William M.
Yelp
The first part of this review deals with the accommodations. My wife and I, and another couple, stayed here over Columbus Day weekend. We stayed at the Edgewood, not the main Inn so these comments reflect that. They use keys, real metal keys, the kind that go into locks. For me, that's a plus. It can't get de-magnitized because it sat near a cell phone. But, unlock your door, it stays unlocked until you manually re-lock it. Gee, just like at home. The rooms were spacious, and clean. Great view over the lake. Very comfortable queen bed (they also have rooms with kings). Fridge, microwave, and coffee maker. They have wifi, very easy to use, and apparently wired connections though I didn't use that. Cell service is virtually nill, another plus for me. So, accommodations, 5 stars.
Now for the dining. Our original plan was to eat in Ithaca where we had advance reservations. But after spending the day exploring the area before check in, we thought why shlep back into town. So we called late for a reservation and they graciously slotted us in. They were busy, the Inn was filled. Their setup is an interesting concept. You buy the entree at it's price, appetizer, salad, dessert are included in that price. I had the salad & cheese plate, a fav of mine, salad w/ blue cheese, the lamb, and cheese cake. Sometimes I like having a complete meal like this. This was one of those times. It was great! The other 3 felt the same way. So, the dining room was full, late in the evening, but the food was cooked perfectly, the service attentive but not over-bearing.
Breakfast. Not my favorite but still, what I should eat. Everyone else raved about the European style fruit, light pastry, muesli, hard boiled egg, hot crepe/waffle, yogurt, juice, coffee, tea. I want meat. But the gals loved it and I should be eating healthy.
So, if you want a place from which you can explore the finger lakes, the wineries, the creameries, the arts, and the natural beauty, I recommend Taughannock Farms.