D R
Google
We recently spent five nights at Hotel Lancaster Paris to celebrate our honeymoon, having chosen it in hopes of enjoying an intimate, luxurious experience that a boutique five-star property promises. While our stay was comfortable in parts, it ultimately fell short of expectations — particularly given the hotel’s reputation and price point.
Service and Atmosphere
The overall service was courteous but lacked warmth and genuine hospitality. The staff often felt cool and somewhat defensive, which made simple requests unnecessarily complicated. For instance, when we asked for our coffee to be prepared in a particular way, it became a point of contention rather than a straightforward adjustment — even leading to the breakfast manager presenting us with different coffees in what felt like an attempt to educate us.
Additionally, we were told that the cozy booth tables at breakfast were reserved for large families — yet across six mornings, we never once saw such groups. These small but consistent experiences gave the impression that guest comfort and preference were not prioritized.
Rooms and Facilities
Our room was elegantly presented and immaculately clean, though surprisingly compact. We were also disappointed not to receive our expected Centurion upgrade, which has always been honored at other affiliated hotels. The explanation provided was that the property was fully booked due to Fashion Week — however, Fashion Week had concluded the day prior to our arrival, and the hotel did not appear to be at capacity.
Cleanliness and Dining Areas
The most unsettling aspect of our stay was witnessing a mouse on three separate occasions in the bar and dining areas. While management did offer a complimentary night as compensation, the issue persisted, ultimately leading my partner to avoid dining on the premises altogether. For a property of this caliber, this was an unacceptable lapse in hygiene and maintenance.
Spa and Guest Experience
We had also hoped to make use of the spa facilities, booking several months in advance. Unfortunately, despite our early request, it appeared that preference was given to external clients over in-house guests — another example of the hotel’s misplaced priorities.
Location
One undeniable highlight of Hotel Lancaster is its exceptional location.
Final Thoughts
Hotel Lancaster possesses undeniable charm and history, and there were glimpses of what could have been a memorable stay. However, the lack of genuine hospitality, attention to guest comfort, and several operational oversights made it difficult to view this as a true five-star experience.
While not the worst stay we’ve had, it was far from exceptional — and regrettably, we would neither return nor recommend it.