Innersleeve Records

What a fantastic store! They’ve got a deep enough selection of each genre to make a stop in worth your time regardless of where you focus your tastes or collecting. Records are are clean and every one I looked at was truly in great shape. No real bargains to be found but prices are fair and on par with Discogs low end, so it is worth buying something when you find a ln album you’re excited about. I scored about 6 beautiful old blues and rhythm&blues/jump blues records and even picked a nice Marx Brothers collection out of the free bin out front. Staff is knowledgable but laid back and non-intrusive. Highly recommend to stop in!

thank god there are still a few magical places like Innersleeve on the East End!! it's🙏🎶🪗🌌

Great shop with awesome selection. A must stop out east.

Innersleeve Records is the perfect record shop. The selection includes all genres and a few surprises. The staff is knowledgeable and relaxed, but they are also friendly and attentive. Bringing an inclusive cultural vibe to this little stretch of life on Main Street in Amagansett, Innersleeve is highly recommended for any collector or gift-finder.

Great selection of rock, jazz, and soul. Friendly staff, definitely a shop for serious vinyl heads. Would give it 4.5 stars if I could. Recommend it for sure, but make sure you love your purchases, as there are no returns.

I stopped in with my 8-year-old son because he had a specific electronic artist he wanted to see if they had on vinyl. They didn’t have it, but took the time to look it up and chat with him about it. I can’t say enough nice things about the guys working there. They both talked with my son like they would an adult, and that meant so much to him (and me!). He picked out a couple albums and they seemed genuinely interested in connecting over songs. Thank you both so much, we will be back next time we are in town!

So much positive stuff can be said about this place, but I'll try to be brief. Roomy, sunny space. Everything well organized. They're always playing cool music, and the employees all know lots about contemporary music, classic rock, jazz, and other genres. They're not snobbish at all, too! Listening station, soul/R&B section, blues section, country section, massive classic rock section, and quite simply the best selection of jazz LPs you can find on Long Island. Plenty of cool stuff on the walls, including high-dollar collectibles. Not to be missed, and definitely worth traveling to if you're in the tri-state area and want a change from cramped Brooklyn stores or disorganized and picked-over mid island stores.

Way overpriced, sadly. They have good selection but it’s pretty clear they just use the highest price on discogs sale history to price their records. No records under $20, no matter how common. Big letdown

Really cool old school store with a huge variety of vinyl records all sorted by genre. The staff was readily available to answer any questions.