Murray W.
Yelp
Some friends and I came here recently for a few days for a friend's wedding. Having never been to the southern US before, I was already enjoying the flora and fauna that was a stark difference to that back home in eastern Canada; very lush and green, even when plants were barely blooming back home.
Jekyll Island definitely seems to target an older crowd. There's only a handful of things to do if you're a young family or just young - the beaches (which are gorgeous, especially Driftwood beach, although the tides greatly affect accessibility), mini-golf, the sea turtle center (which I regret missing), hiking/cycling trails, and a small water park that I caught sight of on the way in. Given a tight schedule with my groomsman obligations, I didn't get to explore the island as much as I would have wished. There's a few different golf courses, and the restaurant McCormick's at one of them really showed how many senior citizens come to the island; there were high-waisted shorts and boring golf shirts everywhere. Everywhere.
There's a handful of restaurants, but the hours aren't the best. Driftwood Bistro at Villas by the Sea is only open for dinner service, which leaves you SOL if you're staying there and want a quick breakfast or lunch without having to drive to the main part of the island, and they all shut down at 9 or 10pm. I did hear that the food at the Bistro was great though, from my fiancée and friend's wife who were able to go there, which almost makes it worse that I didn't make it there. The Grand Dining Room at the Jekyll Island Club Hotel did have a fantastic brunch though, and at a very reasonable price given the amazing location, quality of the food and high end service. Most of the business are located more centrally near the Historic District and the road to the rotary.
The tap water throughout the island is very sulphurous smelling well water, it tastes horrible and even smells bad when you're showering, so I'm not sad that we didn't go to the water park.
Definitely go for a walk around the beautiful Historic District and check out the ghost tour, which while not particularly scary, does give you a good history lesson on the island.
If you're looking for a relaxed vacation, Jekyll Island is a beautiful spot to go. However, if you're looking to have a lot of things to do at all times of day, especially if you're young, you might find yourself somewhat limited in options, especially on an extended stay.