Peter H.
Yelp
Lipstick On a Pig
We stayed at The Paradox in Santa Cruz for four nights, with five rooms reserved for people invited into town to join in the celebration of our 50th Anniversary.
Marriott corporation bought an old chain motel, put in some pretty furniture, slapped on the "Autograph Collection" designation and called it a "4 Star" Hotel. However...
It is a motel, not a hotel. Marriott did nothing to remodel the room configurations, so they are still the postage stamp rooms of the low-end chain, with a phone booth-sized bathroom. There are few amenities, not even a plastic shower cap that a 2 Star motel would offer, and no facility info or map in the room. The 'Fitness Center' is nowhere near that of true 4 Star hotels, with just a few treadmills, two stationary bikes with no functioning heart rate monitors and a sad little weight rack and bench. No mats, stability balls or foam rollers for stretching. The Fitness Center was not maintained, with rotten fruit sitting in a bowl for several days. 4 Star?
Customer service is a hallmark of a true 4 Star facility. Marriott has not invested in 4 Star staffing levels, so over-worked frontline workers are expected to do multiple jobs (simultaneously?).
Example: We needed pillows. I called the desk and was told they'd be 'sent up right away - stat.' An hour later with no sign of the pillows, I called the desk. No answer, except by a robot, and when I entered the 'Customer Service" number as directed I ended up in a loop where the line rang and rang before defaulting back to the robot (3X). I finally had to dress and walk down to the desk myself to get pillows. Same robot loop and no human response the next day when I called the desk with a facility inquiry.
Example: The young man in front is expected to be valet and bellman, helping move customers' luggage to their rooms. Inevitably, he is unavailable for either valet or bell service 50% of the time - two jobs Marriott corporation and local management try to cover on the cheap with one over-worked employee.
Example: My daughter and son-in-law had no air conditioning in their room, and management never made an effort to respond when informed. "Customer Service" is atrocious. Far from a 4 Star profile, "service" is maybe a weak 2 at best. Not the fault of the working staff - poor management and sufficient corporate investment are the culprits.
We have stayed at other "Autograph Collection" hotels in America and abroad. The Paradox is nowhere in the ballpark of these true 4 Star+F hotels. My advice, stay at a reputable chain with reasonable pricing, as the 4 Star prices at The Paradox are a rip-off, given the state of the facility, the poor management, and the farce that is "Customer Service. Superficially pretty. This is not a 4 Star facility. You can put lipstick on a pig; it's still a pig.