Motown D.
Yelp
We are just now finishing our first stay at Hotel L'Orologio and will be returning after three days in Siena. This hotel, our experience here, the staff, and the entire experience has been in a word... well, two words...- simply superb. If you are reading this review you are doing your due diligence, having moved beyond Trip Advisor (I don't post there) to learn more about where to stay while vacationing in Florence.
This hotel is not the most inexpensive, but if you are traveling to Florence don't nickle and dime yourself into a cheaper hotel or travel experience. We stayed in Room 501, with our own (private) patio view - and view from every room - of Il Duomo, just a few short blocks away. Want the Steak Florentine experience at Buca Lapi? It's less than two blocks away. Great Gelato from Grom? About 6 blocks from the hotel, which is right in Piazza Santa Maria Novella. Want to buy yourself or your wife a magnificent purse from the Scuola del Cuoio at the Monastery of Santa Croce (another 'must visit' destination)? A very pleasant walk of about a mile down along the Arno river. Visit Ponte Vecchio? Hotel L'Orologio is just a few short blocks away.
More about the room and the hotel: Room 501 may seem at first to be narrow and long, but it is - it boasts a living room with patio off to the side, and to the left as you enter is the bedroom and beyond that the bathroom. Well worth the daily rate. The service has been almost invisible: re-enter the room in the afternoon for a nap to compensate for a bit of jet lag, walk out and when we return the bed was once again made and crisply refinished. There's a wonderful breakfast buffet in the morning on the 4th floor with the usual fare (I'm a coffee, OJ and cereal guy so it was perfect but it offered eggs, bacon and meats/cheeses). My only nit (and this is like saying you're complaining about having to wait in line for a meeting with the Pope) is that you often have to keep re-signing up for the room wi-fi, which does seem to have a mind of its own. But who cares!
If you are looking for a memorable stay at one of the most elegant places in Florence you won't go wrong with a stay at this hotel.