Il Pellicano Cucina Italiana

A wonderful place to eat on the island. It won't disappoint if your looking for Italian. The salami pizza was fantastic. 😋 The atmosphere is perfect too. Great music and wait staff. Get there early for dinner or you'll be waiting in line.

Another amazing meal while on the island. El Pellicano never disappoints. Salads were delicious, pastas were perfect and the key lime pie was the perfect ending. Our server Kayla was so friendly and made the meal even that more enjoyable.

Was walking down Avenida Hicaco and got directed to the restaurant. Great spot. Elegant, romantic, and great for a family too. Food was delicious and well made. My daughter thought the lasagna may have been better then her Nonna's. Foccacia and balsamic vinegar/oil was provide. My only request would be to include a small piece of foccacia with the pasta, as I needed some for my sauce.

If you love Italian food you have to eat here!!! Hands down the best lasagne I have ever had. It basically melts in your mouth. My boyfriend had the chicken Alfredo which was just as delicious. The atmosphere is lovely and romantic, lots of greenery and nice music. The servers are all extremely pleasant and attentive. Drinks were also yummy. Very well priced for what you receive. If we were going to be on the island for longer we would definitely be returning.

Very pretty restaurant with excellent Italian food! Dinner, drinks, and dessert were very tasty. Meals were a perfect portion size.

We enjoyed our smoked enchiladas immensely! The atmosphere is upscale, but the prices are moderate. The staff was amazing as they were taking care of a table of about 20 people, but still managed to be very attentive to everyone else. We were served in a timely manner. We would definitely visit again!

This was by far my favorite dining experience on Caye Caulker. The truffle mushroom pasta and seafood pasta were perfect. If I could do the days there over, I would have come back and had dinner here more nights.

Delicious Rib eye and Eggplant Parmigiana followed by Key Lime Pie while being serenaded by a good guitarist. What could be better on. Caye Caulker Saturday night? Nothing I can think of right now :-)