Hótel Flatey

I arrived in Flatey a bit tired and disoriented... Starving... I rushed to the only restaurant of the island, I was alone there, so I was also a bit stressed... Then Lily came to explain the menu, and she went literally extra miles to make me feel confortable, I felt like she was waiting for me, serving me delicious food and wine, and absolutely charming the whole lunch! It made my day, and my experience in Flatey, I absolutely enjoy the island after that. So thank you Lily, I guess you welcome a lot of people everyday, but keeping this sense of service and kindness is exceptional!!

Our stay on Flatey made for the best serene adventure. We were the first guests of the season at Hotel Flatey and the only tourists staying overnight on the island. This made for a rejuvenating solitude. It was fascinating to explore the tiny island, and imagine what life was like back in the heyday when it was a cultural epicenter. It was fascinating to imagine what life is like now, during a busy tourist season and during the dead of winter when only two farmers (who apparently have no affection for each other…) call the island home. Our room had a view that I don’t have adequate words to describe. You could throw the windows open wide (if the winds allow), and be lulled to sleep by the ocean waves (best to bring your eye mask for the midnight sun). I fully recommend the suite in the second house to you. The bed was VERY soft. I could see it being too soft for the firm bed folks - but I think you all are crazy, personally. There were two bathrooms in our building. I could see this being a unique experience to work around when there’s actually a full house. But hey, having to share amenities also creates beautiful opportunities for connection. The staff were so kind and attentive. We got to know one of the waitresses a bit, who shared some beautiful descriptions and tips that have us making plans for our next Iceland adventure. She also was kind enough to whip us up “Flajitos”- the Flatey mojito, made with pickled rhubarb. We also got to know one of the chefs, who made incredible food (mushroom soup from a recipe passed down from an Icelandic grandma?!) and also hung out and chatted with us as we waited for our departing ferry. Loved this. Give it a go. In case it’s helpful: you can’t drive your car on to the island. Instead, you have to purchase the appropriate ticket and arrange to have the ferry staff drive your car off at the other side and park it. It will be waiting for you to arrive when you make the rest of your voyage. Very slick.

Incredibly charming hotel. It's a very old renovated house, and that comes with some limitations like shared toilet, showers and sound carries between floors - but nothing to complain about. Dinner and lunch were absolutely amazing, but breakfast is pretty light. The hotel staff is incredibly lovely and helpful and I can't fault them for the service, although I would have loved to see a bit of effort from some of the staff on learning and conversing in Icelandic. ||Great hotel in a great place, highly recommend!

This review is for food and drinks only, not accommodation, based on a long, 9 hr day trip, via Baldur ferry. Super-classy restaurant and hotel, fantastic lounge bar, situated in an old-timey N-Atlantic island (think 1973 movie Wicker Man) , super-good dinner menu, great halibut and divine, fresh scallops. Drink menu during happy hour was great as well. Staff was absolutely fantastic. The surroundings were unreal, nice, sunny day, sheep roaming everywhere...really can't praise this island high enough. An absolute must, if you're staying in the Breidafjorfur area. Thank you all so much! Will definitely come back ASAP.

We loved our stay at Hotel Flatey! They will greet you at the ferry to collect your luggage and then you can take a 10 min walk across the island to the hotel. It’s in an extremely beautiful and serene location, if you are looking for a relaxing and quiet environment - be sure to stay here. The staff were so friendly and helpful and the meals were all delicious. If you have the time to stop at Flatey and spend the night here, I would highly recommend it!

A unique hotel in a unique environment! I recently stayed at this hotel for the first time and loved every minute of it. 😊👍😊 When you arrive at the island with the ferry, hotel staff is there to transport any luggage you may have, which my friend and I did. Then we walked to the hotel that is situated in what used to be the towns central square (in the old times) and arrived just in time for dinner. The rooms and bathrooms (shared) are comfy and spic span clean and the service in general very friendly. Our dinner was excellent and breakfast really nice ... although its presentation could be improved! Hope to visit soon again and totally recommend the hotel and visiting the island of Flatey.

One of the best places in the world to enjoy a day or two, just doing nothing and enjoying the nature all around you. The clock stops, but makes two "ticks" a day when the ferry boat comes. ||The hotel is simple and very nice with a very good hotel restaurant with a simple menu of the local food.

Hotel Flatey was a fantastic place to stay. The stay and the welcome were great. The rooms were super cosy and comfortable and the bathroom had lovely toilets. The butter breakfast was great too - good selection |We also ate In the restaurant - amazing food and service.