il Castello

This was third time I ordered fettuccine Alfredo. First time it was so buttery perfect second time it was not as buttery. Third time it was completely dif taste. More like cream fettuccine. It's like each time it was made by a dif chef and they had their own idea of what it should taste like. Instead of it being consistent with what the restaurant consistent taste

First time there it was wonderful, great authentic Italian food, staff was very friendly. Great atmosphere they were not blasting out music like most restaurants in EL Poblado. I will definitely be going back.

We went for dinner with really high expectations after reading many great reviews, however, we left somewhat disappointed. We had 6pm reservations and arrived a few minutes early when one of the staff greeted us and rather unpleasantly. He refused to even allow my elderly mother to sit while we wait and made us wait outside on the street. At 6pm we were allowed in and taken to our table. Service was a little more friendly and we ordered. The pizza was really disappointing. The gnocchi and penne arrabiata were average at best. And the veal was good, however, I asked them to change the pasta side to pomodoro and surprisingly their idea of pomodoro was tomatoes and basil on dry pasta. Tiramisu was also not good. But the cannoli, while not real cannoli, was delicious. I think prices were also fair. The decor and ambiance were also very nice. I wish I liked the food more as I’d definitely be a regular customer.

By far our favorite meal in Medellin!! Pastas and salads were incredible - very high quality, and generous with ingredients and portions. Service was also fantastic, staff were hospitable and attentive throughout the evening.

Having tried Italian food twice already on my tour of Columbia I didn’t have high expectations. They were pretty grim. However this was a delight. Lovely restaurant, great and attentive staff and great food. Lasagna could have been a tad warmer but it tasted good. Great evening out. Recommend.

ABSOLUTE PERFECTION! Everything was far beyond expectation! Ambiance-5 stars! Food-5 stars! Service 100 stars!!!!! I am a 52-year-old Foodie, world traveler and former restaurant employee/manager in the United States for 12 years. I’ve lived in Medellin a year and find myself constantly frustrated by the slow service here. I recently took my gf to Tony Romas for a celebration. It’s one of the nicer restaurants in El Poblado. Service was AWFUL!!!! I wish I would’ve brought my girlfriend here for our celebration. I can’t recommend this restaurant more highly. It’s seriously the greatest combination of relaxing, upscale yet comfortable ambience combined with absolutely delicious food and cocktails and the greatest service I’ve ever had traveling in the country of Colombia for five years.

Was lucky enough to snag a seat at the bar without reservations on a very busy Saturday night. The room is bright, fresh, and lively and not overly noisy. Just happy people enjoying good food. Service was prompt, friendly, and very efficient and professional without being intrusive. A free mini pizza came as a complimentary amuse bouche, which was a lovely surprise. My Carpaccio starter was very tasty, but it had a bit too much olive oil and cheese for my preference. The Arrabieta pasta, however, was spot on! Perfectly al dente pasta with a delicious sauce that had me licking the bowl. Ok, not literally, I'm not that bad. My one quibble is the lack of options for wine by the glass. One mediocre option is not what I had expected from a restaurant of this quality. It wasn't even Italian. The bottle options were better but still somewhat limited, so I guess wine isn't really a priority. There is a full bar however, so try a cocktail.

Think this was the best italian restaurant i had in Medellin good service best pizza dough i had in my life...and this is not a joke. Check was also way cheaper then expected had to check twice if everything was charged. So good food good service and best price.