Melissa S.
Yelp
Okay, I feel bad giving I Due Fratelli only three stars, but I was a bit underwhelmed considering all the hype. After the initial bites and me going, "ooh, this is good," I ended up thinking, "so this is it?" with more than half a sandwich to go.
First of all, and maybe this is me being shy, but I initially wanted to ask the guys behind the counter for a recommendation I noticed from the people who ordered before me that they didn't interact a ton with the customers. They did, though, produce a sandwich very quickly. When it was my turn, after studying the menu very carefully while in line I decided to order the #4, which had roast pork ham (and I am leaving out a comma for a reason that I will explain below) and parsley sauce.
My first impression of the sandwich was how warm and crusty the roll was. I love me a good piece of bread, and I Due Fratelli has fantastic bread to compliment their sandwich fillings. I also have to say the parsley sauce is very tasty. Very herby with possibly a bit of raw garlic in there to give it a bit of a kick. As for the meat, I expected a slice of porchetta and a slice of ham. Bite after bite I kept thinking that maybe the pork was on the bottom of the sandwich since I clearly saw and tasted a piece of ham. Finally, I opened up my sandwich and alas, there was no other piece of meat to be eaten. Perhaps this altered my opinion of the sandwich too much, but after finding this out I merely finished my sandwich out of obligation.
So yes, I 2 Fratelli is cheap, has fantastic bread, and the parsley sauce is very flavorful. But I'd rather shell out two more euro for a panini from another place that has way more meat and fillings. Sorry, Florence.