Islamorada Pizza Co.

I really wanted to try a variety of slices. Unfortunately I missed it, they only offer slices from opening to 3pm. We got a whole hot honey pepperoni pizza pie, and oh my that was good. Not too spicy, not too sweet. Tasted so good after a long day of fishing. The place is clean, seems well managed and organized. Plenty of seating indoors and outdoors. Bathroom maintenance 10/10 The sodas were different from your usual coke or Pepsi, but so good!! That vanilla cram soda was delicious 😋 Thank you so much for working on thanksgiving day, we’ll definitely come back to try the rest of your menu.

Loved grabbing pizza by the slice (from 11-3) before we headed out on the water. Ended up getting the carnivore and it’s my favorite! Liked the sausage and pepperoni too. I don’t mind grease, but the pepperoni is on the greasier side if that isn’t your jam. A great quick snack or lunch!

My husband and I are so picky about our pizza and this was by far one of the best slices we’ve have!! Every bite was perfect! The dough was fluffy, the bottom was crusted to perfection, the cheese and sauce ratio was on point, and we loved all the flavors from the garlic to the pesto. They know exactly what they are doing! Will always come back! Plus the interior is clean and the cashier is a sweetheart!!

Had dinner here and omg the pizza was amazing!! We got the classic cheese add mushrooms, the baked buffalo chicken wings and a Caesar salad. Like I said earlier the pizza was amazing. It’s exactly what I look for in a pizza. A nice char on the crust and the cheese was a great cheese blend. But I have to say the baked wings were incredible. I usually don’t like baked wings because you don’t get the crisp you do from a fryer but these wings were exactly how I like them. The were crispy and the buffalo sauce was good. Just the right amount of heat. Very good Caesar salad too. I would highly recommend this place

Great pizza. There’s only one size of pizza - and it was cut into 10 pieces - so there was plenty for 2 or 3 people to share. Since it’s at a resort and the tables are big, we ended up sharing a table with another couple that we didn’t know and had a lovely time.

We've had better Pizza and wings from Papa Johns no need to say anything more about that. But here's the real kicker $104.60 for 2 pizzas and 12 chicken wings of course it ends up being a front for Three Waters Resort which is also an OVER PRICE tourist trap. And good luck placing an order over the phone, have patience it only took her 7 minutes. Save you $ go to Whistle Stop for a fraction of the price... Highway robbery literally....

I hate doing this. From out of town. We chose this place because it was close. The lady at the front was nice. The food flavor was ok. The pizza was a little overdone. I think someone asked them to redo their orders because of this. That caused a back up. From the time we ordered until we got our food was 54 minutes. You read that right. 6 minutes from an hour waiting. I overheard her telling another customer they could only cook 2 pizzas at a time? I get it’s not a conveyer system and ovens take space but of their backed up more than 30 min they should at least warn you. If it was me and my wife it wouldn’t be suck a big deal but 2 small hungry kids doesn’t help after being out all day.

Review for Islamorada Pizza Co – A Must-Try Spot in the Keys! We had the pleasure of trying Islamorada Pizza Co, the new pizza spot just outside of 3 Waters Resort in Islamorada, and it absolutely exceeded our expectations! We ordered the Carnivore Pizza, and it was phenomenal—crispy crust, high-quality meats, and perfectly portioned to feed four people comfortably. Every bite was packed with flavor, and it’s clear they use only the best ingredients. The sodas were another highlight—no high fructose corn syrup, just clean, refreshing flavors that complemented the meal perfectly. The atmosphere is laid-back and inviting, making it a great spot to kick back and enjoy good food with family and friends. Bonus for locals—they offer a discount with your ID, which makes supporting this fantastic local business even better. If you’re in Islamorada, do yourself a favor and check out Islamorada Pizza Co—you won’t be disappointed!