level management should seriously reconsider her position at the hotel as this review would not have been written but-for her embarrassingly low level of service.